If Dave Goodrich were writing this, he would walk it down to the office, typewritten on yellowish paper, and there would be at least one pithy line in it. He would read it aloud, and with a sly grin and pushing up his taped-together glasses, he would say, “Huh? Do you like it?”
And, yes, invariably, we would like it.
Mr. Goodrich, who died Sunday on the North Side of a heart attack at 72 while waiting for a bus, was one of those indelible Pittsburgh eccentrics, his specialty being music. In fact, one could argue he was the greatest music fan who ever walked Pittsburgh’s streets.
For starters, Mr. Goodrich could claim to be one of the few people to have seen both the Beatles and Rolling Stones in their first visits to Pittsburgh in 1964. That was about five years into his concert-going life.
Mr. Goodrich was an award-winning music critic (he wrote reviews for the Post-Gazette) and historian who documented the history of Pittsburgh performances in a 1985 book called “Key to the City: Volume 1, 1928-1954: A Guide to Pittsburgh Music, History, Entertainment & More!” There is a second volume, never published, somewhere in his apartment on the North Side, where he recently moved after living for decades at the Edison Hotel, Downtown. He did the books there for almost 40 years.
If you walked into one of Pittsburgh’s indie record stores — Jim’s, Eide’s, Jerry’s — any time from the ‘70s until last month, chances are you encountered Mr. Goodrich, generally hanging near the counter, talking to clerks about music. He was the guy in the long black overcoat and trucker cap that covered his greasy graying hair.
“Dave would spend hours in my shop talking about music,” says Jim Spitznagel, who owned Jim’s Records from the late ‘70s to the ‘90s. “Mostly the history of music in Pittsburgh, but he was interested in all sorts of music... from doo-wop to punk. Every time he stopped by he had a new music fact or bit of information.”
“Dave was always great to talk to outside the Stanley Theatre backstage door back in the day,” says Ed Traversari, who spent decades working for concert promoter DiCesare-Engler Productions. “He was always our ‘go to’ if we needed some artist history.”

“I got to know Dave during the late ’70s via Jim's Records,” says Mike Kolesar, a Pittsburgh drummer. “When I started shift work at Weirton Steel in 1981, I'd call him around midnight at the Edison and we'd talk until dawn before I started night turn, in order to get my sleep pattern adjusted.”
Post-Gazette columnist Brian O’Neill wrote of a visit to Mr. Goodrich at the Edison Hotel, “Goodrich, mustachioed and shaggy-haired, looks a little like David Crosby after a crash diet, and he can answer the who-played-where questions like nobody south of God. In a typical sentence, Goodrich tells me that Strawberry Alarm Clock, the one-hit-wonder that sang ‘Incense and Peppermints,’' played Heinz Hall when it was the Penn Theater, and included guitarist Ed King, who later played for Lynyrd Skynyrd.”
Mr. Goodrich, an only child, born in Venezuela while his parents were working for Gulf Oil, attended his first concert in 1959 when he was 14. It was Dick Clark's Cavalcade of Stars at the Syria Mosque in Oakland with Lloyd Price, Duane Eddy, Annette Funicello and more.
"The whole rock 'n' roll thing was still very new and even though these were mainstream white acts, there was a sense of the underground to it," he told the PG. "I was a Duane Eddy fanatic. I'd siphon off 20 percent of my lunch money and put it toward a single . . . My parents were not exactly pro-rock 'n' roll. When I'd watch ‘American Bandstand’ they'd look over my shoulder and see that it wasn't as wicked as they might have thought. I was surprised that they agreed to take me to the show that night.”
Needless to say, he was hooked for life, and from there, he rarely missed a show of any significance. Not only could he tell you who he saw 40 years ago, but he could rattle off every opening act on the bill.
And not only did he see the Stones and the Beatles, but he would note that they were the second and third parts of the British Invasion here.
“You have the Dave Clark Five at the Arena in June," he told the PG. "You have the Rolling Stones at West View Park in the middle of June. And then you have the Beatles in September."
Of that Beatles show, he said, “They played for about a half an hour. And you had to listen carefully [over the screaming] to figure out what songs were being played.”
Mr. Goodrich was in college, in Ohio, at the time, and in the late ‘60s he was in the Marine Corps, stationed in San Francisco, where he got to witness that psychedelic scene developing.
After his service, he returned to Pittsburgh. In a tribute, longtime Pittsburgh music writer Rex Rutkoski wrote, “When I first met him, his day job was in, I believe, public relations for a large Pittsburgh corporation, wearing his three-piece suits on the job. He experienced some personal family and relationship problems, I recall, and he eventually gravitated to jobs that just allowed him to survive.”
He became a manager at the Edison Hotel, where he lived and worked for 38 years. His room, of course, was filled with clippings and memorabilia, an archive of Pittsburgh’s music history. He was stubborn about not owning a computer, which went hand in hand with him never driving - getting around instead by foot, bus and bumming rides.
“He was a rebel,” says Albert Bortz, owner of the Edison Hotel and Blush. “He wouldn’t go to the doctor’s office, he never applied for social security, he didn't even have any ID, for god’s sake.”
One of his all-time favorite Pittsburgh groups was Gravel, the country-rock band that became Corbin-Hanner. In 1977, three members of Gravel, under the name The Four Swallows, released a 45 of his country song “(Lord Knows) I Don’t Need Anita,” protesting Anita Bryant’s homophobic comments. It ended up getting played on WDVE.
“It was a case of making something really fast and having it turn out better than you thought,” says Dave Hanner. “And it was really ahead of its time in terms of the subject matter.”
Twenty years later, he worked with Mr. Hanner and singer Donna Groom on a collection of songs called “Hymns from Ground Zero.”
“It was a lot of material inspired by what went on at the Edison,” Mr. Hanner says. It went unreleased, but Mr. Hanner says it’s good stuff that he has somewhere in his files. Mr. Goodrich paid one of the musicians with two fistfuls of Susan B. Anthony silver dollars.
In 1991, Mr. Goodrich won a Golden Quill for “Modern Living,” a story published in In Pittsburgh Newsweekly.
For decades, his biggest musical interest was rising country/folk/bluegrass artists, like Alison Krauss, Rosie Flores and Maria McKee, and he reviewed their albums for the Post-Gazette.
“He would lose interest when they became famous,” says Jerry Weber, the well-known founder of Jerry’s Records. “His fun was finding something and bringing it to me that no one knew about.”
As a music consumer, he says, “The records he would buy were so obscure, nobody would even want them, so I gave them to him.”
According to Mr. Weber, for the few years Mr. Goodrich would spend hours at Jerry’s on Saturdays poring over a special project he was working on.
“He was writing an epic poem about Pittsburgh entertainment: everybody big, entertainment related, from Pittsburgh or who came to Pittsburgh. He had like seven notebooks with about a thousand couplets.”
Mr. Weber says it was great, and jokes that “it would appeal to about 500 people in the country -- and all of them are from Pittsburgh.”
We learned of his passing in an email from Justin Fabus, a country artist from Dormont who is signed to the Universal Music Group.
He wrote, “I had the honor of going to the school of Dave Goodrich’s music history for three years when I worked with him as a young 19-year-old at The Edison Hotel. He taught me everything from Hank Williams to T. Graham Brown to Warren Zevon to The Eagles. Dave was a musical encyclopedia and one of the kindest guys out there.”
As Pittsburgh legend Billy Price put it, “He knew more about Billy Price than I do.”
“I dearly miss him,” Mr. Bortz says. “I’m sorry I couldn’t say goodbye to him and tell him I love him. I appreciate everything he did. I hope he went to heaven, because he was a good soul.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.