WASHINGTON -- A car dealer from Butler, Mike Kelly ran a successful campaign to unseat U.S. Rep. Kathy Dahlkemper, D-Erie, playing up his small business experience and distaste for the current state of affairs in the nation's capital.

But for his chief of staff, Mr. Kelly hired experienced Washington hand Karen Czarnecki, a George W. Bush administration Department of Labor official who most recently worked at the Heritage Foundation conservative think tank.

As the large incoming Republican class makes the transition from candidate to member of Congress, hiring a staff presents a challenging balancing act between staying true to campaign ideals and assembling a competent team. Even the most virulent anti-Washington member acknowledges that it's important to learn the ways of the capital in order to change it, so Mr. Kelly sees no contradiction in hiring a D.C. veteran to lead his staff.

"I'm not looking for dealmakers," he said. "I'm looking for somebody that actually knows and can navigate the waters."

Advertise with us

Mr. Kelly said the hiring process isn't much different from what he's done for decades in the car business, but staffing Mike Kelly Chevrolet Cadillac certainly didn't carry as much scrutiny as his Congressional hires.

"I can see how someone would say it doesn't strike the right chord: You want to bring a new way of thinking to Washington and that's what you campaigned on, yet you decided to hire somebody who's been down there for an entire career and may not get a fresh set of eyes on a problem," said David Urban, a Washington lobbyist and former chief of staff to then-Republican Sen. Arlen Specter, when asked about Mr. Kelly's hire of Ms. Czarnecki.

"The flip side is this is a woman who's been obviously thinking about how to solve some of these problems her entire career and has been working on some of these problems for her entire career."

Mr. Urban, a Beaver County native, had no Washington experience when Mr. Specter hired him as chief of staff in 1997, but he said he was helped by the large and skilled group already in place. A House member has maybe a half-dozen people in Washington, and the body's rule structure is difficult to grasp quickly.

Former Rep. Phil English, a Republican who held the Third District seat before Mrs. Dahlkemper, said he arrived under comparable circumstances in the 1994 GOP surge.

Advertise with us

"I came in as part of a very similar wave of people who were critical of the Washington status quo and there were many members there who selected people of their personal experience or campaign infrastructure, and some of those appointments worked and some of them did not," said Mr. English, who hired a veteran of Pennsylvania's state government who also had Washington experience as his chief of staff.

"The key thing here to understand is the only way a member of the House -- one out of 435 members with a vote -- gets anything done is by working as part of a team. And they need to have staff who can support what they try to do on the floor, what they try to do in their district, what they try to do in their committee."

Mr. English said the current Republican leadership was mindful of some of the cautionary tales of the 1994 class -- which had some ineffective offices -- when it distributed a list of potential chiefs of staff to incoming members.

"This from a team standpoint was probably the right thing to do," he said. "The challenge to it is if the leadership could be criticized for only putting forward people who were, shall we say, antiseptic, who were pre-cleared, and I haven't seen any real evidence of that."

It's still early in the hiring process, but news reports show that new Republican members have largely heeded the leadership's advice -- with one glaring exception. Rep. Allen West, R-Fla., announced shortly after the election that his chief of staff would be conservative radio host Joyce Kaufman, whose anti-establishment rhetoric at times has been militant. In the resulting outcry, Ms. Kaufman stepped down.

Advertise with us

The task of staffing Senate offices in Washington and throughout the state is a much larger task, and Sen.-elect Pat Toomey, R-Pa., has yet to make a hire. Mr. Toomey's campaign manager, Mark Harris, said Mr. Toomey is still sifting through the 1,200 resumes that have poured in since Election Day.

Mr. Harris said the Toomey transition team is working with Sen. Arlen Specter's office on clerical tasks, such as handling the enormous amounts of mail and phone calls a senatorial office gets.

The communication deluge is one reason hiring well is so important to a member of Congress: Your staff is your stand-in with the public, more often than not.

"You're never going to be able to meet everyone in your district or respond to all of them personally," Mr. Urban said. "If a young [staff member] is impolite on the phone -- there's their impression of you. You develop a bad reputation for poor constituent service, you have people who don't answer the phone, it's a sure way to lose."

Mr. Kelly said he will treat constituent service like he does customer service in running his car dealerships. He'll hire bright people with experience in their fields -- be it folks who know how to navigate the legislative process or Mercer County.

"Politics, at least for me, it doesn't hold this mystery that people think it does," Mr. Kelly said. "You're serving a group of people."