Growing up in Pittsburgh as a Reform Jew, Marcie Kebler Alter dreamed of moving to Israel.
Eventually, after becoming an Orthodox Jew, she made the move.
As it turned out, most of Ms. Alter’s time in Israel was spent in a Catholic hospital in Jerusalem. After a failed brain surgery, she was left almost completely paralyzed and lived more than a decade in the St. Louis French Hospital. But her faith continued to be central to her life, and she remained immersed in her Jewish community.
Ms. Alter died on April 17 at the age of 52 in Jerusalem. She was buried in a cemetery on a hill overlooking the Old City.
Born Sept. 17, 1965, to a Reform Jewish family in Point Breeze, she was the daughter of Arthur Alter, a chemical engineer for Gulf Oil Corp., and Tema Alter, who worked at their synagogue, Rodef Shalom Congregation in Shadyside.
Marcie Alter came from a large, close extended family, said a cousin, Lynetta Neft of Moon.
“We always had big family dinners” at Ms. Alter's grandparents’ house, Ms. Neft said. “She was always full of fun, always smiled a lot. She was a mischievous one.
As a child, Ms. Alter loved family history, said her brother, Howard Alter, of Fairfax, Va.
“She liked collecting stories about family history, and pictures. She was doing family trees long before there was all that DNA stuff that people use now,” he said.
“All our family was in Pittsburgh, on both sides,” Mr. Alter said.
Their grandmother owned Kleber’s Luggage, and the family at one point held the patent for dress hangers, Mr. Alter said.
Ms. Alter loved animals, including the family dog. Ms. Neft repeatedly brought up Ms. Alter’s beloved dog Comet, a mutt, or a “Heinz-57,” as Ms. Neft called it.
Mr. Alter recalled that his sister went every year to Camp Deer Creek in Cheswick, first as a camper, then as a counselor.
“She was very into teaching the kids arts and crafts,” Mr. Alter said. “That was one of her passions.”
Ms. Alter attended Winchester-Thurston School and graduated from Blair Academy, a boarding school in New Jersey. She then studied writing at the University of Pittsburgh and desktop publishing at the Art Institutes.
Ms. Alter worked as a graphic designer and made several trips to Israel. She had a son, Ben Alter, whom she loved deeply, her family said.
“She would do anything in the world for him,” Ms. Neft said.
“She made sure he got to spend lots of time with his grandfather and with my family,” Ms. Neft said. “She made sure he had a Jewish connection.”
In 2003, shortly after she began practicing Orthodoxy, Ms. Alter “made aliyah” to Israel, as her family put it in the Zionist terminology; “aliyah” means “ascent” in Hebrew. She worked on a kibbutz, a collective, agricultural community.
Her son, Ben, too, made aliyah, and served in the Israeli military. He now lives in Neve Daniel, a settlement in the West Bank.
Only three years after her arrival in Israel, Ms. Alter went to a doctor with numbness in a leg and was diagnosed with a cavernous angioma — malformed blood vessels — and bleeding in the brain. She had four surgeries over the next several years, Mr. Alter said, with only some success. The bleeding stopped, but she was left 99 percent paralyzed.
Ms. Alter could not speak or eat or move her limbs, but her higher brain functions were completely intact. Mr. Alter described visiting his sister when she was first paralyzed and only being able to communicate by pointing at letters on a wall and watching her eyes.
“Communication was extremely hard,” he said.
After “roughly five to seven years,” according to her brother, Ms. Alter was fitted with a computer that she could control with the slight amount of head movement she had access to.
“It opened up a whole world,” he said. “She had been literally locked up for years.”
That period was difficult, Mr. Alter said.
“It was because of her faith that she was able to keep going,” he said.
Before moving to Israel, Ms. Alter adopted Orthodox Judaism.
“It was the best decision she could have made. It prepared her for challenges later in life,” Mr. Alter said.
“She never wanted to give up,” Ms. Neft said. “She always had a smile on her face.”
There was a group of around 20 women who each month planned visits with Ms. Alter, her brother said.
“They would send around a spreadsheet and all mark the times when they would stay with her. She was constantly getting visitors,” he said.
With her community, she celebrated Jewish holidays in her room and studied the Torah regularly, he said.
“She couldn’t participate a whole lot other than acknowledge, but it was obvious from her eyes that she was paying close attention and listening very closely,” he said.
Once Ms. Alter had the computer, she was able to keep in touch with family more easily through email and Facebook. Ms. Neft talked about crying at pictures of Ms. Alter’s ailing mother, Tema, Ms. Neft’s first cousin, at Ms. Alter’s bedside in Jerusalem. Mr. Alter arranged two trips for his mother.
Ms. Alter also co-wrote a cookbook in the hospital.
“She compiled this collection of recipes while in an essentially vegetative state. It’s a cookbook written by someone who hadn’t had a meal in seven or eight years,” Mr. Alter said.
“Chanukah Highlights (My Favorite Food Is Birthday Cake)” was self-published as a Kindle e-book in 2014.
Ms. Alter’s son married, and he and his wife, Belle, have two sons, Adir Shaked and Oziel Sagiv.
Much of Marcie Alter’s communication with her family in the United States was about her family, her brother said.
“She posted how proud she was of her son and her daughter-in-law,” Ms. Neft said.
In the last months of her life, Ms. Alter had some signs of recovery, including regaining feeling in her arms and legs.
In addition to her son, brother and grandsons, Ms. Alter is survived by another brother, Howard Alter of Fairfax, Va.
Christopher Huffaker: 412-263-1724, chuffaker@post-gazette.com, or on Twitter @huffakingit.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.