Pennsylvania’s U.S. senators split their votes — and their reactions — to the overnight passage of the GOP tax bill, which prompted a flow of dueling statements either lauding the legislation or demonizing it.

“Passage of this pro-growth tax reform bill brings hardworking Pennsylvanians one step closer to seeing a direct pay raise and better job opportunities,” Republican Sen. Pat Toomey who voted for the bill, said in a statement.

Mr. Toomey, who tried but failed to carve out a narrow exemption that appeared to be tailored to a single school in Michigan with ties to conservatives, touted the $1.5 trillion tax bill as good for middle-income families, American workers and businesses.

“Our bill directly lowers the tax burden for middle income families and fundamentally restructures the business tax code so American workers and businesses can compete globally,” Mr. Toomey said.

Advertise with us

“It transforms one of the world’s worst business tax codes into one of the most competitive, making it easier for entrepreneurs to start new businesses and giving employers greater incentives to buy new capital equipment and bring operations home from overseas. I am confident these reforms will unleash a surge in economic growth and job creation.”

His Democratic counterpart, however, who voted against the plan, issued a statement blasting the bill as a “tax scheme” and a “windfall for the wealthy.”

“This is an insult to the many middle class families in Pennsylvania who will pay more in taxes under this scheme while the super-rich and big corporations get a windfall,” Sen. Bob Casey said.

“Congress should be working in a bipartisan way to make our tax system simpler and fairer, but the Senate Republican plan does just the opposite. In 2019, the country’s 572,000 richest households will see $34 billion worth of tax cuts, while the 90 million Americans making under $50,000 a year will see a fraction of that. That is both obscene and grossly unfair.”

Mr. Casey warned that the bill rewards companies that outsourced job; will trigger $25 billion in cuts to Medicare; and lead to the partial repeal of the Affordable Care Act, leading to 13 million Americans losing their health care.

Advertise with us

“What passed today is a big Republican giveaway to corporations and Republican corporate donors,” Mr. Casey said.

The Republican National Committee took issue with Mr. Casey’s stance.

“In an historic vote last night, the Senate voted to put middle class families first and pass tax reform,” said committee spokeswoman Christiana Purves, who cited research by the nonprofit Tax Foundation claiming that tax reform will create more than 37,000 new jobs in Pennsylvania and provide an extra $2,683 in after-tax income.

“Unfortunately for hardworking Pennsylvanians, Bob Casey decided to listen to Chuck Schumer [D-N.Y.] instead of his constituents and oppose the bill in a blatant effort to obstruct the President’s agenda at all costs,” Ms. Purves said. “Pennsylvanians will remember Bob Casey’s vote against tax reform. Casey has obstructed tax reform from the beginning, and voters have the opportunity to replace him in 2018 with someone who puts the best interest of Pennsylvanians ahead of partisan politics.”

One of those people, U.S. Rep. Lou Barletta, R-Hazleton, who is running for Mr. Casey’s seat, put out a statement supporting the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, as the tax overhaul bill is formally called.

Advertise with us

"For too long Washington has forgotten about American workers and families," Mr. Barletta said. "The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act will finally give those forgotten Americans the break they need. This plan will create jobs, raise wages for our workers, grow the economy, and provide much needed relief to working families. Why does Senator Casey not want working families to keep more of their own money?”

Frederick Isasi, executive director of Families USA, a nonprofit health-care advocacy group, criticized the passage of the bill in the Senate and said it reflects GOP senators voting for “short term political gains and against the long term interests of people in America.”

“The result,” Mr. Isasi said, “will be a spike in monthly health insurance premiums and more than 13 million people losing coverage.”

He called on the Republican-led House, which approved a similar bill last month and will now work to reconcile it with the Senate’s version, to block the legislation.

“We urge the House to vote against this harmful health bill masked as a ‘tax plan’, ” Mr. Isasi said.

Advertise with us

Democratic National Committee Chairman Tom Perez called the tax bill a “scam” and “an absolute betrayal of America’s working families.”

He excoriated Republican senators for the lack of debate and the inclusion of “hundreds of pages of hastily-drafted, handwritten bill text” with what he described as “dozens of new giveaways to special interest lobbyists.”

“This is the price of Republican leadership: a tax plan built on lies and written for the rich, by the rich,” Mr. Perez said.

The president of the Amalgamated Transit Union, which represents mroe than 190,000 people in the U.S. and Canada, assailed the tax vote. Its president, Larry Hanley, said, “We owe $20 trillion and now Congress will add a trillion more dollars to give people with gold drapes money they do not even need.”

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.