Edward R. Becker, a judge of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals known for his scholarly opinions and humble lifestyle, died in Philadelphia yesterday, according to the court. He was 73.

The court's statement did not specify a cause of death for Judge Becker, who had a reputation as one of the nation's most influential judges.

"He's probably made more law than any other appeals judge," Professor Stephen Saltzburg of George Washington University Law School said in 2003. "He's not afraid to stick his neck out, and if the Supreme Court thinks he's wrong, they'll tell him. But a lot of times they think he's right."

Colleague Marjorie O. Rendell described him as "the perfect combination of Mensa and mensch."

Advertise with us

Judge Becker was appointed as a district judge in 1970 by then-President Richard Nixon and attributed his 1981 promotion to the appeals court to his work ethic.

"I've never been bored a single day on my job and I don't think I ever will," he said when his portrait was unveiled at the courthouse in 1998. "I have the best lawyer's job in the world."

He became chief judge of the appeals court in 1998, then relinquished that job when he turned 70 in 2003, becoming a senior judge.

Despite his prestigious job, Judge Becker continued to live in the Northeast Philadelphia house where he grew up. "It's beautiful and it's peaceful," he once said. "Why would I want to live anywhere else?"

He would arrive at work by subway after reading briefs on the train.

Advertise with us

Ann Meredith, a historic preservationist, worked with Judge Becker to reopen the street in front of Independence Hall after it was closed following the Sept. 11, 2001, domestic terrorist attacks. She said the only thing better than succeeding at that was working with Judge Becker.

"He could so easily live in an elitist world," Ms. Meredith said in 2003. "Instead, he tromps around in shabby clothes, a ridiculous coat that he has some Yiddish word for, and a cabdriver hat. He answers his own phone a lot. He's always accessible. He's one step below the Supreme Court, but he's such an everyday man."

Judge Becker was also known for playing the piano for secretaries' birthdays and for an annual singalong that now-deceased U.S. Chief Justice William Rehnquist used to host for Supreme Court law clerks.

Funeral arrangements had not been made as of yesterday, the court's statement said.