Dr. Carl Marnatti, the former chief of family medicine at the Western Pennsylvania Hospital, was "a country doctor in a city," said his daughter, Judith Weakland.
When patients couldn't pay the four or five dollars he charged for house calls in the 1970s, he would accept pies, jars of jam and cookies in lieu of payment.
" 'They couldn't afford it, but they're sick,' " Mrs. Weakland recalled her father saying.
Dr. Marnatti, who worked for West Penn for nearly four decades as a family doctor, died of a brain tumor Tuesday in San Antonio, where he had lived since he moved from Pittsburgh seven years ago. He was 73.
The son of a coal miner and a maid, Dr. Marnatti grew up in Brockway, Jefferson County. His mother, Esther, who worked for doctors ironing their shirts and scrubbing their office floors, pushed him into medicine, telling him that she wanted see him be a doctor rather than work for one.
He joined West Penn Hospital after graduating from University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine in 1961.
It was at West Penn where he met his wife, Patricia, when she came to get a physical from him in 1964. When he called two days later, she worried it was because there was something wrong, but instead he asked her to a movie.
She said the move was surprisingly bold for a man that was, in spite of his man talents, typically unassuming and quiet. His wife called him "my Renaissance man."
Outside of his job, he loved model trains and was so handy that he would occasionally retool motors from his daughters' old toys to be used in trains. A whole room in his Squirrel Hill home was dedicated to his hobby.
In addition to being good with his hands, he was an exceptional cook, making dinner for his family on a daily basis. On any given night, he could whip up chicken piccata or homemade bread or pretzels.
"He taught me how to cook," said his wife, who said that he won over her parents by cooking them dinner every Sunday. He also loved gardening and was an adept woodworker.
In the doctor's office, he endeared himself to his patients by his straight-talking demeanor.
"If they followed his advice, he was very sweet. If they didn't, he could get angry," said his wife, who worked in his office occasionally. "He didn't sugarcoat anything. ... He was blunt and practical."
He was also technologically savvy, designing a computer program in the late 1970s to keep track of his patients' medication history so he could alert them if there any drug recalls.
When he retired seven years ago, he and his wife moved to San Antonio to be closer to his wife's aunt and uncle. They moved into the Towers, a high-rise retirement community, where Dr. Marnatti volunteered to design a medical intake protocol for new residents.
In 2004, he was diagnosed with a stage four glioblastoma -- a malignant brain tumor --and was told he had six months to live. But he shocked doctors when he lived beyond his prognosis, and for a time even thrived, continuing to work on his model trains with his wife.
His wife attributed his ability to survive so far beyond his prognosis to his healthy lifestyle. He tried to be a role model for his patients and never smoked and ate healthy foods and exercised.
He so impressed doctors that one called him "the miracle man." They told him his case was "helping to write the next chapter, the next text book" on brain cancer, his wife recalled. The doctors told him "you're here to continue teaching us," his wife said.
After more than four decades as a doctor, his family considers it, in a sense, his final contribution to the medical community.
In addition to his wife and daughter, he is survived by another daughter, Janet Marnatti, and two grandsons. Dr. Marnatti's life will be celebrated at a service at 9 a.m. tomorrow in Winter Funeral Home, 4730 Friendship Ave., Bloomfield, followed by a 10 a.m. Mass at Immaculate Conception Church, 4712 Liberty Ave., Bloomfield.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.