Friends and even most family assumed that Herman Mitchell's bid to become a police officer just hadn't worked out. He started at the academy in late 1958, attended classes for a while — but months later, in early 1959, there was no uniform, no badge, no shiny shoes.
Maybe, at age 27, he could go back to painting, cooking or selling sweepers. Too bad, huh?
Then came the bust — 11 drug dealers rounded up, thanks to federal agents and a young guy named Mitchell who had been plucked straight from the academy and put into an undercover role. The Certificate of Commendation credited the new officer with "seriously impairing" a drug network.
Only then did he let on that he’d made the cut.
He would go on to become a Pittsburgh Bureau of Police commander and a key figure in efforts to add diversity to the force and build bridges to schools and neighborhoods. Cmdr. Mitchell remained a community fixture well into his 80s, until thyroid cancer felled him — though it did not stop him from singing with his friends from the Rodman Street Missionary Baptist Church into his final days.
Cmdr. Mitchell, who lived in East Liberty, died Nov. 16 at age 86.
The son of a postman and a stenographer who also volunteered for the elderly, Cmdr. Mitchell was a strong voice from his days at Allegheny High School, where he directed the choir and participated in glee club. After graduation, he joined the army, serving in El Paso, Texas, in the early 1950s.
There, during a haircut, a barber recommended a restaurant around the corner. The young soldier didn't know that the barber was directing business to his sister, the cook.
But the conspirators got more than they bargained for when the soldier tasted Franzelle C. Mitchell's rice pudding, loved it, fell for her, married her and brought her back to Pittsburgh after leaving the army as a corporal.
After working a series of jobs and then making his splash undercover, he rose through the police department ranks, reaching upper management in the early 1980s. He didn't want to be one of the few minorities to make it up the ladder.
So he and others sued the city to invalidate hiring practices that had long resulted in a disproportionately white, male force. As a result, the bureau for a time hired equal numbers of whites and African Americans, men and women.
"He was always proud of that. Extremely proud," said daughter Karen D. McNeal, who followed him into the police bureau, as did daughter Frances N. Noel. Both remain in Pittsburgh.
They followed his lead because of the way he carried his public power and responsibility.
"His shoes were so shiny. Everything was perfect," said Officer McNeal. "Take that hat off, smile, hello, put that gun away, and it was done." After the obligatory family dinner, he'd often suit up again, for community meetings. "When he went out that door, he was a distinguished, bigger-than-life person."
A teetotaler, Cmdr. Mitchell recognized the scourge of addiction. He worked with the Pittsburgh Public Schools, where his wife taught home economics, to get anti-drug education to the students. He was the city's original Officer Friendly.
He also saw the deepening divide between police and minority residents, and became a public advocate for community-oriented policing.
He made the time to share his singing talents with his eight children. "He had us listening to opera from early on," said Officer Noel. "Our favorite record that we listened to all the time was ‘The Alamo,’" the score from a 1960 film. "We were so well versed, he was sure we'd be on Broadway."
His flair for drama didn't end there. On Christmas Eve, there would be little sign of festivities when the kids went to bed. By the time they woke in the morning, there would be a fully trimmed tree, all the right gifts, and a half-empty cup of milk complete with the cookie crumbs Santa must have dropped.
In 1988, he won a Jefferson Award for Public Service for his effort raising $50,000 for the Lemington Home for the Aged. He went on to be a perennial judge for the national community service award program. He also helped to establish the Eva P. Mitchell Residence for the elderly, named for his mother.
Cmdr. Mitchell served on the boards of Renewal Inc., the Allegheny County Jail and the Program to Aid Citizen Enterprise. He worked briefly as a tipstaff for Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Eugene Scanlon and picked up occasional small film roles.
When his wife grew ill, he shouldered many caregiver duties until she died in 2006. He married again last year, to Dorothy (Wells) Mitchell.
Cancer didn't dim him, even as he got hospice care at home and received a stream of family and friends. He died quietly and peacefully, surrounded by family a week before Thanksgiving.
"He really wanted us to feel that he was not fearing his fate," said his daughter Elizabeth Mitchell, a doctor of pharmacy living in Dallas.
Cmdr. Mitchell also is survived by sons Herman M. III of Albuquerque, N.M., and Arthur E. Mitchell, of Philadelphia; and daughters Gwendolyn Mitchell and Eleanor McKissick, both of Pittsburgh, and Greta Roberts of District Heights, Md.; 24 grandchildren and 11 great-grandchildren.
Family will receive guests from 4-8 p.m. Sunday at Rodman Street Missionary Baptist Church. The funeral on Monday at 11 a.m., in the church's sanctuary, will be followed by entombment with military honors at Allegheny Cemetery.
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.