WASHINGTON — Since 2013, more than a dozen states have tried to ban abortion as soon as a sonogram can pick up the thump-thump of an embryonic heartbeat.
That’s about six weeks, an egregious constitutional affront under Roe vs. Wade. No court has allowed a ban so early in pregnancy to stand.
The Supreme Court never even granted an appeal — until Texas concocted Senate Bill 8.
What grabbed the Supreme Court’s attention, prompting two hours of oral arguments scheduled Monday, isn’t the six-week ban, which clearly violates Roe, but the way the law outsources enforcement to legal bounty hunters in an effort to evade judicial review.
A ruling could come quickly, and it will focus on whether Texas achieved its goal of crafting a law immune from challenge by anyone, including the federal government and abortion providers.
That’s an important question, as other red states consider copycat laws. But it means SB 8 won’t be the vehicle the conservative majority uses to toss Roe on the scrap heap with Dred Scott and other landmarks the court came to regret.
Read More
The fact they let SB 8 take effect on Sept. 1 is a strong omen that Roe’s days could be numbered, though.
“Pro-life advocates are energized and excited. The court has declined every opportunity to block SB 8,” said Kyleen Wright, president of Texans for Life Coalition. “That just gives everyone more hope and anticipation of what they’re planning to do with Dobbs.”
The court will hear arguments Dec. 1 in Dobbs vs. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, involving a 15-week ban in Mississippi intended as a test case that might topple Roe.
“We may get some tea leaves from [Monday’s] argument, but I would be very surprised if there were major changes that come directly out of it,” said I. Glenn Cohen, deputy dean of Harvard Law School and an expert on medical ethics and the law. “If there is going to be a big change in abortion law itself, i.e., what the Constitution prohibits states from doing, that’s likely to come at least initially in Dobbs.”
Under Roe, the state’s interest in protecting the fetus outweighs a woman’s right to bodily autonomy once the fetus could survive outside the womb. That’s about 22 to 24 weeks.
For decades, courts have enforced Roe by stopping prosecutors and police from enforcing certain restrictions. Under SB 8, there’s no official to enjoin.
The mechanisms built into SB 8 are so complete that doctors aren’t allowed to defend themselves against lawsuits by pointing out that the six-week ban is unconstitutional.
Even the most ardent anti-abortion activists were dubious as the bill worked through the Legislature.
“We had concerns that SB 8 would not survive a federal court challenge even back during the spring,” said Joe Pojman, executive director of Texas Alliance for Life, who said he privately urged key Texas lawmakers to think twice.
Roe is a “terrible precedent” that “ties the hands of the Legislature from protecting unborn babies before the point of viability,” Mr. Pojman said, but it is, unequivocally, the law of the land unless the Supreme Court says otherwise.
That’s exactly why the court needs to strike down SB 8, say the Justice Department and abortion providers who’ll plead the case Monday.
Texas’ solicitor general, Judd Stone, will defend the law before the court, along with a lawyer for a group of private citizens who want to file lawsuits under SB 8.
The Biden administration’s solicitor general Elizabeth Prelogar, confirmed by the Senate only on Thursday, will argue the case for the Justice Department.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.