There was a time when Florence Shields didn’t think that she was cut out for a life of full-time service to God and community, but when that passed, she hurled herself into the sisterhood and a series of educational roles that drew on both her clear eye and her warm heart.
Known to students and co-workers from here to California as Sister Carita, the name she took with her final vows, she reached an educational pinnacle as principal of schools associated with Holy Cross Catholic Church in Youngwood, Holy Innocents Parish in Sheraden and St. Therese Parish in Munhall. Sister Carita earned her bachelor’s degree from Seton Hill College, a master’s in education from the University of Pittsburgh and a master’s in school counseling from Duquesne University.
After earning the guidance degree, she became freshman guidance counselor at Seton-La Salle High School through 1994, after which she continued to work in finance for the Sisters of Charity of Seton Hill through last week.
“She always had time to take care of other people, in a beautiful, loving way,” said Sister Eileen Johnston, a friend to Sister Carita for 50 years who also worked a stint as principal of the St. Therese School.
Sister Carita died Sunday at 82.
The fourth of six children of Hugh and Flora (Desmond) Shields, Sister Carita was raised in Swissvale by a family that later set deep roots in Munhall. She entered the order in 1952 but left a year and a half later.
“She was tired. That’s what she said,” recounted Sister Brigid Marie Grandey, associate principal at Seton-La Salle, who entered the order with Sister Carita and later periodically worked and lived with her. “We all worked hard. But she worked harder. ... She got some distance and was able to discern that the community was where she belonged.
“She would say that the hound of heaven pursued her and so she came back to the community.”
That return to the community was made easier by Mother Claudia Glenn. In 1963, when Sister Carita was asking to make her final vows, she wrote to Mother Claudia, superior general of the Sisters of Charity: “If you hadn’t been so gentle and kind, I don’t know if I would have had the courage to return.”
She brought a similar gentleness to a series of roles in education — starting at schools in California and Arizona — that also required toughness.
Brian Tomasic, a sales leader living in West Mifflin who coaches at St. Therese and attended the school in the 1980s, had the plum student job of setting marker flags around the playground. “She noticed that me and a friend were taking our good old time putting the flags out,” Mr. Tomasic said. “She said that shouldn’t take 20 minutes. ... The next day I was replaced.
“I learned that lesson,” and was better for it, he said, adding that the principal was no knuckle-rapper. “She was more of a nurturing leader of the school that made the first grade and second grade kids pretty comfortable. And she provided some latitude for the adolescent and older kids to grow.”
For Thanksgiving, Sister Carita usually hosted those of her brothers, sisters and 16 nephews and nieces who were in town. At such gatherings, her legend blossomed.
“Her place had to be spick and span,” said her brother Terry Shields, who retired this year as assistant sports editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. “Somehow, it kept growing each year, the myth. ... It got to where she was washing floors when she was 4 years old.”
When the sisters celebrated her jubilee — her 50th anniversary in the order — “the nuns gave her a new bucket and a new mop,” Mr. Shields said.
Shining brighter than the floors was the love. When another nun was suffering from Parkinson’s disease, Sister Carita “would come every single morning just to fix her hair so she would look nice for the day,” Sister Eileen said.
She nursed her mother while running the school at St. Therese. And as her biological sister Kathleen Walter battled muscular dystrophy, Sister Carita was there for her, too, and for her son.
In addition her brother Terry, she is survived by sister Mary Lou Kost of Kennedy, and was preceded in death by brother Hugh “Bud” Shields and sister Betty Lydon.
Visitation will be 2 to 7 p.m. Thursday and Friday and the funeral 7 p.m. Friday at Caritas Christi Motherhouse in Greensburg.
Memorial contributions can be made to Sisters of Charity, DePaul Center, 144 DePaul Center Road, Greensburg, PA 15601.
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.