As an assistant district attorney for Allegheny County for 23 years, Edward "Ted" Fagan earned a reputation as a tough, no-nonsense prosecutor, happy to take on the most difficult and high-profile cases.
He headed the homicide unit, and led the prosecution of the Chicken Hill Bandits -- two men who robbed a Hays bank and then got into a gun battle with police in 1959.
Mr. Fagan, who retired in 1979, died on Monday at Vincentian Nursing Home in McCandless, where he'd lived for 18 months. He was 89 and had been diagnosed with pneumonia last week.
Stanley Greenfield, who represented Joseph Gaito, one of the Chicken Hill bandits, had only been an attorney for two days when he was hired on the case.
He soon learned he would face Mr. Fagan at trial.
"He had a reputation as a grizzled, experienced, no-nonsense prosecutor, who was gruff, short in his comments, with no apparent sense of humor," Mr. Greenfield said. "He was kind of scary to me."
Though Mr. Greenfield's client was convicted by Mr. Fagan, the two men eventually became friends.
"His bark was probably worse than his bite," said his daughter, Sue Fagan-Weber, of McCandless. "Once you knew how to give it back to him, he was mellow as could be."
Her father liked to intimidate, she said, and see who would stand up to him.
Mr. Greenfield described Mr. Fagan as a lawyer who saw things only in black and white, or guilty and innocence.
"What you saw was what you got. There was no subtlety," he said. "You knew where you stood."
After his retirement, Mr. Fagan did a bit of real estate law, but no longer practiced criminal law.
In a May 1979 Pittsburgh Press article about his career, Mr. Fagan said he was "too disillusioned and disgusted with the criminal justice system" to go on.
Instead, he enjoyed his retirement, playing golf several times each week at North Park.
He and his late wife, Charlotte, traveled, and he spent a lot of time reading mysteries -- when he borrowed books from Northland Library, he'd put a small pencil mark in them so he wouldn't check out the same book twice.
Mr. Fagan, who was in the Army from 1943 to 1946, graduated from Duquesne University School of Law in 1950, and joined the district attorney's office in 1956. Before that, he worked as a minute clerk in the courthouse.
"He was a standout prosecutor -- a very tenacious advocate," said U.S. District Judge Terrence F. McVerry, who worked under Mr. Fagan at the district attorney's office. "I thought the world of the man."
Judge McVerry called Mr. Fagan a "tremendous mentor" who was dedicated to his work as a prosecutor.
"He was gruff, tough and supremely principled," said Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning. "He was the Jack McCoy of an earlier era. A lot of good lawyers out there today owe their dignity and principles to Ted Fagan. He taught us what it meant to represent the law and the ideals of being a prosecutor."
When Mr. Fagan's daughter became a lawyer, he was proud of her, but he told her he didn't want her working in the district attorney's office.
"He thought it was too disgusting," she said. "He didn't think women should be exposed to that."
Ms. Fagan-Weber works as a hearing officer in the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas Family Division.
In addition to his daughter, Mr. Fagan is survived by two sons, Stephen E. of Surprise, Ariz., and Tom E. of San Jose, Calif.; two brothers, C. Donald of Franklin Park, and Lawrence of New Bern, N.C.; and a sister, Carol Williams of Naples, Fla.
Visitation will be from 2 to 9 p.m. today at Simons Funeral Home, Ross. Mass will be celebrated at 10 a.m. tomorrow in St. Alexis Church, McCandless. Contributions may be made to the Crisis Center North, P.O. Box 101093, Pittsburgh 15237.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.