The Metropolitan Opera's loss was Pittsburgh Opera's gain when contralto Esther Fay Cohen decided to remain in her hometown.

Known as Fay Kohler on stage, she began as a singer in the Pittsburgh Opera chorus during the late 1940s and later sang many supporting roles at Pittsburgh Opera, including playing the page in "Lohengrin" and the shepherd in "Tosca" in several productions in the 1950s, '60s and '70s.

Mrs. Cohen died Monday of a massive stroke at UPMC Shadyside. The longtime Squirrel Hill resident was 85.

"She had the opportunity to go to many different places; she had the ability," said her son, William Cohen, of Edgewood. "She was offered a job with the Met but decided to stay in Pittsburgh because of my father's business and raising a family."

Advertise with us

Born in the Hill District to a family of humble means, Mrs. Cohen attended Schenley High School and then put herself through Chatham College for a few years.

"She was well-versed in any subject in music, art and literature and was literate in five different languages. She read four to five books a week," said Mr. Cohen.

She attended Congregation Shaare Torah in Squirrel Hill.

In the '50s, Mrs. Cohen took lessons from the famed teacher Samuel Margolis in New York.

"She wanted to take the extra step," said her son. "He told her she was capable of singing at the Met, but she turned it down."

Advertise with us

At Pittsburgh Opera, Mrs. Cohen sang with the likes of Robert Merrill, Roberta Peters and Richard Tucker, gave lieder recitals and taught students.

"Only 5-foot-1, she was a diminutive woman but had an exceptionally strong voice," said Mr. Cohen.

In addition to her son, Mrs. Cohen is survived by a daughter, Judith Joseph of New York; a sister, Minnie Caplan; and two grandchildren.

Visitation will be at noon today, with services following at 1 p.m. at Ralph Schugar Chapel, 5509 Centre Ave., Shadyside.