Justice David Souter was a quiet, highly intellectual, soft-spoken jurist who was a believer in the paramount importance of public service. For that reason, his time on the Supreme Court was marked by a studious approach to his work, with little enthusiasm for the pomp and circumstance of Washington.

He enjoyed gathering with lawyers and judges to talk about serious issues of law — so he was not an infrequent speaker at events hosted by the Judicial Conference of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, often in Philadelphia or Pittsburgh, because he was the justice assigned to that circuit that covered Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware and the Virgin Islands.

Although shy and low-key in public gatherings, his speeches were masterworks of plainspoken ideas and concepts; he often generated rousing ovations from his thoughtful and inspiring observations.

I got to know Justice Souter in part due to my work on Archibald Cox, the New England Brahmin whose biography I was privileged to write. Cox was viewed as one of the great U.S. solicitor generals in history, arguing landmark cases in the Supreme Court. Yet he was also viewed as an American hero after standing up to President Nixon as Watergate special prosecutor and was regarded as one of the great public servants of the 20th century.

Advertise with us

In 1971, Cox had argued a major criminal case in the U.S. Supreme Court — Coolidge v. New Hampshire — that set new parameters on searching and seizing automobiles without probable cause. Souter, then working in the State Attorney’s General office in New Hampshire, later shared with me his admiration for Cox’s handling of that complex case that broke new ground in protecting Fourth Amendment rights under the Constitution.

In early October, 2001, I received an unexpected, personal note on Supreme Court letterhead from Justice Souter, mailed from his Chambers in Washington. This came just months after the Supreme Court’s controversial decision in Bush v. Gore, in which the court waded into the dispute over the 2000 presidential election between George W. Bush and Al Gore, and decided, 5-4, in Bush’s favor, paving the way for him to win the White House.

Read More

Justice Souter vigorously dissented. Reports were numerous that the decision in Bush v. Gore had caused intense, personal friction among the justices and their clerks, and that the wounds were still raw as they entered the new October term in 2001. It was then that Justice Souter wrote this note, revealing his personal feelings in the aftermath of Bush v. Gore:

“When we met in Pittsburgh a couple of years ago, you most kindly gave me a copy of your biography of Mr. Cox. After reading the book last July, I just want to affirm my thanks to you for giving it to me and for writing it in the first place. This past summer I felt the need of reading about people like Archibald Cox, and your volume was just what I wanted. Your writing was fine, and your subject pepped me up.”

Justice David Souter, in many ways, was a loner on the court. He preferred retreating to his quiet farmhouse, amidst the mountains and lakes of New Hampshire, to the limelight and bruising struggles of Washington. Yet he believed, fundamentally, in the sacred nature of public service, and devoted all of the energy and intellectual firepower at his command to doing the job correctly during his time on the court, always seeking to push the system of law and justice forward so that it met the high standards set by the U.S. Constitution.

Advertise with us

Justice Souter may not go down in history as the most famous or flashy Supreme Court justice. But he nonetheless devoted his life to trying to get it right.

— Ken Gormley, Duquesne University president