WASHINGTON -- President Bush invigorated proponents of teaching alternatives to evolution in public schools with remarks saying schoolchildren should be taught about "intelligent design," a view of creation that challenges established scientific thinking and promotes the idea that an unseen force is behind the development of humanity.

Although he said curriculum decisions should be made by school districts rather than the federal government, Bush on Monday told Texas newspaper reporters in a group interview at the White House that he believes that intelligent design should be taught alongside evolution as competing theories.

"Both sides ought to be properly taught, ... so people can understand what the debate is about," he said, according to an official transcript of the session. Bush added, "Part of education is to expose people to different schools of thought. ... You're asking me whether or not people ought to be exposed to different ideas, and the answer is yes."

These comments drew sharp criticism yesterday from liberals, who said there is no scientific evidence to support intelligent design theory and no educational basis for teaching it.

Advertise with us

The White House yesterday said Bush's comments were in keeping with positions dating to his Texas governorship, but aides say they could not recall his ever addressing the issue while president. His remarks heartened conservatives who have been asking school boards and legislatures nationwide to teach students that there are gaps in evolutionary theory and to explain that life's complexity is evidence of a guiding hand.

"With the president endorsing it, at the very least it makes Americans who have that position more respectable, for lack of a better phrase," said Gary Bauer, a Christian conservative leader who ran for president against Bush in the 2000 Republican primaries. "It's not some backwater view. It's a view held by the majority of Americans."

John West, an executive with the Discovery Institute, a Seattle-based think tank supporting intelligent design, issued a written statement welcoming Bush's remarks. "President Bush is to be commended for defending free speech on evolution, and supporting the right of students to hear about different scientific views about evolution," he said.

Opponents of intelligent design, which a Kansas professor once derided as "creationism in a cheap tuxedo," say there is no legitimate debate. They see the case increasingly as a political battle that threatens to weaken science teaching in a nation whose students already are falling behind.

"It is, of course, further indication that a fundamentalist right has really taken over much of the Republican Party," said Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass., a leading liberal in Congress. Noting Bush's own Ivy League education, Frank said, "People might cite George Bush as proof that you can be totally impervious to the effects of Harvard and Yale education."

Advertise with us

Bush's comments were "irresponsible," said Barry Lynn, executive director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State. He said the president, by suggesting that students ought to hear two viewpoints, "doesn't understand that one is a religious viewpoint and one is a scientific viewpoint." Lynn said Bush showed a "low level of understanding of science," adding that he worried that Bush's comments could be followed by a directive to the Justice Department to support legal efforts to change curricula.

Bush gave no sign that he intended to wade that far into the debate. The issue came up only when a reporter from Knight-Ridder news service asked him about it; participants said the president did not seem especially eager to be asked. "Very interesting question," he told the reporter playfully.

At a briefing yesterday, White House press secretary Scott McClellan said Bush was simply restating longstanding views.