Which would you rather have — weather forecasts that are scary or weather forecasts that are confusing?

National Weather Service meteorologists in the Northeast this week decided to play it safe as they stuck to their forecasts of giant blankets of snow even after the conditions started to change.

“Out of extreme caution we decided to stick with higher amounts,” Greg Carbin, chief of forecast operations at the Weather Prediction Center in suburban Maryland, told The Associated Press. “I actually think in the overall scheme that the actions [by states and cities] taken in advance of the event were exceptional.”

On Monday, the weather service predicted 18 to 24 inches of snow in New York City. It got about 7 inches.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh had been projected to get 2 to 4 inches but the flurries only amounted to 1 inch by 9 p.m. Tuesday. But then, a “very narrow band of snow,” according to the weather service, moved into Allegheny County, dropping more than an inch of snow in a couple of hours.

Overnight and into Wednesday, up to 3 inches were possible in some areas, said meteorologist Bill Modzelewski.

Mr. Carbin said downgrading snowfall predictions at the last minute Monday might have given people the wrong message that the storm was no longer a threat. It still was, although the real danger was from ice and sleet in places such as New York City and Washington, D.C., he said.

Meteorologists in Boston, New York, Philadelphia and Washington held a conference call Monday afternoon to discuss whether to dramatically cut snow predictions. They opted to keep the news to themselves.

“The nature of the beast is that there’s always uncertainty in every forecast and we have to get better at describing that,” Mr. Carbin told The Associated Press.

Advertise with us

And they weren’t totally wrong. A lot of snow did fall inland. Upstate New York and Connecticut got more than a foot and a half of snow, and swaths of northeast Pennsylvania were walloped by 20 to 30 inches. Harrisburg got more than a foot.

Pennsylvania transportation officials Tuesday night lifted speed and vehicle restrictions on the northeast extension of the Pennsylvania Turnpike and Interstates 80 and 81 as the storm moved out of the commonwealth. Interstate 84, however, which stretches across the northern part of the state, remained closed to trucks.

Warnings about ice on the roads remained in place overnight.

Philadelphia had been bracing for a couple of feet of snow. The Philadelphia Inquirer said the 7 inches that did fall still set a record for the date.

Meteorologists, the newspaper reported, said the storm tracked closer to the coast than expected, and once it matured, the strong winds it generated from the east carried a stubborn warm layer of air, about 2,500 feet up.

Advertise with us

Mr. Carbin said the forecasts did have a positive effect in that they got the attention of emergency managers: “I think that was great.”

Mike Gable, Pittsburgh public works director, said Monday that the city could put as many as 90 snowplows on the streets Tuesday, but when it was clear snowfall would be light, a “normal” 50 trucks were dispatched to treat the roads.

Not that the storm didn’t cause trouble. Commuter rail service between Washington and Boston was disrupted, there was flooding in New Jersey, a wind turbine in Rhode Island was toppled, and tens of thousands of residents lost electricity for hours. Schools and businesses closed and thousands of flights were canceled.

Bob Kerlik, spokesman for Pittsburgh International Airport, said more than 40 flights to and from the airport were canceled because of conditions to the north and east. Officials were advising people to check with their airlines before driving to the airport.

Brian Edwards, a meteorologist with AccuWeather in State College, said Pittsburgh could continue to see flurries and breezy conditions. Temperatures are expected to drop into the teens Wednesday.

Advertise with us

“It’s certainly not unusual to get one of these storms in March, and then it gets very cold,” he said. “But the record lows are in single digits. Friday temperatures should get up to 40.”

Dan Majors: 412-263-1456 or dmajors@post-gazette.com

Pa. Gov. Tom Wolf describes effort to escort child in need of a heart transplant: