ATLANTA — The judge presiding over the grand jury investigation into possible election interference by Donald Trump and his allies expressed skepticism Thursday over arguments from Republicans that the prosecution, led by a Democratic district attorney, was politically motivated.

Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney did not immediately rule on a request from Republican Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp to toss a subpoena for his testimony from Democratic Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis.

“It is not my space” to focus on politics, Judge McBurney said, as lawyers for Mr. Kemp argued that the subpoena had already become a political issue this election season. “I don’t think it is the right forum” to debate the political ramifications of the case, said the judge.

With the midterm elections approaching, the investigation has expanded dramatically, reaching Mr. Trump’s inner circle and edging closer to the former president himself. In recent days, a new wave of political and legal tensions erupted into public view, with Mr. Kemp’s attorney and others accusing prosecutors of politicizing the sensitive case.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kemp, who resisted pressure from Mr. Trump to overturn Georgia’s election results, is considered a key witness. Prosecutors said in a filing this week they would like to ask the governor about calls he received from Mr. Trump and others pressing him to contest the state’s election results.

Mr. Kemp is running for re-election against Democrat Stacey Abrams, a former state lawmaker and voting rights advocate whom he narrowly beat in 2018. Last week, Ms. Abrams tweeted that the governor’s “refusal to testify shows that he will do anything to win an election. Mr. Kemp wants credit for ‘standing up’ to Mr. Trump but refuses to testify against the former president and said he would welcome his endorsement.”

In court on Thursday, lawyers for the governor cited Ms. Abrams’ comments as an example of the politicization of the ongoing inquiry.

“What began as an investigation into election interference has itself devolved into its own mechanism of election interference,” the governor’s lawyer wrote in a 121-page motion seeking to kill a subpoena for the governor’s testimony or at least delay the matter until after the election.

Ms. Willis denied any political motivation in court filings that became public last week.

Advertise with us

“Let’s discuss the ways you are wrong: This is NOT a politically motivated investigation. It is a criminal investigation,” Ms. Willis wrote in a letter released as part of last week’s motion.

It was not clear from the hearing Thursday, which lasted more than two hours, whether Mr. Kemp’s effort to invalidate the subpoena will prevail. In July, the judge rejected a similar request from the lieutenant governor and a former state senator to toss subpoenas.

Earlier Thursday, Judge McBurney issued a decision rejecting a request from 11 of Georgia’s 16 Republican would-be electors who sought to disqualify the prosecution team because of political bias. Prosecutors say these electors may have been part of a plan to try to cast electoral college votes for Mr. Trump in Georgia and other states despite Joe Biden’s victory. Lawyers for the electors deny any wrongdoing, citing a pending court case over the Georgia election at the time they were certified. The roster of electors includes Georgia Republican Party Chair David J. Shafer, candidate for lieutenant governor Burt Jones, county-level GOP officials, a former state lawmaker and local Republican activists.

The ongoing inquiry, Judge McBurney wrote, “is inherently ‘political’ in the simple and unremarkable sense that politicians and leaders of a specific political party are alleged to have undertaken efforts to defeat the will of the Georgia electorate.”

A prosecutor who takes on such a case, he wrote, “is not automatically biased and partisan — and subject to disqualification — because of the common political affiliations of the subjects (and targets) of the investigation.”

Advertise with us

Brian McEvoy, Mr. Kemp’s attorney, told the judge the governor is being asked to testify as the gubernatorial election is “reaching a crescendo.” He questioned why the district attorney’s office would not permit Mr. Kemp to testify after the election.

Judge McBurney noted that the criticism from Mr. Kemp’s political rivals over his resistance to testify “happened because what had originally been negotiated didn’t happen.” He said that other statewide leaders, like Republican Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger, had testified without fanfare.

“We agreed on a date. You were available, you had confirmed the governor was available,” Judge McBurney told Mr. Kemp’s counsel.

Prosecutors have said they intend to avoid grand jury activity after the start of early voting in October.

Mr. Kemp’s lawyers also cited the doctrines of sovereign immunity and executive privilege that they argued would protect the governor from a subpoena. They said they were alarmed by the decision to subpoena the governor when he’d previously agreed to be interviewed under certain conditions.

Advertise with us

“We’ve been trying to come in voluntarily, facilitate the dialogue to discuss executive privilege, attorney-client privilege, those types of things. They’ve rejected at every turn,” Derek Bauer, one of the governor’s lawyers.

Nathan Wade, an attorney for the district attorney’s office, said that Kemp’s legal counsel was trying to “control” how prosecutors interview Mr. Kemp. Judge McBurney noted that “if anything, Kemp is a victim” of the crimes potentially committed, not a target. Prosecutors confirmed that.

As Ms. Willis and her staff seek testimony from prominent Georgia Republicans and Trump allies, they face increasingly heated criticism from Republicans — and praise from those who support the inquiry.

“This is reckless and it borders on maniacal,” said John Malcolm, a former federal prosecutor in Georgia who is now vice president of the Institute for Constitutional Government at the Heritage Foundation. “I don’t know whether she’s doing this to aggrandize her political fortunes or to try to affect the results of the upcoming midterm election or to try to affect the results of the 2024 presidential election — or whether it’s all three.”