In most cases, it comes in the form of a letter.

Shortly after a U.S. service member is killed in action, the letter is delivered to the family. It thanks them for their loved one’s service, and is typically signed by the president.

But for many Gold Star families, including some in Pittsburgh, it’s an important gesture from the commander in chief in a time of great pain; an acknowledgment of condolences on behalf of the country their loved ones sacrificed for. And after President Donald J. Trump this week called into question his predecessors’ interactions with those grieving families in justifying his own, the role of the president as “Consoler in Chief” took on a new significance.

Families of Pittsburgh-born soldiers who died in action spoke about their experiences with presidents, in interviews with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Most received a letter. Some wanted more.

Advertise with us

For Valerie Lane, the widow of fallen Marine Sgt. Ryan Lane, who was killed in 2009, it took about three months for her to receive a letter from President Barack Obama. When it arrived, it was the same letter Ryan’s parents got, which she said felt “a little impersonal.”

Ms. Lane said some of her friends received a signed plaque from President George W. Bush after their husbands were killed in action.

“For me, no matter what party any president belongs to, or the family of that member who was killed, a personal phone call or something more than a generated letter would be very appreciated,” Ms. Lane said. “If you think about it, the president is the commander in chief, which one could say is the boss of our armed forces. Most bosses wouldn’t just write a letter to a family who tragically lost one of their own.”

After Army Spc. Rafael Navea was killed in 2003, his mother, Lucia, got a signed letter from Mr. Bush. During Mr. Obama’s term, First Lady Michelle Obama contacted Lucia for a picture of her son to display on the White House Christmas tree.

At the end of Mr. Bush’s presidency in 2008, Doug Maseth’s son, Army Staff Sgt. Ryan Maseth, was killed in Iraq. He received a letter from the president, but wasn’t called.

Advertise with us

The family of fallen Marine Lance Cpl. Patrick Kenny received a letter from Mr. Bush in 2005 after he died in Iraq. At the time, it was a great honor, but simply a gesture.

“Let me put it bluntly — we were grieving. The letters were nice, but they were just put away in a pile,” said Patricia Kenny, Patrick’s mother. “We wanted our son. We didn’t want a letter from the president, or the man on the moon, at that point.”

Ms. Kenny and her husband, Chuckie, questioned why Mr. Trump was being criticized for his recent delay in publicly discussing the deaths of four soldiers in Niger. Like previous presidents, Mr. Trump has personally contacted families of fallen service members, but not all.

The Rev. Gerald Caskey said he received more attention from the Trump administration than from Mr. Obama, who was in office at the time his son, Marine Sgt. Joseph Caskey, was killed in Afghanistan. Mr. Caskey and his family were invited by Mr. Trump to the White House in June to take part in an event honoring families of the fallen.

“When we went in, my wife said, ‘Oh, it’s such an honor to do this,’ and President Trump said, ‘Oh, no, no, this is my honor,’” Mr. Caskey recalled. “President Trump was engaging. He was personal. We felt really supported.”

Advertise with us
The family of fallen Marine Sgt. Joseph Caskey -- who was killed in Afghanistan in 2010 -- poses for a photo with President Donald Trump and First Lady Melania Trump at an event in June. (Courtesy of Gerald Caskey)

About 6,900 Americans have been killed in overseas wars since the Sept. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, and there is no White House rule that demands presidents speak or meet with their families.

The widow of fallen Army Spc. Doug Weismantle figured she would receive a letter. She did, from Mr. Bush, in 2003.

”I don’t expect the president to go to every service member’s funeral. That wouldn’t be an expectation,” Christine Weismantle said. “I can’t say I wanted the president to do any more. It certainly would be nice if he could meet every family of every service member killed in action. But I expected a letter.”

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1952, Twitter @julianrouth.