WASHINGTON — A majority of the Supreme Court were seen as ready Monday to agree with a group of California teachers who say it violates their First Amendment rights to be forced to pay dues to the state’s teachers union.
A 40-year-old precedent allows states to permit unions to collect a so-called agency fee from non-members to support collective bargaining activities. The case affects more than 5 million workers in 23 states — including California — and Washington, D.C.
Public employee unions say such fees are essential to their well-being, and that challenges to the arrangement are born of conservative efforts to weaken their strength. Liberal justices during an hour and a half of oral arguments said the challengers had not supplied the kind of evidence required for the court to overturn a precedent.
But the court’s conservative majority in 2012 and 2014 expressed grave doubts about the 1977 decision in Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, and little reason was seen after the oral arguments for unions to think the majority was not ready to now finish it off.
Justice Antonin Scalia in the past has expressed sympathy for the view that the unions needed to collect the fees to prevent “free riders” — those who benefit from the agreements unions reach with government employers but do not pay for the union’s costs.
But he did not pose any questions Monday that favored the union’s view and said he doubted whether such fees were necessary to union survival.
Justice Anthony Kennedy, the member viewed as most likely on other issues to side with the court’s four consistent liberals to form a majority, seemed hostile to the union’s arguments.
In the public sphere, he said, negotiations between unions and government could not be separated from controversial public policy questions such as merit pay for teachers or layoff policies that rely on seniority rather than teacher performance.
Those teachers who disagree with the union position should not have to subsidize views with which they disagree, Justice Kennedy said, adding that the current system creates “a whole class of persons whose speech has been silenced.”
Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito joined Justices Scalia and Kennedy in aiming skeptical questions at union and government lawyers. The fifth member of the 2014 majority, Justice Clarence Thomas, followed his usual practice of asking no questions.
Justice Elena Kagan defended the status quo and said the challengers “come here with a heavy burden” by asking the court to overturn a precedent that has been in place for four decades and on which both government and unions have come to rely.
Justice Stephen Breyer took a similar tack, suggesting the overturning a decades-old precedent would undermine the public’s confidence in the judiciary.
“You start overruling things, what happens to the country thinking of us as a kind of stability?” Justice Breyer asked.
The Obama administration also weighed in to support the unions. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli told the justices that there has been no change in circumstances over the past 40 years to warrant overturning Abood.
But it seemed after arguments that the most the unions could hope for was a reprieve — perhaps remanding the case back for additional fact-finding on exactly the impact unions would feel if agency fees were not required.
The case does not affect private employers, and about 25 states do not require such payments to public employee unions. But about 80 percent of workers represented by public-employee unions are in states that don’t, including California, New York and Illinois. Federal worker unions also are not allowed agency fees, although Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg noted that federal workers may not negotiate for pay raises.
The unions say such fees are fair because they are required to negotiate on behalf of all workers, not just their own members.
The group of 10 teachers that filed the challenge wants the high court to overturn the 1977 case that allows public unions to collect money from members and non-members alike, as long as the funds aren’t spent for political action.
The challengers argue that public-sector unions have become more political over time. They say even a push for higher salaries and pension benefits raises political questions about the best use of tax dollars for cash-strapped localities.
A federal district court ruled against the teachers, saying the outcome was clear under Abood. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed.
Rebecca Friedrichs and other California teachers have given the majority a clear chance to overrule the precedent. “Every individual should have the right to decide” which organization she supports, said Ms. Friedrichs, a third-grade teacher from Anaheim whose case is championed by conservative legal organizations.
Being excused from paying for the union’s political activities is not enough, she said. Public-employee union negotiations necessarily affect public policy decisions on government spending and taxes and issues such as seniority and educational policy.
Labor leaders call the challenge a “radical” attack on public employee unions, one of the strongest segments of the organized labor movement. Laura Juran, a lawyer for the California Teachers Association, said teachers who disagree with the union’s views “are perfectly free to speak as citizens” to try to influence government decisions.
The partisan significance of the case was seen as clear. Public employee unions have been viewed as becoming a major player in Democratic politics, generating campaign contributions and on-the-ground support for candidates. At the same time, disputes between the unions and Republican governors have become frequent and bitter.
A decision in the case, Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association, 14-915, is expected by late June.
Associated Press and Bloomberg News contributed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.