The Rev. Thomas E. Smith — known as the Singing and Dancing Priest for taking to the altar by day and the footlights by night, bringing his Broadway-seasoned “theatrical evangelism” from local parish halls to the TV studios of David Letterman and Phil Donahue — died Monday at 90.

The retired priest from the Diocese of Pittsburgh, who had been suffering from heart failure, spent his last years at his family’s homestead in Level Green, Westmoreland County, after earlier retiring to Florida.

“You don’t dance your way into heaven,” said “Father Tom,” as he was known. “You enter heaven through love — but you can get love through dancing.”

Born Sept. 15, 1924, he was raised in Pitcairn. He began to take dance lessons and joined the local church boys’ choir. He put aside early thoughts of the priesthood after high school and set off for the Broadway of the early 1940s. He landed a part with the Ziegfeld Follies behind its star, Milton Berle, and later a lead role at Billy Rose’s Diamond Jubilee Horseshoe Night Club.

Advertise with us

But he sensed the loneliness of the city whenever a show’s run ended and its family-like cast disbanded. He turned down a Hollywood opportunity and entered St. Vincent Seminary in Latrobe. He was ordained in 1951 at St. Paul Cathedral in Pittsburgh.

As for show business, “he thought he had put that aside,” said his friend the Rev. Sam Esposito.

But Father Smith was soon organizing musical and theatrical shows with parish youths and eventually returned to the stage himself.

Accessorizing his clerical garb with a top hat and cane, he would use his considerable tap-dancing skills — and less considerable singing abilities — to do a variety of Broadway standards, religious songs, original compositions and mildly irreverent parodies. (One sample: “A tisket, a tasket, I love that wicker basket.”)

He performed in parish halls, dinner theaters and conference centers, helping parishes raise funds while also, he hoped, spreading far more evangelistic seeds than he could sitting at the rectory “waiting for someone to ring the bell.”

Advertise with us

“I’m trying to bring the message of love to all men,” he once said. “I think the stage is uniquely adapted to doing this. Show business can be sacred if it opens men’s hearts to one another.”

When he performed on Mike Douglas’s daytime television show, the host asked if he was supposed to be wearing such hip clerical garb. “I don’t go along with a ’supposed to’ life,” he replied. Yet it was then-Bishop John Wright in the 1960s who approved his theatrical evangelism, Father Smith later said.

Father Esposito said he would remember Father Smith for “his joy for life. One of his shows was called ’Say Yes to Life.’”

For a while, Father Smith enlisted Father Esposito and other priest friends to perform at a dinner theater in Westmoreland County as “The Four Fathers,” often packing the house. They later took the show on the road for benefits.

Father Smith also developed shows with Catholic youth and for children and adults with disabilities.

Advertise with us

Onstage, he paid tributes to “Saint Fred Astaire” and local “Saint Gene Kelly.” He was written up in Parade Magazine. In an interfaith foray to the Borscht Belt in the Catskills, he reported receiving a “kneeling ovation” from Jackie Mason.

Even his preaching had a theatrical element, said his sister Carol Mock.

“He used to get ovations for his homilies,” she said. “They were all about love and affirmation.”

Father Smith served various parishes, including ones in New Castle, Roscoe and McKeesport.

After retiring from full-time work, he moved to Altamonte Springs, Fla., where he continued his sacramental and his theatrical ministries. He returned home in 2004 and helped at St. Maurice Church in Forest Hills and St. Bernadette Church in Monroeville.

Advertise with us

He was the brother of Dorothy O’Reilly, Donald Smith, Doris Della Piazza, Ms. Mock and the late Gilbert Smith and June Mitlo. He also is survived by many nieces and nephews.

Visitation will be today from 2-4 and 6-8 p.m. at the Jobe Funeral Home and Crematory in Monroeville and Thursday from 4-7 p.m. at St. Bernadette in Monroeville, followed by Translation Vespers. Mass of Christian Burial is scheduled for Friday at 11 a.m. at St. Bernadette.

 Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com