PALO ALTO, Calif. -- Critics began panning the first leg of California's futuristic high-speed rail network as a "train to nowhere" soon after officials decided to build it not in the major population centers of Los Angeles or San Francisco, but rather through the state's Central Valley farming belt.
Since then, things have only gotten worse. Spiraling cost estimates and eroding political and public support now threaten a project crucial to a 21st-century vision of train travel that President Barack Obama promised would transform U.S. transportation much as interstate highways did more than half a century ago.
A national high-speed rail network would not only support tens of thousands of construction and manufacturing jobs but also would get Americans out of their cars, revitalize struggling downtowns and spare the environment millions of tons of carbon emissions and travelers untold hours wasted in traffic or in airport terminals waiting out delays.
Mr. Obama set a goal of providing 80 percent of Americans access to high-speed rail within 25 years. But that lofty vision is yielding to the political gravity generated by high costs, determined opponents and a public that has grown dubious of government's ability to do big things. Virtually none of the projects have gotten off the ground, and the one that has is in trouble.
For Mr. Obama, the political stakes are high going into the 2012 election. Republican front-runner Mitt Romney has accused him of putting too much faith in government to build the economy. The president, Mr. Romney says to the delight of GOP partisans, "does not know" how business, or the economy, works.
The plan that envisions bullet trains zipping between the nation's major cities at speeds as fast as 220 mph was one of the few transformative projects included in the $797 billion stimulus program enacted early in Mr. Obama's presidency. "Imagine whisking through towns at speeds over 100 miles an hour, walking only a few steps to public transportation and ending up just blocks from your destination," Mr. Obama said in announcing his vision for high-speed rail in April 2009.
So far, Mr. Obama has wagered more than $10 billion in federal money on high-speed rail, only to see his plans diminished, one after another.
Republican governors in Florida, Wisconsin and Ohio turned back billions of dollars in federal money for high-speed rail, denouncing the proposals both as creations of big government and as economically unfeasible.
The objections in those three states left money to be redirected to a host of projects that promise to relieve bottlenecks and speed up traditional rail service in many parts of the country. But those improvements fall short of the transformative promise of high-speed rail.
House Republicans were also among those who dug in against Mr. Obama's vision for high-speed rail, saying that outside select regions, it did not fit a sprawling, car-loving nation served by nearly 50,000 miles of interstate highways and an extensive air travel network.
Now, the nation's only pending true high-speed rail project is facing a crisis moment in California, a Democratic stronghold known for innovation. Few places would benefit more from the trains.
California's urban areas are notorious for hair-raising traffic jams. The skies between San Francisco and Los Angeles -- the busiest U.S. route -- are so packed that 25 percent of flights between the two cities are at least one hour late, state officials say. And with the state's population projected to soar by 50 percent over the next four decades, the congestion is expected only to grow more dire.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.