WASHINGTON — In the clearest sign yet of the impact of Justice Antonin Scalia’s death, U.S. labor unions scored a major victory Tuesday with a tie vote in a high-profile Supreme Court case they had once seemed all but certain to lose.
The tie vote came amid a political standoff over President Barack Obama’s nomination of appeals court Judge Merrick Garland to fill Justice Scalia’s vacant seat. Judge Garland met Tuesday with Sen. Mark Kirk, R-Ill., his first meeting with a GOP senator.
The 4-4 split, in a case that sharply divided the court’s liberal union supporters and their conservative opponents, demonstrated how much is riding on Mr. Obama’s effort to replace Justice Scalia with a judge who could tilt the balance on the high court for years to come. Senate Republicans say they won’t consider any nomination until a new president takes office.
The vacancy helped the liberals this time. The deadlocked vote came in a case that considered whether unions representing government employees can collect fees from workers who choose not to join. California teachers backed by a conservative group said being forced to pay union fees violated the free-speech rights of nonmembers who disagree with the union’s policy positions.
The split vote left in place an appeals court ruling that upheld the collection of “fair share” fees from nonmembers. Union members will keep paying higher dues that also cover explicitly political expenses.
The result was viewed as an unlikely reprieve for organized labor. It had seemed to many as virtually certain that the high court would rule 5-4 to overturn a system that’s been in place nearly 40 years. But the court now is operating with only eight justices after the Feb. 13 death of Justice Scalia, who had been expected to rule against the unions.
Read More
The one-sentence opinion issued Tuesday did not identify how each justice voted. It simply upheld a decision from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
But it was a blow to conservative groups that have spent years pushing the court to overrule a 1977 precedent that allows unions to collect fees from members and nonmembers alike to cover the costs of collective bargaining.
Union officials feared a ruling barring the fees would threaten membership and further weaken the clout of unions, which are major supporters of Democratic candidates and causes. Labor leaders called the lawsuit part of a coordinated effort by conservative groups to weaken labor rights.
Meanwhile, Mr. Kirk criticized GOP leaders’ refusal to hold confirmation hearings or a vote on the longtime federal judge and praised him as “one of the most eminent jurists in the country.”
But there were no signs seen that the session would erode Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell’s insistence on leaving the vacancy unfilled until Mr. Obama’s replacement names a selection. Even so, Mr. Kirk’s 20-minute session with Judge Garland provided Democrats with a visual image they hope will pressure other Republicans to end their blockade.
He’s one of just three Senate Republicans to say the Senate Judiciary Committee should hold hearings on Judge Garland.
White House spokesman Josh Earnest said the 4-4 tie rather than a majority ruling “is not what our founders intended.”
But conservative groups said the split underscored the risk of replacing Justice Scalia with someone more liberal.
The union case is just one among a handful of key disputes this term in which Justice Scalia’s vote had been expected to tip the balance toward a conservative result. During arguments in the case in January, Justice Scalia and the court’s four other conservatives had made it clear they were prepared to deal a blow to the unions.
Since Supreme Court decisions are not final until they’re handed down, nothing Justice Scalia did or said in connection with the case before his death mattered in the outcome.
Union officials have worried that the potential loss of tens of millions of dollars in fees would reduce their power to bargain for higher wages and benefits for government employees. More than 5 million workers in 23 states and Washington, D.C., are required to pay fair-share fees to public-sector unions that represent them in bargaining. Unions say the fees are necessary because the organization has a legal duty to represent all teachers, even those who are not members of the union.
McClatchy Newspapers contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.