Walking through the halls of Allegheny General Hospital’s emergency department, Brent Rau waved at coworkers, nodded to his residents and made small talk about a family ski trip over the weekend.

He paused at one of the department’s trauma bays, where a patient in critical condition — just transported by ambulance — was surrounded by several doctors performing life-saving procedures.

The intense scene, on a day in February, was a common one for Rau, as the hospital’s medical director of emergency medicine.

It’s similar to what audiences of “The Pitt” see on their television screens, as Rau’s fictional counterpart, Michael “Robby” Robinavitch, performs his duties as an attending physician at the Pittsburgh Trauma Medical Center. At the start of both seasons — the second of which ends Thursday — the experienced doctor walks into a 12-hour emergency room shift and remains calm while facing immense pressure.

Advertise with us

Though “The Pitt” is entertainment, it aims to reflect the challenges real-life emergency health care workers face, from mass casualties to complex patient diagnoses.

“It does a very good job, probably more than other shows I’ve seen, in not just being medically accurate, but also showing the human side and the emotion around it,” Rau said in a January interview.

AGH, which inspired the set design of “The Pitt,” houses a variety of healthcare workers whose roles mirror those of actors on the series.

Rau has experienced the screams of mothers who have lost a child, the relief of a patient who is going to be OK, a global pandemic, the uncertainty of operating in tragedies with nationwide significance, and the confidence doctors in training build as they take on more responsibility.

There is chaos, camaraderie, heaviness, pride, a sense of obligation and just a smidge of excitement that keeps Rau coming back to one of the most difficult jobs in the United States.

Advertise with us

“What I do can be very challenging, not only from the clinician side of things, but also being responsible for multiple physicians,” he said. “Not only how they’re practicing medicine, but also their well-being.”

The intensity of the emergency room has become second nature to Rau, who has worked at Allegheny General since completing his residency there in 2015. He held a variety of positions at the hospital before he became a real-life Dr. Robby in 2024.

Dr. Brent Rau

Brent Rau, the medical director of emergency medicine at Allegheny General Hospital, stands outside the Central Northside hospital’s emergency department on Tuesday, Feb. 10, 2026. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Rau has lost a lot of sleep working in emergency medicine at AGH. In the past eight years, he has seen a lot.

That includes the 2018 synagogue shooting in Squirrel Hill, which left 11 dead and even more injured. Staff at Allegheny General Hospital switched into “mass casualty incident” mode — similar to the one seen in the final episodes of “The Pitt” Season 1 — to treat shooting victims, but none ended up at the North Side Hospital.

The shooter, however, came through the doors of the ambulance bay that day. Rau was on shift.

Advertise with us

“I was one of the people in the room, and we took care of him before he went upstairs to the operating room,” he said.

Robert Bowers was later found guilty of the hate crime shooting and sentenced to death in 2023.

In 2020, Rau became associate director of emergency medicine at AGH just before the COVID-19 pandemic hit.

“We had patients coming in that were extremely sick. Their oxygen levels were so low and they were still speaking to us, which was very unusual,” he said. “They looked very unwell, but they were able to talk. And they would deteriorate so rapidly in front of you.”

At the time, Rau and his team didn’t fully know how to protect themselves from the illness. They tried wearing pappers — “space suit”-looking coveralls that were also worn by Dr. Robby and other doctors in “The Pitt’s” COVID-19 flashback scenes. 

Advertise with us

“We had an idea how the virus was transmitted, but we didn’t know for sure,” Rau said. “So I would go home and, like many doctors, I would strip down in my garage and run up to the shower as fast as possible so I didn’t touch my wife or kids.”

Rau treated a former firefighter whose death from COVID-19 complications gained media attention. Despite shortness of breath and low oxygen levels, the patient was talking and “seemed fine-ish,” then declined rapidly.

“To come in like that and, within three hours, be on a ventilator, and seven hours later dead, those were the ones that I remember,” Rau said.

He has seen a variety of traumatic situations — terrible accidents and assaults, abuse cases and mass casualty incidents, including the 2024 assassination attempt against then-presidential candidate Donald Trump. The worst are the deaths of children.

“I can remember every single kid I’ve ever pronounced. I remember every single one of them,” he said.

Advertise with us

Some doctors cope by turning to friends and family; others try not to take their work home with them. It can be hard to connect with people who don’t work in medicine, especially during difficult times such as the pandemic.

“It’s almost like the only people who could really just truly understand what you were going through were each other when you would go to work,” he said. “So that led to leaning heavily on each other.”

Rau takes solace in thinking about the people he saves and the times he catches something small that changes a patient’s life. He tries to pass on what he has learned to medical residents and students. Watching these doctors grow into their roles helps him stay committed to his career in medicine despite its difficulties.

“There’s a sense of pride when you watch them go out and do what they do in the world, the patients that they’re going to save,” he said. “And knowing you were part of that, what they became — that feeds me, that keeps me going.”

Dr. Olivia Giambra

Dr. Olivia Giambra, who is in her second year of residency in the AGH Emergency Department, wants "what’s right for the patient and it’s not always saving their life, to be quite honest." (Samuel Long / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

It’s taken Dr. Olivia Giambra a bit of time to build her confidence as a resident at Allegheny General Hospital. She recalled the first time she ordered a patient’s morphine during her first year of residency.

Advertise with us

“My senior resident was sitting next to me and I made her look at it every single time I put it in that day,” she said. “I was like, ‘Make sure I’m putting in the right dose, make sure I’m putting it in the right way’ because it’s scary to finally have your name on something.”

That process is now easy for Giambra and, now in her second year of residency, she’s become more of a teacher while she grows her own skill set.

She knew she wanted to be a doctor from a young age; her mother worked as a vascular ultrasound technician. Her story is similar to that of Dr. Victoria Javadi on “The Pitt,” who is 20 years old and in her final year of med school.

“Her nervousness walking around the ER — I remember being that medical student, nervous, making sure I was doing the right thing,” Giambra said. “Although I’m a resident now, I would say that I relate to that.”

The AGH emergency medicine residency program rotates through specific specialties. Giambra recently completed a rotation in the cardiac ICU, where she helped patients with heart issues.

Advertise with us

“I was the more senior resident in the cardiac ICU this past month. You run all the rapid responses in the hospital,” she said. “So anytime there is an emergent situation going on on the floor, they put out a rapid response and then you go to them. That was a fun experience to run those rapids and develop my critical thinking a bit further.”

The 28-year-old is quickly building her confidence as an emergency medical doctor, according to Rau. She now confidently leads other doctors in treating patients suffering from active cardiac arrest, a skill that often takes months to develop.

“She just gets it, and it’s hard to put what ‘it’ is,” he said. “Sometimes it’s just the ability to walk in and say: ‘I don’t know what’s going on, but I know this person is sick and this is how I’m gonna make them less sick and get them to somewhere where they can figure out what’s going on.”

Confidence and skill don’t erase the emotional toll of emergency medicine. It’s difficult to be responsible for people’s lives, especially when the cause for an illness or injury is undetermined.

Like Rau, she has found that both negative and positive outcomes for patients stick with her. She likes to remember the saves who get to go home.

Advertise with us

One time, a young girl entered the ER and presented symptoms that didn’t seem to have an exact cause.

“She had been to multiple different specialists and could not figure out what was going on,” Giambra explained. “They came into the ER, and the ER is normally not a place where you figure out very niche diagnoses, to be quite honest.”

Giambra was able to steer the girl and her family to a specialist who provided a diagnosis and care. And though she wouldn’t describe the situation as a textbook “big save,” she continues to monitor the patient’s chart to see how she’s doing.

Giambra has also learned how to compartmentalize death — which is unavoidable in the emergency department.

She recalled the first death she experienced as the primary doctor, overseeing an elderly patient with numerous medical issues and who was close to death. The patient’s family ultimately chose to let them pass comfortably and peacefully instead of fighting for more time.

Advertise with us

“You want to do what’s right for the patient and it’s not always saving their life, to be quite honest,” Giambra said. “That’s a hard idea to grasp.”

As the program continues, she continues to learn. She now has experience helping stabilize trauma patients, a task usually left to third-year residents. Before her residency, she watched doctors work in the trauma bay as a medical student.

“I used to think they were really exciting and a little scary and I couldn’t imagine myself leading those situations,” she said. “But as you get further into training, you realize you’re just following an algorithm in a lot of acute care and trauma settings as well.

“When a new patient comes in, it’s not like we’re scrambling or thinking: ‘What are we doing?’ We have an algorithm.”

Dr. Olivia Giambra and Dr. Brent Rau talk in an Allegheny General Hospital trauma bay in February. (Samuel Long / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Dr. Allan Philp

Dr. Allan Philp, the chief trauma surgeon at Allegheny General Hospital, treated U.S. military personnel in Europe and the Middle East. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

After being stabilized in Allegheny General Hospital’s emergency department, some patients are taken to the trauma surgery department. Dr. Allan Philp, hired in 2011, is the director emeritus of the sector. He has spent years optimizing its systems using his military experience between 2002 and 2008.

Advertise with us

Similarly, Dr. Jack Abbot in “The Pitt” is an established military veteran and former combat medic.

“I did four deployments in support of those things in a variety of places, some in the Middle East, some in Afghanistan, one in Germany. But I don’t count that one because anywhere you can get a beer with dinner is not really hardship deployment,” Philp said.

He was required to treat members of the U.S. military who were injured in combat, a job that entailed “99% boredom and 1% panic,” according to Philp.

“There’s not a bunch of meetings, there’s no PowerPoints, there’s no Microsoft Teams,” he said. “It really was pure medicine, which was kind of cool.... They ring the thing and say ‘casualties incoming’ and you do what you need to do.”

Working as a military trauma surgeon introduced Philp to a wide range of injuries that are rarely seen in the civilian world. Rocket-propelled grenades and improvised exploding devices made the injuries Philp was treating “much more dramatic.”

Advertise with us

Though these injuries were “awful,” they gave him the opportunity to learn things he would have “never learned stateside.”

He was the initial doctor to treat soldiers suffering from explosive and bullet wounds. Then, an orthopedic doctor would enter and fix, say a fractured leg, followed by a vascular doctor who would repair the blood vessels and return blood flow to the injured area — allowing it to heal. The patient’s next stop was the ICU unit.

“Then, there’s a different set of people who are gonna scoop them up, fly them back through Germany, stabilize them from there, scoop them up again and bring them back to the states,” Philp said. “So you’ll have a series of half a dozen operations performed over maybe four or five days on three continents.”

His deployments offered rare and unique training for a surgical career, but spending years abroad in dangerous areas took a toll on Philp’s personal life. He was treating a large volume of high-severity injuries, and there was no end in sight.

“You wind up in this sort of ego trap of: ‘I’ve gotten really good at this [and] the next people might not be,’” he said. “Who’s gonna take care of these casualties? So you just keep going back.”

Advertise with us

That personality trait shows up in many medical professionals. It allows them to continue functioning in the face of tragedy but can become detrimental if left unchecked. Philp left the military in 2008.

“My then-wife had kind of put her foot down and said, ‘Look, you’ve been gone years. I haven’t see you and I’m worried you’re not gonna come back — it’s me or that,’” Philp said. “That kind of made it time.”

He returned to the United States with an immense amount of knowledge about emergency medical systems and surgery, making Philp an asset to any hospital. After spending some time at Carilion Roanoke Memorial Hospital in Virginia, he came to AGH in 2011.

Although many years removed from the military, that stint and his time in Pittsburgh have made him much more aware of the toll trauma surgery takes on physicians. He said there is a certain “machismo” among doctors in trauma surgery. For most of his career, calling in sick was seen as “incomprehensible,” he said.

“‘Like, you’re clearly alive, you’re calling. Why aren’t you at work?’ Because the only thing that would get you out of a shift was death,” he explained.

Advertise with us

Many physicians will miss their children’s birthdays, putting their marriages, families and any other life obligations second to their jobs, Philp continued.

“I think it’s our own fault, though. When I was training as a resident, the highest praise you could offer somebody is to say that they were more machine than man,” he said.

Philp stepped down from his role as the director of trauma surgery at Allegheny General at the beginning of 2026. As a regular trauma surgeon, he is using any extra bandwidth to develop a wellness protocol for the department.

“When you talk about compassion fatigue or secondary PTSD or burnout — it’s got a bunch of names — it’s the cumulative effect of negative stimuli,” he said. “Our brains are wired that way. We’ve actually looked at this.”

Studies have shown that a part of the brain lights up when humans are exposed to negative stimuli. Those negative experiences have about five times the impact on the brain when compared to positive stimuli.

Advertise with us

“It’s why you don’t remember the day you got up, felt pretty good, got a good night’s rest, not much traffic on [Rt.] 28, got a pole position at work, couple things canceled, went home early,” he explained.

“You don’t remember that day. You remember the day your dog threw up, the kid missed the bus, it was pouring down rain, had a flat tire on the side of the road, they added 16 things to do during the day, you didn’t get out till 10 o’clock at night.

“You remember that because it’s unpleasant. Our brains are wired to help you sort of developmentally so that you don’t keep poking the saber-toothed tiger.”

In medicine, even a “pretty good day” includes exposure to negative stimuli. A bad day means exposure to a lot of them.

That’s why Philp is looking for ways to reduce the stress to people who choose the medical profession.

“I should try and help some other people before they’re in the same pickle,” he said.

Marge Ranier

Social workers perform a piece of emergency medicine that takes a step beyond the initial life-saving procedures physicians do.

Marge Ranier, a social worker on the AGH emergency department night shift, sees every patient and family that comes through the hospital.

“Compared to social workers on ‘The Pitt,’ we do so much more,” Ranier said.

While attending school for psychiatry, Ranier was told she wouldn’t get a job unless she received her doctorate and went into social work. She pursued the profession out of practicality and was hired at Allegheny General in the early 2000s.

Having worked there for over two decades, she has learned how to handle a variety of situations. She works with police, medical examiners, nurses, doctors and other AGH staff throughout her 7 p.m.-7 a.m. night shift.

“We have a patient come in, we don’t even know who they are and we have to figure out who they are. We got to find family,” Ranier said. “We could spend hours trying to find family for a patient.

When they do find contacts for the victims, Ranier plays a lead role in delivering news, both good and bad, that has the power to change lives instantly.

Though the stakes are emotionally complex, the process is quite straightforward. Ranier will meet with personnel who treated the patient, find out more information about family members, then deliver the news — in a private room if the outcome is negative. An attending doctor is often present.

“There is a difference in how we approach people who are critical compared to somebody who just maybe has a bump on their head,” she said.

Despite her extensive experience, Ranier can’t predict how families will respond to bad news. Sometimes they react with anger, sometimes with acute sadness and grief. If things get violent, Highmark police are available.

She recalled a scenario when a shooting victim died during treatment. Viewing was only available for the parents, per police orders, and a brother became upset.

“The brother was yelling at me, screaming at me, calling me heartless and just kept screaming at me,” Ranier said. “But that’s not the norm for me. People are usually very nice.”

Despite the emotional load of the job, Ranier has never had a problem coming back to work.

“How I deal with it, I don’t even know. I just keep on going in,” she said. “I mean, it does break your heart when these parents are dealing with a loss of their only child.”

There are aspects of her profession that she views as positive. She finds value in making herself available to the staff of the emergency department for debriefs following difficult situations.

Social work and its diversity — the fact that she can’t predict the cases she will see every day — keeps her interested. If she was a character on “The Pitt,” Ranier believes she would be a supporting actress.

“We do so much. This week I’ve done two adult protective service reports, so there’s a whole gamut of stuff that I probably didn’t even talk about,” she said.

Kathy Sikora

Kathy Sikora,head of operations for AGH's emergency room, sees a little of herself in a lead nurse on "The Pitt": "She’s very firm and she’s very fair. We have that in common.” (Samuel Long / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Kathy Sikora’s life never really slows down.

As the head of operations for AGH’s emergency room, Sikora is always needed to make adjustments and decisions. She sees similarities between herself and lead nurse Dana Evans on “The Pitt.”

“[Evans] is really kind of the mother hen. She’s very firm and she’s very fair,” she said. “We have that in common.”

Having worked in her role at Allegheny General for over a decade, Sikora also identifies with Evans’ commitment to the emergency room team.

Hired into the Allegheny Health Network’s cohort of hospitals in 2012, she transferred to Allegheny General Hospital to rebuild the emergency services program from the “hot mess” it was then, with staffing problems and quality issues.

Sikora “lived” in the mess for a while to identify what changes were needed, then she began hiring new staff and executing ideas to address the problems she found. That process took years.

The department is in a “good place” now, and as medical technology advances and new, more efficient systems are discovered, the quality and speed of care at Allegheny General — and hospitals around the world — continues to evolve. So Sikora’s work continues.

“The emergency room is always evolving. If you don’t evolve [with it], you’re left way behind,” she said.

Following the COVID-19 pandemic, the public viewed emergency room workers as heroes. That was positive for morale, but created increased pressure on physicians, nurses and other staff to perform.

“Sometimes patients, families are much more volatile, with higher expectations that we’re constantly trying to meet. But too often because of circumstances, our acuity, our volume, we fall short,” she said. “That’s hard for us to manage, too, that we’re not meeting people’s expectations. That’s not what we want to do.”

The Allegheny General Hospital emergency department evolves with the people who make it function. Residents in training gain confidence and experience, leaders learn how to positively impact those who look up to them and skilled professionals learn how to better manage the emotional toll this work has on the people who take it on.

This all happens through chaos as these workers care for sick and injured individuals in the waiting room and trauma victims arriving by ambulance.

“I don’t know what’s gonna happen any day I work,” Dr. Rau said. “I might have the most boring shift where nothing interesting comes in or I might have a situation where a pediatric arrest comes in, a day where you have somebody born in one room and somebody dies in the next room.

“You’re like: ‘Wow.’ You just watched the whole circle of life happen in front of you.”

Then, he and the other employees move on to the next patient in need of their care.

Correction, posted April 17, 2026: An earlier version of this article misspelled Marge Ranier’s surname.