Gary Zimmerman was a fighter — whether in the courtroom or on the soccer pitch. He thought everyone should view the world as he did through a liberal lens, and he made sure they knew it — in a charming and convincing manner.
With a penchant for swearing and a gleam in his eye, he practiced law in Pittsburgh and across the country for more than 40 years. He also continued playing soccer as a defender with men half his age until recently.
“Could you treat your body less like a bowling ball?” his wife, Jane Moriarty, asked after Mr. Zimmerman continued to sustain broken bones and bruises into his 60s.
“This ain’t tiddlywinks, Jane,” he retorted.
“I never met anyone with a greater appreciation for being alive,” she said.
Mr. Zimmerman, of Shadyside, died Wednesday from complications following surgery at UPMC Presbyterian. He was 75.
He grew up in Sykesville, Jefferson County, and left college to join the Army in the late 1950s. He served in Germany and returned to Pittsburgh, finishing college before going to work as a private investigator.
Mr. Zimmerman went to law school only after a friend made him a bet that he couldn’t get in, his wife said. He attended Duquesne University’s night program while raising three children.
“He loved being in the courtroom, putting up a fight and putting the government through its paces,” said Ms. Moriarty, a law professor at Duquesne.
Judge Jeffrey A. Manning of Allegheny County Common Pleas Court, who befriended Mr. Zimmerman 42 years ago when he was an assistant district attorney and Mr. Zimmerman worked in the public defender’s office, said his friend was a character.
In 1974, Mr. Zimmerman represented Stanley Hoss, who had previously been convicted of killing a Verona police officer and was then charged with killing a corrections captain at Western Penitentiary.
As court was ending for the week one Friday during trial, Mr. Zimmerman casually mentioned to the district attorney that on the coming Monday he planned to present evidence of his client’s extra Y chromosome. The prosecutor and his team spent their entire weekend researching the condition and found experts to call to rebut the expected testimony.
On Monday, when court resumed, the DA said to Mr. Zimmerman that he was prepared to counter anything he would present on the extra Y chromosome.
“Gary looked at him and said, ‘What the hell is an extra Y chromosome?’ and rested his case,” Judge Manning said. “He was irascible, undeterred, robust.”
Ms. Moriarty described Mr. Zimmerman as strongly principled and kind.
“He was never afraid of the power of the government,” Ms. Moriarty said. “It was his job to be the strong defender of the Constitution and an individual’s liberty.
“He tackled everything with vigor.”
In addition to his love of soccer, Mr. Zimmerman enjoyed competitive running and skiing — though he didn’t learn the latter until he was 50. He was competing into his early 70s on double black diamond and moguls courses, and in his youth had a pro baseball tryout with the Philadelphia Phillies as a shortstop, Ms. Moriarty said.
As a defense lawyer, Mr. Zimmerman was among the first to challenge federal sentencing rules that set the penalty for crack cocaine higher than that of powder cocaine. He argued that the penalties, which were more severe for those selling crack cocaine, were racially biased.
Eventually, Congress agreed, and the penalties were changed in 2010 and applied retroactively by the U.S. Sentencing Commission the next year.
Mr. Zimmerman handled more than 95 homicide cases, and throughout his early career traveled the country, taking on huge drug cases.
Ms. Moriarty remembers the story of one drug case in which Mr. Zimmerman’s clients were caught on an airplane runway in Oklahoma with several tons of marijuana. He got a not-guilty verdict.
Mr. Zimmerman loved spending time with his family, and he and Ms. Moriarty enjoyed taking their grandchildren on what they called “spy adventures.” Just three weeks ago, Mr. Zimmerman took his 10-year-old grandson, Aaron, with him to the gym to teach him some self-defense moves. He called it, “Pop-Pop’s Fight Club.”
Mr. Zimmerman also was generous to his colleagues.
He did not hesitate when they asked him questions about the law, or sought his help in their own matters, said attorney Stephen Begler, who shared an office with Mr. Zimmerman for about 20 years.
When fellow lawyers had issues before the disciplinary board, Mr. Zimmerman would help them navigate through them. He didn’t get paid, Mr. Begler said.
“He did it for the love of the profession,” Mr. Begler said.
In addition to his wife of 28 years, Mr. Zimmerman is survived by three daughters, Lisa Krackow of Point Breeze, Amy Haldane of Seattle and Kat Zimmerman of Denver; as well as three grandchildren.
McCabe Brothers Funeral Homes in Shadyside is handling arrangements. A memorial service will be held this month with time and location to be announced.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com or 412-263-25620.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.