The West Virginia legislature on Tuesday passed a bill to prohibit nearly all abortions, making it the second state to pass a new ban since the Supreme Court reversed Roe v. Wade in June.

The State Senate passed the bill 22-7, after a brief debate Tuesday afternoon. The State House concurred and passed the bill with a 78-17 vote. The ban will take effect 90 days after passage.

West Virginia Republicans moved forward with the strict ban despite signs in other parts of the country that many American voters do not support the Supreme Court’s ruling and largely oppose the harshest restrictions on abortion. A similar effort to pass a near-total abortion ban in South Carolina fizzled out last week and voters resoundingly rejected a ballot measure in Kansas that would have stripped abortion protections from the state constitution.

Abortion had previously been legal up to 20 weeks in West Virginia since July, when a state judge blocked a pre-Roe ban that dated back to the 19th century. The state sits on the border of an antiabortion stronghold in the Midwest and South that includes neighboring states Ohio and Kentucky. Abortion is legal east of the state line in Virginia, Maryland and Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

In West Virginia, the Republican-controlled legislature reached a compromise over penalties for doctors who perform illegal abortions that had previously been a sticking point for some conservative lawmakers. The bill they passed, which now goes to Republican Gov. Jim Justice’s desk, bars abortion from implantation with narrow exceptions to save the pregnant person’s life or in cases of rape or incest so long as the victim reports the crime.

Mr. Justice has indicated that he will likely sign a bill tightening state restrictions on abortion.

The exceptions for victims of rape or incest limit the procedure to before eight weeks of pregnancy, or 14 weeks for minor victims. Doctors who violate the law may lose their medical licenses, but will not face criminal penalties. Anyone other than a licensed physician with hospital admitting privileges who performs an abortion faces felony charges and up to 5 years in prison. Women who receive abortions do not face any penalties.

West Virginians support putting restrictions on abortion more than voters in most other states, but some lawmakers raised concerns that harsh criminal penalties could drive doctors, especially obstetricians, out of the state at a time when some regions known to be “maternity deserts” that already face a physician shortage.

“You’re not concerned we could lose docs who are practicing OB because of this?” senate minority leader Stephen Baldwin, a Democrat, asked after the amended version of the bill was introduced. He also questioned why the senate was choosing to vote on the new language without giving physicians a chance to weigh in on the bill.

Advertise with us

“We’ve had a lot of time where we could have involved docs, but now, today, we’re going to vote on this . . . and they haven’t had time to read it,” Mr. Baldwin said.

Republican Sen.Tom Takubo, who opposed the earlier version of the bill and advocated to remove criminal penalties for doctors, said he believes the new language addressed physicians’ fears that they could be prosecuted for trying to save the life of a patient suffering from a life-threatening pregnancy complication.

“I think once they read what is in this amendment they will feel comfortable,” he said. “I feel this protects those physicians who are not trying to violate the law.”

Some antiabortion Republican senators opposed the amended bill because it did not go far enough in limiting abortion.

“I’m confident that this bill shuts down the abortion clinic,” said RepublicanSen. Tarr, who urged his colleagues to vote no on the new language because he said it carved out too many exceptions.

Advertise with us

“I’m also torn and disappointed that my vote now is to decide when do you execute an innocent,” he added. “If life is sacred, when does it become sacred?”

About 100 protesters gathered outside the senate chamber on Tuesday to oppose the bill and could be heard inside the state capitol as senators discussed the bill. Some observers in the senate gallery briefly disrupted the senate shortly after the amended bill was introduced, shouting their dissent over the ban.

Even though West Virginians broadly support some restrictions on abortion, advocates for abortion access say the bill is still at odds with the will of the state’s voters.

“West Virginia lawmakers are working to ban abortion in our state, dragging us back to the 19th century,” said Margaret Chapman Pomponio, executive director of WV FREE, the state’s largest abortion rights advocacy organization. “They’re plowing ahead, despite recent polls showing that nearly half of West Virginians identify as pro-choice and a strong majority oppose this draconian legislation.”

Some members of the State House proposed backing away from the bill and instead posing the question directly to voters. They brought up the ballot measure rejected in Kansas last month and suggested West Virginia voters might surprise lawmakers at the polls.

Advertise with us

West Virginia’s governor has dismissed suggestions that voters should decide the state’s abortion laws directly.

“Coming down from the U.S. Supreme Court, this is the responsibility of our Legislature and our attorney general,” Justice said in August.

Justice called legislators back to the West Virginia Capitol for a special session to consider more stringent abortion restrictions in July. Days later, the state house had passed an initial version of a near-total ban. But the bill stalled after the state senate became gridlocked over criminal penalties for doctors performing illegal abortions that included fines and prison time. The state senate eventually passed a bill that stripped away many of the penalties for doctors, but the house refused to concur.

State senators and house delegates spent more than a month trying to reach a compromise that could get the bill passed in both chambers. Ultimately, the two chambers of the state legislature managed to find common ground and passed the new version of the bill, without criminal penalties for doctors, on Tuesday.

abortion-westvirginia