NILES, Ohio — President William McKinley’s mark on the town of his birth is hard to miss.

A towering white monument, erected in Cherokee marble quarried in Georgia, stands near the center of this city, no more than a block from the 25th president’s childhood home. A statue of McKinley gazes out through iconic columns set amid well-tended gardens.

With the removal of the McKinley name from North America’s tallest peak, the William McKinley Memorial here serves as one of the last tributes to the president. And residents of his birthplace about 78 miles from Pittsburgh are concerned he will fade into history now that the Alaskan peak that was Mount McKinley is Denali.

“He has the mountain and that’s pretty much it. He just doesn’t have a lot, even in Washington, D.C.,” said Patrick Finan, director of the McKinley Memorial Library. “None of the sites dedicated to McKinley are national sites, so he’s kind of been forgotten.” Ohio lawmakers — including U.S. House Speaker John Boehner, a Repubilcan; U.S. Sen. Rob Portman, also a Republican; and governor and Republican presidential candidate John Kasich — decried the change.

Advertise with us

Mr. Finan, however, said the name change, announced by the Obama administration on the eve of the president’s visit to Alaska, was inevitable. In 1975, Alaskans began an effort to restore its name in the Koyukon Athabaskan language, Denali, which roughly translates as “the high one.”

“We received a proposal from Alaska Gov. Jay Hammond asking the secretary of the interior to change the name based on a resolution by the Alaska Legislature,” said Lou Yost, executive secretary for the U.S. Board on Geographic Names, the federal governmental body responsible for naming geographic features in the United States.

Read More

Ralph Regula, then an Ohio Republican congressman whose district included Canton, where McKinley spent most of his life, opposed restoring the old name. He gathered signatures from other Ohio lawmakers and no action was taken until 1980, when President Jimmy Carter signed the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act, incorporating McKinley National Park into a larger protected area named Denali National Park and Preserve.

That was considered a compromise by some, but Alaskans continued to press for the name change for the peak itself. Mr. Regula took advantage of a longtime practice by the Board on Geographic Names to not act on a name when legislation on the name is pending before Congress.

Mr. Regula, now retired and living on his farm in Stark County, Ohio, recalled: “What I did — bottom line — the board would not change the name of any landmark as long as there was legislation pending in Congress. So what I did every two years, I’d put a bill in officially naming it Mount McKinley, so they couldn’t act because there was legislation pending.”

Advertise with us

“Since Rep. Regula kept submitting the bills, the board couldn’t take action,” Mr. Yost said. When Mr. Regula retired in 2009, “the tradition was carried on,” Mr. Yost said. There have been other efforts to block name changes by the board, he said, “but nothing like this, for 40 years.”

After all that time, the Sunday announcement that the Obama administration would rename the mountain hit the town hard.

“It just goes to show how fast things change, and it’s not always for the good,” said Tom Lewis, 71, a lifelong resident of Niles.

“How can you go back and change history just because one person decided to do it?” asked Wayne Thompson, 66, who was visiting the memorial from Lake Texoma, Okla.

Mr. Regula disapproved of Mr. Obama’s decision.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think he has the authority to do that. I think it’s a cheap shot by the president to make a certain group of people in Alaska happy.”

As to what connection McKinley had with a peak in Alaska, Mr. Regula said: “Over the years, we’ve named landmarks after presidents. This is not a unique thing at all. I think McKinley was a visionary president. McKinley is the highest peak in North America. He deserves it.”

But it was merely a fluke of political history that got an Alaska mountain named for an Ohio-born president who never set foot in what was then a territory.

The mountain was named after the Republican nominee for president in 1896 by William Dickey, a gold prospector. Mr. Dickey wrote an account of his travels through Alaska for the New York Sun that year and announced he’d named the peak “after William McKinley of Ohio, who had been nominated for the presidency, and that fact was the first news we received on our way out of the wonderful wilderness.” McKinley was an outspoken proponent of the gold standard, so Mr. Dickey had reason to want to see him succeed.

Still, the Niles community lamented a decision that made its members feel as though their beloved son’s legacy had been assassinated, just as the president himself was in 1901.

Advertise with us

“Just speaking for myself personally, I would say that it is a disappointment,” said Trish Scarmuzzi, curator of the McKinley Memorial Museum. However, “I understand that the Native Americans should also have the name, too.”

The restoration of the native name garnered attention for Barack Obama’s three-day trip to Alaska, but the main purpose of the visit is an effort to encourage action on climate change. Mr. Obama arrived Monday afternoon at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, just outside of Anchorage. He met with Alaska Natives after he arrived, then spoke on climate change and the Arctic at a State Department-sponsored conference involving Arctic and non-Arctic leaders.

While in Alaska today and Wednesday, Mr. Obama will meet with fishermen, tape a special episode of the NBC reality show “Running Wild with Bear Grylls,” hike a melting glacier and tour a national park by boat. He’ll close his trip with a visit to the tiny town of Kotzebue, north of the Arctic Circle.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352. Associated Press contributed.