Ernest W. Lefever, a Protestant minister, scholar and self-described "compassionate realist" whom a Senate panel in 1981 rejected as President Ronald Reagan's choice to lead his new administration's human rights efforts, died July 29 near York, Pa. He was 89.

The Ethics and Public Policy Center, the research and advocacy organization Dr. Lefever started in 1976, announced his death.

Dr. Lefever used the institute, 20 books he wrote or edited and many speeches to accentuate the links he saw between Judeo-Christian morality and national and foreign policy. He championed fierce anti-communism, tough treatment of criminals and the political rise of evangelical Christians.

In February 1981, Mr. Reagan appointed Dr. Lefever as assistant secretary of state for human rights and humanitarian affairs. His appointment quickly became the center of a national debate over whether, how and how much human rights issues should be part of U.S. foreign policy. President Jimmy Carter had promoted a broad array of human rights policies, which Mr. Reagan sharply questioned during his successful campaign against Carter in 1980.

Advertise with us

The Washington Post reported in 1981 that Dr. Lefever's appointment mattered greatly to "ultraconservatives" because the new secretary of state, Alexander M. Haig Jr., had not included ideological hardliners in his policymaking team at the State Department.

Dr. Lefever told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that the United States had no right or power "to promote human rights in other sovereign states," a direct refutation of Carter policy. And he drew a sharp distinction between oppression by communist and other brutal governments, speaking out much more strongly against communism.

His confirmation hearings were far from smooth for him. When senators asked Dr. Lefever about a statement in 1979 to the House Foreign Affairs Committee that all human rights standards should be repealed, he replied that he had "goofed." To the same committee, he excused the use of torture by the military junta in Chile as "a residual practice of the Iberian tradition." And Dr. Lefever insisted he had not said that people opposed to his nomination were inspired by communists. The committee chairman, Sen. Charles H. Percy, R-Ill., insisted that he had.

There were also questions about the financial relationship between Dr. Lefever's research center and Nestle SA, a manufacturer of infant formula, which had given more than $25,000 in grants to the center. Critics said the center had helped promote the sale of infant formula, which was a controversial business in many developing nations because polluted water was sometimes all that was available to mix with the formula and because it discouraged breastfeeding.

On June 5, 1981, five of the Senate committee's nine Republicans joined eight Democrats to vote against his nomination. Dr. Lefever withdrew his name from consideration.

Advertise with us

Mr. Reagan, who had campaigned vigorously for Dr. Lefever, suffered his first loss on a confirmation vote.

Ernest Warren Lefever was born in York on Nov. 12, 1919, graduated from Elizabethtown College in 1942 and earned a Ph.D. in Christian ethics from Yale in 1945.