“My relationship with running must change. My love for it is stronger than ever,” Jenny Simpson, a former professional track and field athlete, said in an Aug. 20 Instagram post.
Simpson, who has medaled in Olympic and World Championship competitions, faced the news that no runner ever wants to hear.
That she will never be able to run again.
Simpson, of Boulder, Colo., suffered a cardiac event at age 39 on June 16 while pacing the Sir Walter Running Pop Up Mile in Raleigh, N.C. CPR and the use of an automated external defibrillator before paramedics arrived saved her life.
Doctors later diagnosed her with a rare, inherited heart condition called arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy (ARVC), which causes heart muscle cells to be replaced by fibrous and fatty tissue.
Over time, this can cause the walls of the right ventricle — the lower right chamber of the heart — to thin and stretch. The condition accounts for up to 20% of sudden cardiac deaths in people under age 35, according to Johns Hopkins Medicine, and can be worsened by endurance exercise.
While estimates of ARVC prevalence range from 1 in 2,000 to 1 in 5,000 people, many individuals with the condition experience mild symptoms or remain entirely asymptomatic until a cardiac event, making its true prevalence difficult to determine.
At UPMC, experts in the Heart and Vascular Institute treat and study ARVC and other inherited heart conditions, working to better understand how these diseases develop, how to identify patients at risk and how to prevent potentially fatal complications.
What happens to the heart
Aditya Bhonsale, a cardiac electrophysiologist at UPMC Heart and Vascular Institute, said ARVC is most often caused by inherited genetic changes that affect proteins responsible for holding heart muscle cells together — like Velcro between two cells.
Mutations in genes responsible for these proteins can weaken those connections. Over time, damaged heart muscle cells can die and be replaced by fibrous and fatty tissue, creating scarring that disrupts the heart’s electrical signals and can make it vulnerable to abnormal rhythms.
“ARVC predisposes individuals to both heart rhythm problems, as well as, in some cases, heart failure or congestive heart failure in the future,” Bhonsale said during a video interview.

Most inherited forms of ARVC follow an autosomal dominant pattern, meaning a child of a parent carrying one disease-causing genetic variant has a 50% chance of inheriting that variant. Inheriting it, however, does not mean someone will necessarily develop the condition.
“There are many patients who have the gene mutation but don’t manifest the disease,” Bhonsale said.
That variability is one reason family history is important. Within the same family, Bhonsale said, one person carrying a mutation may have no abnormalities on an electrocardiogram or cardiac MRI, while another may experience cardiac arrest.
And increasingly, research suggests exercise may help explain some of those differences.
When exercise becomes a risk
In a 2013 study published in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology, Bhonsale and a team of researchers at Johns Hopkins studied 87 people who carried genetic mutations associated with ARVC, asking about their physical activity beginning at age 10.
They found a dose-response relationship between exercise and the disease: Greater exercise exposure was associated with a greater likelihood of developing signs of ARVC. Endurance athletes also faced higher risks of dangerous arrhythmias and heart failure.
People who participated in endurance athletics developed symptoms about a decade earlier, on average, than those who did not. Researchers defined endurance athletes as those who participated in vigorous aerobic sports — such as distance running — for at least 50 hours per year.
“A clear signal was shown, and then shown by others as well, that participation in long-standing, moderate-to-vigorous endurance athletics, especially on a competitive basis, increases the odds of manifesting either with arrhythmias or with symptoms or with even congestive heart failure in these patients, and therefore is related to progression,” Bhonsale said.
More recently, research has raised questions about whether prolonged endurance exercise can produce ARVC-like changes even in some people without an identified disease-causing mutation.
In a 2022 editorial published in HeartRhythm Case Reports, Bhonsale and two colleagues discussed what has been called “exercise-induced ARVC,” an ARVC-like condition observed in some endurance athletes without an identified disease-causing mutation.
The editorial accompanied a case report of an endurance athlete whose heart showed structural and electrical abnormalities consistent with ARVC despite genetic testing finding no known disease-causing mutation. After the athlete stopped endurance exercise, imaging showed that some of the structural changes to the heart reversed.
Still, Bhonsale and his colleagues cautioned that exercise-induced ARVC remains a theoretical diagnosis without a definitive diagnostic test.
For Simpson — primarily a middle- and long-distance competitor who won four NCAA titles at the University of Colorado Boulder before winning an Olympic Bronze, a World Championship gold and two silvers — years of distance running may have contributed to the progression of a disease she unknowingly carried.
“When my heart was pumping blood and was dilated, at some point in my life, it was very likely the electricity was going to turn off, and that's what happened,” Simpson told CBS News in an Aug. 22 interview. “[My cardiologist] said, 'You thought you trained your whole life for the Olympics, but you were really training your whole life for June 16.' I trained my whole life for that day — and I won.”
To exercise or not to exercise
An ARVC diagnosis does not mean a person should stop moving altogether.
“It's a patient-by-patient, shared decision-making, individualized kind of prescription,” Bhonsale said.
Current guidance is that people diagnosed with ARVC avoid competitive sports and vigorous endurance exercise because of the potential for exercise to accelerate the disease and trigger dangerous arrhythmias. Lower-intensity physical activity, however, may still be appropriate.
Running, cycling and rowing are among the aerobic activities that can place sustained demands on the cardiovascular system, Bhonsale said. Activities such as walking, golf and bowling generally involve much lower aerobic demands.
“There’s also data that activities of daily living or the amount that the AHA says that you should do — say, 30 minutes of brisk walking every day — has no deleterious impact,” Bhonsale said. “One shouldn’t turn into a couch potato just because you have an ARVC diagnosis.”
For endurance athletes, however, being told to scale back can mean giving up much more than exercise.
“For others that do it, that’s what makes them happy — endurance athletics, running, going for a run every day, participating in long-distance running,” Bhonsale said. “It’s a difficult decision in terms of restriction, and it changes your lifestyle.”
Staying safe
Despite the devastating diagnosis, Simpson, now 40, said she feels “profoundly fortunate” for another chance at life.
“CPR, AED shocks, exceptional medical care, a healthy body and a fighting spirit that have spent a lifetime adapting to hard things all came together to give me another chance at life,” she said on Instagram.
For those concerned about ARVC, Bhonsale said family history is one of the most important considerations. A history of cardiomyopathy, unexplained sudden cardiac arrest or other significant heart problems in a close relative may warrant discussion with a cardiologist.
Symptoms such as unexplained lightheadedness, dizziness or feeling as though you may pass out — particularly during physical activity — should also be evaluated, he said. Sustained episodes of a suddenly racing heart, especially when accompanied by lightheadedness, can also be a warning sign.
Once someone is diagnosed with ARVC, screening family members becomes important.
“More data is needed in this field, especially not only to guide the proband — or the person in front of us — but also the first-degree family relatives,” he said. “If somebody has had cardiac arrest, then their first-degree family members should undergo comprehensive screening to make sure that, one, they don’t have the mutation and, two, they don’t have the disease.”
Simpson is continuing to receive medical guidance and treatment through Duke Health.
“My future is an incredible gift,” Simpson said on Instagram. “It’s hopeful, and it will continue to have great purpose.”
Ava Dzurenda (ava.dzurenda@gmail.com) is a science writer and exercise physiologist based in Squirrel Hill.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.