When Jeff Parish signed onto his TurboTax account recently, he was surprised to see that the popular online filing service had already calculated a federal refund — to the tune of more than $5,000. But there was a problem. The 61-year-old marketing executive from Fairfax, Va., was just starting the process of filing his taxes, not finishing it. Somebody had broken into his account, completed a fraudulent return and diverted Mr. Parish’s refund to a pre-paid debit card.
As tax season moves into its busiest stretch, such unpleasant surprises await hundreds of thousands — some experts say millions — of Americans as the fallout from an unprecedented surge in online tax scams hits home. People counting on a quick windfall will discover they instead are victims of an audacious gang of online criminals who systematically targeted TurboTax, the nation’s largest online filing service.
The attacks highlighted the perilous security of the nation’s overstretched systems for online tax collection. A spike in the use of services such as TurboTax has coincided with deep cuts to the Internal Revenue Service, which along with state taxation authorities has struggled to adapt to the rising sophistication of online criminals.
As fraud rises sharply, Intuit — which makes TurboTax — said some states saw a 37-fold increase in suspicious returns earlier this year — it remains unclear who is responsible for combating the problem. TurboTax files millions of returns each year that its internal screening algorithms have flagged as “suspicious,” internal documents show, and the company said it does not immediately alert taxation authorities.
It is ultimately up to the IRS to reject a return and determine if it is fraudulent, Intuit added. “We do not have that authority,” the company said in a statement.
“If any one company, ours or any other company, decided to take a whole bunch of actions that would 100 percent determine that every single one of their customers was exactly who they said they were, that would not stop fraud in the industry,” said David Williams, Intuit’s chief tax officer. “It would just push the fraud around, it would squeeze the balloon and push it anywhere.”
But critics said Intuit and other tax software providers have a responsibility to protect the integrity of the tax filing system. Several cybersecurity analysts added that the company is only now adding security measures that have been used by email and social media companies for years.
“They can’t blame everything on the IRS. That’s ridiculous,” said Ed Mierzwinski, consumer program director at U.S. PIRG.
“I think that both the IRS and the states need to up their game,” he said. “The agencies have been starved. They have not gotten adequate funding to protect people’s financial lives in the way that they should. … They’re not keeping up with the bad guys.”
Among Intuit’s critics are two former employees, who said they protested Intuit’s decision not to halt fraudulent returns when they worked at the company.
One of them, Shane MacDougall, who was a principal security engineer at Intuit until last month, recently filed a whistleblower complaint with the Securities Exchange Commission that alleges Intuit chose not to take needed security measures because executives worried those actions would cut into the company’s market share.
“One of the main reasons that I left was that Intuit was seemingly unwilling to implement even the most basic safeguards to protect their users that we were recommending,” Mr. MacDougall said. “Something like preventing multiple people from using the same Social Security number is extremely simple to do and that would stop a ton of fraud.”
Intuit vehemently denied the charge, adding that the company voluntarily shares reports about suspicious returns on a three-week delay with the IRS and is discussing whether to accelerate the process. “This is not a company that profits from fraud,” said Intuit spokeswoman Julie Miller. “And if there is any that gets through it would certainly be immaterial for the business.”
The fraud problem does not appear to be a small one at Intuit. An internal strategy presentation obtained by The Washington Post showed that the number of suspicious accounts identified by Intuit grew from about 900,000 in 2010 to about 2.5 million in 2012. About 29 million people used TurboTax last year.
The spike in fraudulent online tax returns this year has drawn the attention of the FBI, which is investigating the matter, and Congress, where the Senate Finance Committee plans to hold a hearing on identity theft and tax fraud later this month.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.