WASHINGTON -- Barely an hour had passed since Sen. Bob Casey voted against denying federal funds to Planned Parenthood on Thursday when the Family Research Council announced its intention to launch an advertising campaign against his re-election.
The Susan B. Anthony List followed Friday morning with its own vow to take on Mr. Casey, a Catholic, anti-abortion Democrat who always seems to walk a tightrope in the abortion debate.
For the son of Gov. Robert P. Casey, the man whose administration argued Planned Parenthood v. Casey to the U.S. Supreme Court in a failed attempt to overturn Roe v. Wade, it's always been a delicate balance. Mr. Casey is anti-abortion but favors contraception and preventative health, often couching his political stances in the language of what's practical -- will this reduce the number of abortions?
He determined yes in the case of Planned Parenthood.
"One of the best ways to reduce abortion is to have family planning available, and an organization like Planned Parenthood provides a whole range of services," he said this week.
It's a view that has often earned him criticism, with opponents at times raising the ghost of the elder Casey.
During Mr. Casey's first Senate campaign in 2006 he smarted when then-Sen. Rick Santorum criticized Mr. Casey's support for the Plan B emergency contraception bill during a debate, saying "I think his father would be very upset if he were alive today and heard him be supportive of something like this."
In late 2009, as Mr. Casey helped negotiate a compromise on abortion coverage in the health care overhaul bill, the Susan B. Anthony List ran a television ad in his hometown of Scranton featuring the face and words of Gov. Casey and accusing the son of backing a bill that promoted taxpayer funding for abortion.
The most recent controversy arose during the spending imbroglio. House Republicans, in an amendment to their spending bill sponsored by Rep. Mike Pence, R-Ind., stripped funding from Title X, which provides family planning and preventive health services. The debate was less about saving the $317 million handed out last year by Title X than it was about Planned Parenthood, the nationwide chain of health centers that provides contraception, health screenings and abortions that took home about a quarter of the sum.
In the final days of negotiations on a six-month funding bill among congressional leaders and President Barack Obama, the Planned Parenthood issue became a key sticking point. In the end, Title X funds were preserved in the deal that passed Congress this week, but the deal required a pair of votes in the Senate on defunding the health care overhaul law and Title X.
The nakedly political votes were designed to fail, while producing a tally of targets for the 2012 elections. One of them is Mr. Casey.
The first-term senator isn't considered among the most vulnerable in what is sure to by a tumultuous election cycle, and he has yet to draw a well-known opponent. A poll released Friday by Democrat-leaning Public Policy Polling shows his approval rating at only 39 percent, but Mr. Casey has healthy leads on a group of possible opponents, topping 50 percent in hypothetical matchups with state Sen. Jake Corman, U.S. Reps. Jim Gerlach and Charlie Dent, tea party activist Laureen Cummings and Murrysville native and attorney Marc Scaringi.
But in a state where Republicans swept gubernatorial and senatorial elections last year, Mr. Casey's race is sure to be a tough one. He's already gearing up his financial operation, raising $1.1 million in the first three months of the year.
A Supreme Court decision last year opened the floodgates for outside spending in elections, and this cycle should be no different. FRC has formed the Faith Family Freedom Fund, a so-called "Super PAC" that can take in unlimited donations and spend unlimited amounts on its priorities -- in this case, attacking candidates whose views on abortion are out of sync with its own.
The group has its eye on 18 Senate races next year, including incumbent Democrats like Mr. Casey, open seats and Maine's Olympia Snowe, who was one of five Republicans to vote against defunding Planned Parenthood.
"In the coming months, we will work to make sure that voters are fully aware of Senator Casey's vote to send their hard-earned dollars to this scandal-plagued abortion organization," the fund's chairwoman, Connie Mackey, said in a news release.
Mr. Casey's not exactly getting counter-fire from Planned Parenthood, either, as the organization disagrees with his anti-abortion stance. Rebecca Cavanaugh, spokeswoman for Planned Parenthood of Western Pennsylvania, said the organization isn't going to endorse him but would be happy to inform supporters of Mr. Casey's "pro-prevention" record.
Casey spokesman Larry Smar dismissed the anti-abortion groups' challenge, saying the same folks opposed Mr. Casey in 2006, too. He pointed to Mr. Casey's work on practical anti-abortion initiatives, extending the adoption tax credit and creating a fund in the health care overhaul law to support young pregnant women with funds for school and other things so they won't choose abortion.
"He stands up for his beliefs and he's consistent in supporting those beliefs," Mr. Smar said, "and he's not going to back down even though it can be a lonely place sometimes."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.