To say that Robert E. “Bob” Colville came from humble beginnings would be an understatement.

Growing up in Manchester on the North Side, he was the first member of his family -- including his extended family -- to graduate from high school.

“He never forgot where he came from. He was a poor kid form Manchester who caught a break,” said his son, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Robert J. Colville. His father died Tuesday after a five-month battle with lung cancer.

Mr. Colville, 83, had a long tenure as police chief, county district attorney and as a judge.

Advertise with us

“Bob was an exceptional boss. Everybody called him ‘Boss’ out of respect and admiration,” said Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey Manning, who worked with Mr. Colville in the DA’s office and later as a county judge. “He was respected by everybody for his charm, his wit and his incredible common sense. He cared for everybody who worked for him, personally.”

Mr. Colville graduated in 1953 from North Catholic High School, then enlisted in the Marines during the Korean War. He rose to the rank of sergeant and served for three years, until August 1956.

He became a Pittsburgh police officer in 1961, though he didn’t always aspire to a career in the law, his son said.

“He told me that he put in with the police and fireman for a job, and the police called first,” said Judge Colville, 53, of Ross.

By 1963, Mr. Colville had graduated from Duquesne University with a bachelor’s degree in political science. He returned for several years to North Catholic High School, where he worked as a teacher while coaching the school’s football team and keeping his police job.

Advertise with us

In 1969, he completed a law degree at Duquesne and was promoted to homicide detective. Just two years later, he was named chief of Pittsburgh police.

He resigned as chief in 1975 to run for district attorney -- a precarious prospect for any political newcomer -- but most especially so for Mr. Colville, a Democrat who was challenging an incumbent without the backing of his party.

“It was risky, but he was a very fine candidate,” said Walter A. Bunt Jr., 70, of the South Side, a lifelong friend, lawyer and campaign official for Mr. Colville. “It was most unusual for an unendorsed Democrat to be successful in a primary back then.”

Mr. Colville had by that time cemented a reputation for his efforts to moderate police response in protests and racial strife and for cleaning up corruption in the department, Mr. Bunt said.

“He was most cognizant of the minority community and its needs,” when he was chief, Mr. Bunt said. “He also did away with gay raids that the police had been known for and he removed corruption and the vestiges of corruption that had existed.”

Advertise with us

After he was elected district attorney, Mr. Colville used his post to lift women and minorities into positions of power, his colleagues said.

“He was the first to make sure that minorities had a role in the DA’s office and he promoted women to major positions in the office,” Mr. Bunt said.

Growing up in Manchester with few advantages or expectations made his friend a more compassionate man, Mr. Bunt said.

“Bob was more interested in getting people treatment for drugs than sending them to jail,” he said. “As DA, he aggressively used diversion programs to remove non-violent offenders from the system so as to focus on real criminals. And, he saw Mental Health Court as a road to treatment and assistance for those suffering from mental and psychological problems.”

Claire Capristo, who had numerous roles in the district attorney’s office over the years, remembers some of the other major changes Mr. Colville made.

Advertise with us

“It was a small office when he became DA and the big thing he did was make it a full-time job, instead of having part-time prosecutors,” said Ms. Capristo, 69, of Mt. Lebanon, who recently retired as county court administrator. “Before that, it had been an ethical nightmare for monitoring conflicts. Making it a full-time position really changed the whole office.”

People sometimes underestimated her former boss -- a mistake they rarely made twice, she said.

“He really was a very special, special person,” she said. “He kept a very low profile for a prosecutor. He was always mindful of the immense power that a prosecutor has and the obligation to use it fairly, deliberately and responsibly.”

Mr. Colville also felt strongly about the blame Cardinal Donald Wuerl has received lately over his role in handling sexually abusive priests during his tenure as bishop of Pittsburgh.

Shortly after the release last month of a statewide grand jury report detailing more than 300 “predator priests” who were accused of abusing children for decades, Mr. Colville reached out to KDKA-TV reporter Andy Sheehan to set the record straight.

Advertise with us

“Please, don’t blame Cardinal Wuerl. If anyone deserves the red badge of courage, he did,” Mr. Colville told KDKA. “He came when nobody else was there.”

“Bob called from his hospital room at Allegheny General,” Mr. Bunt said. “He was dying.”

His friend felt Cardinal Wuerl was a true reformer and [Mr. Colville] wanted people to know about his work with the DA’s office in rooting out abusive priests, Mr. Bunt said. “We were the first to prosecute pedophile priests in Pennsylvania. We put two priests in jail.”

Current District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. issued a statement upon hearing of his predecessor’s death earlier this week.

“It was an honor for me to succeed Bob Colville in this office when he became a judge and the residents of this county are better off because of his dedication to public service over these many decades,” Mr. Zappala said. “The only thing more important than that for Bob was his dedication to his family and friends.”

Advertise with us

One of those friends and former colleagues was Patrick Thomassey, a defense attorney who got his start in the district attorney’s office.

“He was the ultimate gentleman,” recalled Mr. Thomassey, 70, of Monroeville. “He was a great guy.”

Mr. Colville often treated prosecutors in his office like family, Mr. Thomassey said. He told of the time Mr. Colville had a plant delivered to Mr. Thomassey’s wife when he was sent out of town for an extended time to try a case.

“I’ll never forget the note” Mr. Colville sent with the plant, Mr. Thomassey said. “It said, ‘I know you really don’t miss him, but here’s a house plant, because I know he’s away.’”

Later, while he was still away trying the same case, Mr. Thomassey had his revenge, persuading a bartender to fudge receipts for hamburgers and hotdogs.

Advertise with us

“They gave us about $20 a day to eat on, and Bob said, ‘Don’t worry about the per diem. Eat as much as you want, but I can’t pay for booze,’” Mr. Thomassey recalled with a laugh. “After awhile, he calls me and says, ‘Are you gaining weight? Because you’re eating enough hamburgers.’ But, he knew exactly what we were doing.”

In 1997, Judge Colville won a seat on Common Pleas Court, where he served until 2005 -- when he reached the mandatory retirement age of 70. In 2006, he was appointed as a senior judge to the state Superior Court, retiring in 2010.

His friend had the ideal temperament for a judge, Judge Manning said.

“I never saw him angry or saw him raise his voice in all the years I worked with him,” he said.

His son said he will miss his father’s wisdom and love.

Advertise with us

"Growing up, it was never ‘Ozzie and Harriet.’ He didn't tolerate too much nonsense. But you never, ever doubted that he loved you deeply,” he said. “He or anyone else would never have imagined that the kid from Manchester would live such an extraordinary life. And, he knew how lucky he was to live it.”

Along with his son, Mr. Colville is survived by his wife, Janet Graham Colville; other sons Michael Colville, of Oakland, G. David Donahue, of Bellevue, and Patrick J. Donahue, of Berlin, Germany; daughters Molly Colville, of Mt. Lebanon and Kathleen M. Burford, of Emsworth; a brother, Jack Colville, of Scottsdale, Ariz.; and eight grandchildren.

Visitation is from 6 to 8 p.m. Thursday and from 2 to 4 p.m. and 6 to 8 p.m. Friday at Devlin Funeral Home, Inc., 806 Perry Highway, in Ross. Mass of Christian Burial is planned for 9:30 a.m. Saturday at St. Peter Church, at Ridge Avenue and Arch Street on the North Side.

The family suggests memorial contributions to Light of Life Rescue Mission, 913 Western Ave., Pittsburgh, Pa. 15233.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.