Retired Allegheny County Common Pleas Court Judge John W. O'Brien died Friday at the Country Meadows of South Hills nursing facility. He was 84.
He served more than a quarter century, presiding over some notorious criminal trials of the 1970s and 1980s. Lawyers called him an old school gentleman.
"He could exhibit a wry sense of humor from the bench, but never arrogance or sarcasm. When you entered his courtroom, you knew that he was there to dispense justice fairly, and that's exactly what he did," said Gregory Nescott, now a federal prosecutor, who tried cases before Judge O'Brien for a decade in the district attorney's office.
A native of Mt. Lebanon, he was attending St. Vincent College when Pearl Harbor was bombed. He fought with the infantry in Holland, France and Germany. He received the Purple Heart for a shrapnel wound, and the Bronze Star for valor -- but his family never knew why because he didn't talk about the war, said John. W. O'Brien Jr., of Whitehall, the fourth of his eight children.
He worked his way through the University of Pittsburgh and its law school.
He married Ruth Vollmer in 1949 and practiced law in Baldwin, where he became mayor 20 years later. He always put his family first, his son said.
"He liked to get involved in all of our activities, sports or whatever. That was really his whole purpose in life -- to take care of his family," he said.
He was elected to the bench in 1971. A decade later he became the first chairman of a state commission to draft sentencing guidelines.
He presided over high profile trials, including the Coraopolis sniper, a deranged 24-year-old Army veteran who in 1980 opened fire on his neighbors from a third-floor window, killing four and wounding a man who rushed to aid his fatally wounded wife. A jury rejected his insanity defense and Judge O'Brien sentenced him to 20 to 40 years in prison.
The case that distressed him the most was the 1988 trial of a serial rapist from Homestead who attacked elderly women, his son said. He believed the evidence was so strong that the accused, Dennis Foy, should have made a plea bargain.
The trial "made all these elderly women come in and testify about what was done to them. He was a real religious guy, and that case really bothered him," said his son. "He was crying with the women when the guy finally got convicted," he said. He sentenced Mr. Foy to 100 to 200 years.
Some of his strongest words in the courtroom were for prisoners who harmed other inmates. In 1986, when a jury acquitted two convicted murderers of killing another inmate by dousing him with lighter fluid and setting him on fire, he was outraged. "I don't know if you believe in the superior being," he told one of the accused after the verdict, "but you should not only get down on your knees, you ought to crawl out of here on your knees and not get off them for the next 10 years. You beat the system."
Mr. Nescott was a prosecutor in that case. "He would at times wear his heart on his sleeve, but that was because he had such a strong sense of right and wrong," he said. "Although he could be a tough sentencing judge, he often showed compassion, especially in giving some young criminals another chance."
He retired in 1990, but continued as a "senior judge" through much of the decade. When he finally had more time to spend at home, "he liked hanging out with his dog, checking the stock market on television and doing his gardening," his son said.
Besides John Jr. and his wife, he is survived by a sister, Nancy O'Connor of Florida; five daughters, Colleen Adams of Collier, Christie Leslie of Whitehall, Patrice Felton of West Mifflin, Julie Happe of Bethel Park and Jaqueline O'Brien of Whitehall; sons, Terrence of Upper St. Clair and Robert of Shaler; and 14 grandchildren.
Visitation is today and tomorrow from 2 to 4 and 7 to 9 p.m. at the John F. Slater Funeral Home in Brentwood. A prayer service will be held Tuesday at 9:15 a.m. with the funeral Mass at 10 a.m. in St. Elizabeth of Hungary Church, Baldwin.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.