Retired Senior Commonwealth Court Judge Emil Narick was remembered yesterday as a man who strove to do the right thing the right way both in court and on the football field as a college referee.

Mr. Narick, a coal miner's son, University of Pittsburgh football star and labor negotiator who once ran for president of the United Steelworkers union, died a week ago at age 90.

At least a dozen current and retired Common Pleas and Commonwealth Court judges were among the many who gathered for a memorial service at Westminster Presbyterian Church in Upper St. Clair.

Senior Pastor James Gilchrist said that Mr. Narick faithfully followed the words of the prophet Micah: "And what does the Lord require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God."

Advertise with us

"Emil did justice both on the courts and on the field," Mr. Gilchrist said. "By all accounts he was a humble man ... He took church seriously because he took God seriously."

But he did not take himself overly seriously. He delighted in introducing himself as "Judgie," a name bestowed on him by a waitress in the Grant Building coffee shop. It was the only name by which his two grandsons ever knew him, said his son, Kirk Narick.

One of five children born to Croatian immigrants in Benwood, W.Va., he failed first grade due to poor English, said Commonwealth Court Senior Judge James R. Kelley. But his leadership skills began that day, when he informed his parents of what had happened, and told them the family would have to speak English at home from then on, Judge Kelley said.

By his senior year in high school, he was student body president and captain of both the football and basketball teams. He became the first graduate of his high school to attend college -- on a football scholarship -- after his principal drove him to Pitt for an interview.

He graduated in 1939 and worked for the Ford Motor Co. until Pearl Harbor, when he enlisted in the Army Air Forces. Once, while flying a C-46 across the eastern United States, he conveniently developed "engine trouble" over Wheeling, W.Va., within an easy drive of his future wife, Rebecca Nay. He figured the military wouldn't be the wiser but hadn't considered that his plane was by far the largest ever to land at the Wheeling airport, his son said. The local newspaper not only covered the landing, but reported who he had dinner with that night.

Advertise with us

When he reached his destination, MPs escorted him from the plane to the commanding officer, who chewed him out at high volume, but was later heard to remark, "Wish I'd thought of that one."

After law school he spent a decade as a negotiator with the National Labor Relations Board, then was hired as assistant general counsel by the United Steelworkers. By 1968 he was convinced that union's leadership was out of touch with the rank-and-file and oblivious to critical changes in the global market. He challenged incumbent I.W. Abel for presidency of the union -- and immediately was demoted to the contracts department.

Mr. Narick championed cost-of-living increases for steel workers and pledged to hold a national meeting of all local presidents to talk about their concerns. Above all, he sought new models of doing union business.

"He felt that the old us-them labor-management thing was utterly nonproductive, and that if they didn't start working together, they would all disappear," Kirk Narick said.

He lost, but his 41 percent was more than twice what Mr. Abel's camp predicted he would garner. Some labor analysts would say his campaign triggered the first serious examination of how the union was run.

Advertise with us

The experience "shattered his whole life," Judge Kelley said. But rather than mope, "he went on to other things."

He had refereed college football games since 1950. His fellow referees helped him run for Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.

"They went door-to-door. They really worked hard," said Cliff Fair, one of his officiating crew. "The reason I did it was I thought he was born to be a judge" because of the fairness with which he made calls.

He presided over some high-profile cases. But it was his character for which he was remembered yesterday. The Rev. Julie Thompson, a former associate pastor at Westminster, drew laughter when she pantomimed her first experience of "Judgie's" bone-crushing handshake.

"My attorney friends later told me that they thought their hands had been broken," she said, noting that he used the same large hands to give her a thumbs-up after a good sermon.

Advertise with us

When one of his young neighbors got a Cabbage Patch Doll, he announced that the new relationship needed to be properly solemnized, Ms. Thompson said. "He came over in his robes and presided over the adoption of the Cabbage Patch Doll."

Ever the physical fitness buff, he was famous for walking a mile or so each day to his trolley stop with a sign on his back that said, "I prefer to walk."

Age limits forced his retirement from Common Pleas Court in 1986, but he soon became a senior judge on Commonwealth Court, where he served until 2002. That court deals with the relationship between people and the government, and his experiences made him an ideal Commonwealth Court judge, and a mentor to all the others, Judge Kelley said.

"He touched each and every one of us and ... he did it with love and kindness for everyone who crossed his path.".....

Steve Mellon, Post-Gazette

Advertise with us

Cassandra Tominack, left, hugs cousin Kirk Narick after a memorial service for Mr. Narick's father, Judge Emil Narick, at Westminster Presbyterian Church in Upper St. Clair yesterday. A retired senior Commonwealth Court judge, Mr. Narick's common-sense approach to law resolved many labor disputes. He died last Saturday at the age of 90.

Click photo for larger image.Related story

Obituary: Emil Narick, judge on field and in court, dies at 90

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.