The nation's recording industry, bolstered by a major victory this month when a federal jury slapped a Minnesota woman with a $222,000 fine for illegally downloading 24 copyrighted songs, may be aggressively going after consumers who pirate music through illegal downloads.
But for those who download, doing the right thing isn't always easy. In the Wild West of digital music, copy protection rules change from service to service and have an impact on how and where listeners can hear the music they download.
Imagine, for example, buying a CD and finding out it would play only in certain brands of CD players. Or that you didn't really buy it -- you're renting it by the month and it will stop playing when the monthly payments stop.
That's the situation digital music consumers face under the current copy protection system overseeing downloaded music files. The industry's two giants -- Microsoft and iTunes -- have created systems that make it harder to bootleg files. But in the process, those systems -- Microsoft's Digital Rights Management (DRM) and iTunes' FairPlay DRM -- limit how the buyer can hear them.
Richard Menta, editor of the online magazine MP3 Newswire, compares buying DRM-protected music to "paying for ice."
"The restrictions go beyond protecting tracks from being traded online -- a protection that is moot as all of these songs have been freely available on the file-sharing applications for years. It is used to lock consumers to proprietary technology. It is used to control supply and push higher prices," Mr. Menta wrote in an edition last year.
Clearly, the system is confusing for consumers. Musicload, a European online music store, reported that three out of four customer service calls are related to confusion or problems with DRM. The protection system "makes the use of music quite difficult and hinders the development of a mass-market for legal downloads," it concluded.
As currently set up, protected files under the Microsoft and iTunes systems contain software that restricts the way the downloaded songs can be used.
In some cases, the songs can be played only on certain devices, like an iPod. To listen to music on some other systems, the user pays a subscription fee and the files won't work when the subscription expires. Other services sell MP3 files that will play on any device and can be copied over and over. The trade-off: Those sites usually offer fewer big-label artists and more independent music. Which service you choose really depends on what kind of music consumer you are.
For example, monthly subscription services are good for people who want to check out current music, which they can dump when the next new thing comes along. But people who want to keep a copy of their downloads will want to go with a service that lets them burn CDs.
Moreover, people who like mainstream artists and want to download legally will probably have to live with some form of copy protection, while those who favor indie and lesser-known artists will find plenty of choice among unprotected MP3s.
Those aren't the only issues for digital music retailers, whose answers to piracy haven't solved the problem -- for themselves or for their customers.
Microsoft's DRM has been criticized for its closed-system and restrictive policy that limits how and where the music people buy can be played. And until April, Apple was under fire because iTunes purchases could be played only on an iPod, shutting out a large selection of competitive portable players.
And like any other security system on the Internet, online music pirates and even legal buyers continue to find ways to circumvent Apple's and Microsoft's barriers, with their efforts documented in detail online. Further, so-called stream-ripping software that allows a computer user to record audio and video from Web sites is readily available, making piracy easy even for non-hackers.
Because copy protection hasn't been all that effective, the big digital retailers are rethinking their strategies. In May, iTunes began offering a portion of its large library in DRM-free form. Next month, Zune will offer a selection of DRM-free files that will play on other MP3 players, giving shoppers access to more than 1 million DRM-free tracks, as well as videos and podcasts.
Even Microsoft Chief Executive Officer Bill Gates has admitted that DRM had "huge problems." During a speech last year, he surprised the audience by telling them they should "just buy a CD and rip it."
After reading the fine print in the download stores' user agreements, it seems like a simple and elegant solution.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.