John Motto wasn't the best or most accomplished musician this city has ever known. But one could make a pretty strong argument that he was the coolest.
Cool came naturally to Mr. Motto, who died a week ago of liver cancer. He was 56.
Mr. Motto was a guitarist and member of such bands as the Lugnuts, the Polish Hillbillies and Ploughman's Lunch.
Asked about musical proficiency, Steve Sciulli, a longtime friend who played with him in several bands, hesitated and said, "It was important to have him in the band mainly because of his charisma. He certainly had one of the coolest vibes in the city. He was our Stu Sutcliffe," the so-called "fifth Beatle."
With his biker jacket, shaved head, pale, gaunt face and piercing eyes, Mr. Motto didn't have to be good. He looked the part and he lived the part. And that didn't leave a lot of time for employment.
"Being John Motto was his living," Mr. Sciulli said. "That was a full-time living. He booked some clubs, he played in bands, he was kind of a mystery in that aspect. We all helped out."
Mr. Motto was born in Washington, Pa., and graduated from Washington High School in 1967.
Dennis Childers, a friend, artist and musician, said Mr. Motto did some construction work in his younger days and was a jack-of-all-trades. "I lived with him in Polish Hill for a while, and we used to pay off the rent just working on the place."
"He was great with his hands," said Karl Mullen, who played with him in Ploughman's Lunch. "If you needed something fixed, John Motto was the guy you'd call."
They met when Mr. Mullen came to the States from Ireland in 1979. "John showed me an America that no one else could show me, whether it was going down to the rivers to go fishing or hanging out at the biker bars in Washington County. He was into old cars, out-of-the-way places. He was pure Americana."
There's no question he had a tough exterior -- right down to the Marlboros rolled up in sleeves revealing tattooed arms -- but his friends will tell you that wasn't the whole picture.
"John was an enigma," Mr. Sciulli said, "and a lot of people were intimidated by him, but you could look in his eyes and see a good person and once you got to know him, he was soft, so giving."
Mr. Motto is survived by brothers Danny, of Washington, Pa., and Sam, of Claysville, Washington County.
There will be a remembrance for him at Gooski's, 3117 Brereton St., in Polish Hill at 4 p.m. Sunday.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.