In the days of the Balcony, the upstairs Walnut Street jazz club, Robert Smith would often be there digging his favorite genre, sometimes with his son, Ben, who remembers his father as "a kind of romantic, sentimental in a good way."

Mr. Smith, of Point Breeze, a city attorney under three mayors, died Sunday of lung cancer. He was 64.

Described by professional friends as an old-school attorney, Mr. Smith served the city for 21 years until 1992, when he went into private practice as a litigator.

Ira Weiss, who met Mr. Smith when they argued on opposite sides of the transit strike in the early 1990s, said, "He was a premier trial lawyer in a quiet way.

Advertise with us

"It was never Bob, it was always Robert," said Mr. Weiss. "He was very tenacious and had very high standards, an old-school lawyer. He was unfailingly courteous, believed the legal profession was an honorable one and was extremely active in the Academy of Trial Lawyers."

Mr. Weiss called it "the supreme irony" that Mr. Smith died before he could begin serving as the academy's president in the fall.

"Any young lawyer who wanted to know how they should practice law, try a case and treat their colleagues and judges should have followed him around," Mr. Weiss said.

As fellow grandfathers with offices in the same Downtown building, Mr. Weiss and Mr. Smith often swapped grandchildren stories, and Mr. Weiss saw his friend quite choked up after going through the receiving line for the three police officers who were killed in Stanton Heights in April.

"He was sentimental," said Mr. Weiss. "He had a lighthearted side and a sharp wit" with an appreciation for New Yorker cartoons and "an enviable tie collection" that included a panda bear tie and a tie of rabbits coming out of hats.

Advertise with us

"He was a lot more fun-loving than a lot of people realized," said Mr. Smith's 31-year-old son, Ben Smith, of Harrisburg. "He was open to anything" as a lover of art and music, particularly fond of the music of Oscar Peterson, Bill Evans, Wes Montgomery and Ella Fitzgerald.

After visits with his children, he would write them notes "saying how much fun he had and how he loved meeting our friends," his son said. "He nurtured my interests even when he disagreed with me.

"He would make a toast to you if you were home from college or after you graduated. He always realized how special everything was, how you don't get the same opportunities again and that life is fleeting."

Ilisabeth Bornstein, Mr. Smith's 35-year-old daughter who lives in Easton, Mass., said her father "helped my daughter learn to ride a tricycle on her third birthday, and tremendously enjoyed playing ball with my son and having my son knock him over as they played together on the carpet."

She said she has gotten many calls from childhood friends wanting to share their memories of her father and the impression he left on them.

Advertise with us

"He always wanted to talk with them," she said. "He asked them questions. There were conversations on the porch. My male friends said that when he spoke with them it was like a man-to-man conversation. He always was genuinely into my friends and treated them with a lot of respect."

Nancy Tapper Smith said that her husband's interest in others was evident when he was a student at Morningside Elementary and carried books for her cousin, who had polio.

A graduate of the University of Pittsburgh School of Law, Mr. Smith handled more than 300 cases as chief trial counsel for the city. During his career, he represented the city school district as an insurance litigator and was a principal at Smith Cohen & Mork.

In addition to his wife and children, Mr. Smith is survived by a brother, Arthur J. Smith of Point Breeze, and two grandchildren.

Services will be held at 2 p.m. today at Rodef Shalom Temple, 4905 Fifth Ave. Visitation begins there at 12:30 p.m. Interment will be at West View Cemetery of Rodef Shalom Congregation.