The sound is hard to miss.
From across the Center for Surgical Arts at Allegheny General Hospital, there is the rhythmic thud of hammering.
At another station, a surgeon watches a monitor as an instrument advances through a human spine.
Nearby, residents and fellows lean in closely, as internationally recognized neurosurgeons demonstrate techniques, explain anatomy and point out the structures that could turn a routine maneuver into a dangerous one.
This is not an operating room. No living patient is on the table. But the stakes of these lessons are nonetheless high.
Inside a cadaver lab at Allegheny General Hospital, spine surgeons in training were getting a rare opportunity to practice complex procedures under the watchful eyes of some of the field's most experienced surgeons.
The hands-on session was part of the 15th annual Pittsburgh Spine Summit, an intensive educational gathering hosted Aug. 6-8 by Allegheny Health Network.
The summit brought together about 50 AHN neurosurgery and orthopedic surgery residents, along with roughly 30 visiting residents and fellows from institutions around the country and beyond, for lectures, surgical skills challenges and hands-on training.
For participants, the goal is to gain experience before they are responsible for making those same decisions and incisions on their own.

For observers, the lab offers a glimpse of just how much preparation goes into becoming a spine surgeon.
“Everything in this room is high risk,” said Boyle Cheng, the conference director and director of translational research in neuroscience and orthopaedic surgery at AHN.
The spine presents surgeons with a particularly unforgiving landscape. Nerves, the spinal cord and major blood vessels can lie millimeters from the structures being manipulated.
“When you talk about degenerative disc disease or chronic low back pain, you're invariably dealing with an area that also has neural structures that could potentially be compromised as a risk associated with surgery,” Cheng said.
The master surgeons at the summit were on hand to guide those just beginning in the practice of spinal surgery and teach them “the safest approaches and ultimately, if something should go awry,” he said, and how to overcome those obstacles.
The training also emphasizes what happens when those best-laid plans go wrong. After the lab portion in the morning, the participants and “the masters” headed to a lecture hall. There, the surgeons-in-training would hear tales of complications and complex procedures that their mentors had faced in the past.
“What happens when things don't go your way?” Cheng said, describing the focus of the summit's discussions of complications. “What happens when you find something you weren't expecting?”
When confronted with the unexpected in a real operation, a surgeon cannot simply stop and consult a textbook. The training environment allows surgeons-in-training to develop the ability to recognize problems and adapt.
At one station, participants practiced placing screws into the thoracic spine, a technique that can be used in treating conditions including fractures, spinal tumors and scoliosis.
One of the specimens had severe osteoporosis, requiring the residents to quickly adapt their approach. While one performed the surgical maneuvers, her peers gathered around, watching intently as their master instructor Julie Chan, an assistant professor at the University of Florida’s neurosurgery department, suggested modifications and alternate techniques that would account for the fragile bone and allow the procedure to proceed safely.
The summit's faculty also includes surgeons who once sat where today's trainees are sitting. Chan, for example, attended the AHN summit during her residency and returned this year as faculty.
That progression — from student to practitioner to teacher — is part of the culture the summit is designed to foster, Cheng explained.
At another station, surgical residents and fellows were guided by Richard Fessler, a renowned neurosurgeon and professor of neurological surgery at Rush University in Chicago, who was pointing out the importance of precise placement when inserting screws into a patient’s spine.

The lesson: Precision is not an abstract concept in spine surgery. The technology being demonstrated throughout the lab underscored that point.
One station featured a navigational robotic system that can help surgeons execute a procedure that has already been planned for a patient. At another, navigation technology that displays an instrument's position in relation to the patient's anatomy, in real time, was shown.
The technology is becoming an increasingly important part of surgical education, Cheng said, but it is not intended to replace fundamental surgical skills.
The navigation systems can provide an additional layer of information and precision, but trainees must first learn the underlying techniques.
“It's just a very nice assist tool as well as a teaching tool,” he said, adding that, while helpful, surgeons cannot come to rely on technology alone. Their hands-on skills are paramount — and were one of the main focuses of the summit.
At another station, participants worked with a newer approach to cervical spine surgery. They could see the trajectory of an instrument through the anatomy, on a screen, allowing for visualizations such as where a screw should be placed and which areas of bone were denser.
The technology also illustrates how advances in equipment and surgical techniques can make procedures that were once considered particularly risky more accessible.
Posterior cervical approaches, for example, have historically been challenging because of the proximity of the spinal cord and vertebral arteries — “a high risk procedure if not appropriately trained,” Cheng said.
But improvements in instrumentation, navigation and minimally invasive techniques are changing what surgeons can safely attempt.
That evolution is part of what makes a summit like this valuable: Surgeons are not simply learning a single standardized way to perform an operation. They are exposed to different approaches from surgeons trained in various specialties and at an array of institutions.
Every experienced surgeon has a particular style and approach, and seeing those differences firsthand can be invaluable to surgeons still learning the ropes. The experience amounts to adding more options to a surgeon's mental toolkit.

"The ability to handle and navigate complications after surgery is just as important a skill to develop in training," AHN neurosurgery resident and summit attendee Dallas Kramer said in an email. "The best surgeons exemplify not only technical proficiency. But humility and grace when faced with a complication."
Complications and challenges are inevitable and being able to experience them in a practice environment under the tutelage of highly trained surgeons is a great advantage.
“These different environments spur tailored solutions, and conferences like these are a great way to share how we've solved those problems,” Kramer said.
The lessons in the cadaver lab were just one piece of a much larger educational experience at the summit.
Senior neurosurgery and orthopaedic surgery residents also competed in a fast-paced surgical skills challenge, designed to test the technical skills required for complex spine procedures. And lectures addressed difficult cases and complications.
Back in the lab, the atmosphere was remarkably focused. Groups rotated among stations, spending roughly 30 minutes at a time learning different techniques and working with different technologies.
The instructors watched closely.
At one station, removing bone required something less sleek than the sophisticated navigation systems elsewhere in the room: a hammer and chisel.
The contrast was telling. Spine surgery may be increasingly shaped by robotics, navigation and advanced imaging, but the surgeon still needs to understand the anatomy, control the instruments and know when a maneuver has gone too far.
“When you have to remove bone, think about how much you have to hammer, how much you have to chisel just to remove that bone,” Cheng said. “But in a safe manner, in a controlled manner.”
That may be the central lesson of the Pittsburgh Spine Summit.
Technology can show surgeons where they are going. Experienced faculty can demonstrate how they approach a difficult case. Cadaver training can provide an opportunity to practice.
But ultimately, the responsibility belongs to the surgeon.
“You want to make sure you learn from the best,” Cheng said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.