In Pittsburgh, Lent doesn’t just arrive quietly on the calendar.

It crackles and sizzles, showing up golden brown, flanked by fries and coleslaw, and served in church halls, fire stations and restaurants across the region.

For many, Friday fish fries are nearly as sacred as the season itself.

But what do those flaky, crunchy cod fillets actually do to the heart?

Advertise with us

Fish may be a pillar of the Mediterranean diet, but when it’s battered and submerged in hot oil, its nutritional profile changes — sometimes dramatically.

Fried foods in general are pretty high in saturated fatty acids and refined carbohydrates, explained Dr. Mahathi Indaram, a cardiologist with the Allegheny Health Network Cardiovascular Institute.

Our bodies struggle a bit to process these types of carbs and saturated fats. Excess saturated fats, in particular, “get broken down into smaller lipid particles that ultimately the body does not really have much value for, in terms of metabolic requirement.”

Instead, the lipids are what can build up in arteries, oxidize and ultimately lead to plaque formation and blockages — or atherosclerosis, which can lead to heart attack and stroke, she said.

High levels of LDL — often called “bad” cholesterol — can seep into the inner lining of artery walls. There, the particles become oxidized, triggering inflammation. Immune cells engulf the cholesterol, forming so-called “foam cells” that accumulate over time into plaque, according to the Cleveland Clinic.

Advertise with us

Over years, that plaque narrows arteries much like buildup inside an aging steel pipe, restricting blood flow. If a plaque ruptures, a clot can form — blocking blood flow to the heart and causing a heart attack, or to the brain, triggering a stroke.

It’s not the fish. It’s the fry.

The issue isn’t fish itself, Dr. Indaram stressed. It’s what is happening in the fryer.

The process of deep-frying and the type of oil used in that process are the real culprits in adding not-so-heart-healthy elements to fish, which, on its own, is generally considered a cardiovascular-friendly food choice.

When either a hand-breaded or beer-battered fillet is lowered into bubbling oil — often high-smoke-point peanut, cottonseed, canola or vegetable varieties — surface moisture sears away instantly, creating a violent bubble barrier that prevents oil from immediately penetrating the food. The immersion in oil also cooks the food from all sides simultaneously.

The high temperature of the oil — usually above 400 degrees Fahrenheit — triggers the Maillard reaction (browning) and caramelization, thus providing the flavorful and crunchy crust that fish fry aficionados crave. As the cooking and bubbles subside, oil can be absorbed into the surface crust and breading.

Advertise with us

Fish is often celebrated as a heart-healthy food — and for good reason.

“If you look at the requirements of a heart-healthy diet, or what we call a Mediterranean diet perspective, fish is actually recommended because a lot of the high-fat fish are heart healthy, like salmon, mackerel, sardines,” Dr. Indaram said.

If your doctor has alerted you to cardiovascular health risks, Dr. Indaram advises rethinking your Lenten fish dish.

Ordering baked or grilled, or perhaps opting for olive or avocado as a fry oil, would go a long way to make a heart-healthy difference, she said.

“You don't have to not indulge in fried fish, but maybe opting for these healthy alternatives as a substitute would be better in the long term.”

Advertise with us

For die-hard fish fry devotees, that may sound like heresy. But she’s not calling for a Lenten boycott — just a little balance.

Moderation matters

For patients with high blood pressure or heart disease, balance is key.

“Like I tell my patients, if 98% of your diet is heart healthy, and for 2% of your diet, if you want to indulge, then that's actually OK.”

Patients who attempt to eat 100% healthy all of the time often struggle with sustainability, she said.

The Lenten fish fry “is seasonal. This is cultural. There's no need to completely hold off, but finding that balance or that moderation is key,” Dr. Indaram said.

Advertise with us

So yes — still hop in line at your parish hall, American Legion or fire station. Just maybe not every single Friday — and consider skipping the “jumbo platter.”

Speaking of platters, portion sizes at fish fries can rival rush hour at the Fort Pitt Tunnel — much more than most arteries want to handle at once.

“Overeating, of course, is something that we should avoid, irrespective of it being fried fish or not,” Dr. Indaram said, advising diners to stop eating before they feel stuffed or until they cannot imagine indulging in even one more bite.

“The healthiest way to do it is maybe stop at that 80% mark, where actually you could eat more if you wanted to, but you actually don't need to, from a calorie or an energy perspective, and that's a more balanced way of controlling portion sizes.”

Thinking ahead can help too.

Advertise with us

“Portion sizes across all restaurants, in general, are quite large,” she said. So plan ahead to take home half of your dinner and enjoy it the following day.

Side dishes can also pile on extra artery-clogging concerns. Skipping the fries, mayo-laden coleslaw or butter-soaked haluski can help lower health risks without sacrificing the fillets.

Some might even consider making their own sides and sauces with heart-healthier ingredients like vegan mayonnaise or Greek yogurt. And if you’re preparing your fillets at home, pop them in an air fryer instead of a deep fryer as an alternative route to reducing oil, she suggested.

For many Pittsburghers, fish fries are about more than food. They’re about fellowship, tradition and supporting local parishes and fire halls.

Dr. Indaram isn’t asking anyone to give that up.

Instead, her advice is simple. Savor each bite, but make fish fries an occasional treat, watch portions, rethink sides and keep the rest of your week heart healthy.