Gregory Donald Scorzafave Jr., a 29-year veteran of the Dormont Police Department who made a name for himself as a rookie officer during a gunfight with a pair of notorious Pittsburgh criminals, died Monday at St. Clair Memorial Hospital. He was 77.
Mr. Scorzafave had been hospitalized last week following complications from congestive heart failure. He was born in Brookline, spent a lifetime in Dormont, and lived the last few years in Bethel Park. He most recently was featured in a Post-Gazette food story that detailed his family's tradition of making homemade sausage.
Long ago, though, Mr. Scorzafave made a name for himself as a star athlete and hero police officer.
Mr. Scorzafave, who was born into a close-knit Italian family, first achieved local attention as a pitcher for the Connelley Tech trade school. By the time he graduated in 1947, Mr. Scorzafave -- whose nickname as a youth was "Scratch" -- was recruited to play minor league baseball for a Philadelphia farm team. He packed his bags and headed South to play AA ball in North Carolina.
Two years later, while still on the team, he married his neighborhood sweetheart, Philomena Gaglia, a native of Italy. Even after her death in 1990, he continued to refer to her as "my bride."
A year after the couple wed, and with their first child on the way, Mr. Scorzafave decided to give up his $85 a month athlete's salary for a more lucrative job with Pittsburgh Railways Co. as an electrician. That position paid $125 a month.
Son Gregory III was born in 1950, and sons Donald, Robert and James soon followed. For the Scorzafaves, money was tight, but the couple lived by a simple philosophy: faith, family and food. Their Dormont home became the gathering spot for family, friends and neighbors whether for Sunday dinner or a Christmas Eve feast.
In the summer of 1958, Mr. Scorzafave joined the Dormont police force. In those days, training consisted simply of a desire to serve the community.
"He went to work at 11:30 p.m. for the night shift. The mayor was there to swear him in," said his son, Robert Scorzafave of Mount Washington. "They handed him a gun and told him go walk up and down West Liberty Avenue and check all the businesses. And they told him to pick up the call box every so often and let the station know everything was OK."
Just eight months into the job, with residents of Dormont and the surrounding South Hills communities being repeatedly burglarized, Mr. Scorzafave decided to set a trap. He sent his wife, who was pregnant with James, and the couple's other children away for the night. He turned out the lights at the family's Delwood Avenue home and sat waiting.
Sure enough, someone soon tried to enter the kitchen. That someone turned out to be a pair of brothers, Frank and Joseph Gaito, whose criminal escapades were well-known at the time throughout the region. The pair had been dubbed the Chicken Hill Bandits.
One of the brothers opened fire, hitting Mr. Scorzafave in the chest. Despite his near-fatal injury, Mr. Scorzafave returned fire, striking Frank Gaito, who later was found abandoned and wounded in a driveway at Mercy Hospital. It didn't take long for police to link the Gaito brothers to the shooting, the rash of burglaries and a bank robbery. Both were subsequently convicted.
In the days following the shooting, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette headline read: "Rookie Dormont Cop Hero of Gun Battle." The Pittsburgh Press said: "Cop Plays Hunch -- Gets Bullet, His Man." Days of photos and stories followed Mr. Scorzafave's fight to survive the bullet that struck the left side of his chest, less than an inch from his heart.
A worn scrapbook kept by the family contains cards and tributes from hundreds who prayed for the young officer to recover. Donations sent to an appreciation fund ranged from $1 from grateful citizens to $10 from a congressman. Mr. Scorzafave subsequently was honored by Dormont Borough, the Allegheny Boroughs Association and other organizations.
Following his recovery, Mr. Scorzafave went quietly back to police work, serving at night and working as a house painter by day to bring in extra money for his family. He became a founding member of Dormont's Italian Sons and Daughters lodge, volunteered at Kane Hospital, and gave money to numerous charities. He also was a member of Fraternal Order of Police Lodge 91.
Following his retirement from the Dormont force in 1987, Mr. Scorzafave began working as a federal court security officer, enjoying the daily exchanges with everyone from federal judges to federal felons.
In 2001, Mr. Scorzafave retired for good and settled into life as patriarch of the Scorzafave-Gaglia clan. He doted on his grandchildren; freely gave advice about the proper way to make spaghetti; and loved hosting parties for which he was very precise in telling guests what they should bring. No one ever argued. Mostly, though, Mr. Scorzafave loved to talk.
"He could tell a story about a criminal caper or a mundane family event and in either case, you would be mesmerized," said his daughter-in-law, Sioux Scorzafave of Tucson. "He loved to be surrounded by people of all ages. And everyone loved him. He was simply a grand man who left a legacy of love."
In addition to his son, Robert, Mr. Scorzafave is survived by sons Donald of Scott and James of Tucson; and three grandchildren.
Mass will be at 11:30 a.m. today at St. Thomas More, Bethel Park. Burial will follow in St. Anne's Cemetery, Castle Shannon.
The family suggests contributions to the Little Sisters of the Poor.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.