A panel of three judges — one in Arizona, one in Hawaii, and one in California — is scheduled to address the question of whether a nationwide halt to President Donald Trump’s travel ban will stand.

Although the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals refused to grant the federal’s government’s request for an emergency stay of the district court’s opinion from Friday, it received final briefs on the matter Monday evening and slated oral argument by telephone for today at 6 p.m. EST.

University of Pittsburgh law professor Arthur Hellman, an expert on the 9th Circuit, said the motions panel this month for the 9th Circuit is composed of Senior Judges William C. Canby Jr., who sits in Arizona and was appointed by President Jimmy Carter; Richard R. Clifton, who sits in Hawaii and was appointed by President George W. Bush; and Michelle T. Friedland, who sits in California and was appointed by President Barack Obama.

The 9th Circuit includes Washington, California, Arizona, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon and Alaska. There are 25 active judges on the court, and just six of those were appointed by Republican presidents, Mr. Hellman said.

Advertise with us

“It’s very definitely a liberal circuit,” he said. “There’s no question about that.”

Mr. Hellman said he was not surprised by the appellate court’s decision over the weekend to reject the administration’s emergency request to stay the temporary restraining order issued Friday by U.S. District Judge James L. Robart in Seattle.

“Whatever they do, they’re going to want it to be right,” Mr. Hellman said. “They’re going to take the time to do that.”

Had the court granted the emergency stay, that would have reinstated the travel ban before a determination was made whether it is constitutional, which could lead to further confusion for those affected by the executive order.

“They want to bring some order into what has been a pretty chaotic series of events,” Mr. Hellman said.

Advertise with us

There are several legal questions associated with the 9th Circuit appeal, including whether the states of Washington and Minnesota even have standing to challenge the travel ban and whether states can assert due process rights. There is also a question raised by the states that the federal government has no basis for appealing to the circuit court the granting of a temporary restraining order.

While there is an argument there, Mr. Hellman said, it is unlikely the appellate court would hinge the case on that.

“When you have this kind of a clash between two states and the federal government, the court would not be comfortable deciding on what looks like a technical basis,” he said.

Were the federal government to lose before the three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit, it would have two options: ask for an en banc review by 11 members of the circuit court or ask the U.S. Supreme Court to take up the issue of the stay. However, with the Supreme Court currently composed of just eight justices who are ideologically split 4 to 4, it is likely that the issue would be decided upon those lines, and a tie reverts back to the Circuit Court’s decision.

Asking for the en banc review is possible, Mr. Hellman said, because, even if the Trump administration were to lose, it might at least receive a strong dissenting opinion to use as support in presenting the case to the Supreme Court. That process could occur in just days, he added.

Advertise with us

“The 9th Circuit can act very, very quickly,” Mr. Hellman said. “They can act with extraordinary speed.”

Interestingly, in 2015, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals halted an executive order signed by President Obama in which he granted semi-permanent residency status to millions of illegal immigrants. That preliminary injunction remains in place because of the 4 to 4 split on the U.S. Supreme Court.

No matter what scenario plays out in the travel ban, Mr. Hellman believes that if the administration loses, and the temporary restraining order on the ban remains in place, the federal government must abide by it.

“Until they get that order stayed or vacated, the government is bound by it,” Mr. Hellman said. “It’s a basic principle.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.