Federal officials are getting slammed for locking up a foreign student without bail. And they are being slammed for not detaining 30 foreigners with known connections to terrorism.

Amy Otten, spokeswoman for the Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, acknowledges plenty of rock-and-hard-place moments at a bureau that is an easy target for those on either side of the debate over dealing with foreign visitors in the post-9/11 world.

"There certainly has been a lot of criticism that we haven't been aware enough of who's here, that we should be doing more to keep track of them," said Otten.

Last week, a General Accounting Office report concluded that poor communication and follow-through among government agencies had allowed 30 foreign visitors linked to terrorism to enter and remain in the United States even though the State Department had revoked their visas.

Advertise with us

"But when we put a program in place that attempts to do that, it gets criticism," Otten continued, referring to the Special Registration program and the local case in which a Jordanian student from La Roche College was detained and held without bail for failing to comply with the registration deadline.

Special Registration has been controversial since it was announced and continues to be so even as it is being superseded by a new program.

The requirement that men from 25 predominantly Muslim countries appear before authorities to be photographed, fingerprinted and interviewed was announced by the Justice Department late last year as a component of the effort to identify potential terrorists.

In December, Immigration and Naturalization Service officials in California detained more than 400 men who were attempting to register, handcuffing them and herding them into the Los Angeles federal building's basement lockup. That brought attention to the program and sparked criticism by civil rights and immigrant groups, who said Special Registration amounted to profiling -- singling people out based on race, religion or national identity.

Justice Department spokesman Jorge E. Martinez said in January that the countries were chosen because intelligence information indicated a presence of al-Qaida or other terrorist organizations there.

Advertise with us

Officials later seemed to de-emphasize the terror component. Otten characterized the program as the first step in keeping track of all nonimmigrant visitors to the United States. Immigration officials said the program would probably be extended beyond the 25 countries.

In the meantime it served as a broad net that yielded large numbers of immigration regulations violators, 13,000 of whom face deportation.

In the midst of the process, the INS ceased to exist, replaced by a set of agencies under the Department of Homeland Security. The Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, one of the successor agencies, will not say if any people detained under Special Registration have been linked to terrorism.

The La Roche College case started when local immigration authorities arrested Abdelqader K. Abu-Snaineh, 21, on campus June 10. He was held without bond first in the Allegheny County Jail, then in the York County Prison, where the federal government holds people charged with immigration violations.

The Justice Department equates missing a Special Registration deadline with failing to maintain immigrant status -- an offense that could result in deportation, said Crystal Williams, an attorney with the Washington, D.C.-based American Immigration Lawyers Association.

Advertise with us

Even so, she knew of only a couple of cases like the one at La Roche in which someone was taken into custody simply for missing a registration, and she said in those cases the government ultimately granted extensions.

Abu-Snaineh's lawyers, immigration groups and the college all labeled the detention without bond an overreaction, saying he was a student in good standing with no prior immigration violations or other problems.

Then on Tuesday, officials changed course and told Abu-Snaineh he was to be released on $1,500 bond. The college posted it Wednesday, and he returned to Pittsburgh later that day.

Otten said immigration officials can reconsider bond at any point and chose to do so last week in Abu-Snaineh's case. She said there are no hard-and-fast guidelines about what will happen to others who fail to register.

Immigrants nationwide feel besieged by a slew of new edicts, said Judith Golub, the American Immigration Lawyers Association's senior director of advocacy and public affairs. The La Roche case "reinforces the chilling message -- that if you're an immigrant post 9/11 then watch out."

Advertise with us

The government also finds itself struggling to keep up with the reams of information it is requiring and collecting in the interest of national security. It can take 120 to 160 days for information about individuals to get into the hands of officials at airports, so the officials there are unlikely to know whether departing foreign visitors are violators.

Otten acknowledged that the failure to register would not necessarily be detected at the point of departure. However, she said, were that person to try to re-enter the country, the information would come up and likely would result in some action.

"The biggest penalty would be that they wouldn't be able to come back in," she said.

Similarly, the information would come up should the person try to renew a visa, and would likely result in a denial, she said, though cases are always judged individually.

Even as officials try to decide how they'll handle the fallout from one new program, they are preparing to implement another one that will supersede Special Registration.

Advertise with us

Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge in April announced that officials next year will begin fingerprinting and photographing all visa-holding foreigners arriving at U.S. airports and seaports.

The U.S. Visitor and Immigrant Status Indication Technology system, called U.S. VISIT, will shift emphasis to ports of entry and will force other countries to do fingerprinting and screening for passports.

It would affect about 23 million visitors each year.

It will use at least two "biometric identifiers," such as photographs, fingerprints or iris scans, to build an electronic check in/check out system for people coming to the United States to work, study or visit.

Under the system, the federal government is also demanding that by October 2004 Europe, Japan and other countries where visas are not required to visit the United States start issuing new passports with individual fingerprints encoded in the passport.

U.S. VISIT will be launched Jan. 1.