In the mid-1980s, Velma Scantlebury arrived in Pittsburgh. She wanted to be a pediatric surgeon, but needed more research experience to strengthen her application for fellowship programs.

She landed in the mecca of liver transplantation — one of the few places in the country doing liver transplants at the time, led by Thomas Starzl.

She would stay in Pittsburgh for nearly two decades, doing research and then a pediatric surgery fellowship on her way to becoming the first Black female transplant surgeon in the U.S. She is one of several Black medical pioneers in Pittsburgh and is featured in the “Pittsburgh: A Tradition of Innovation” exhibit at the Heinz History Center.

“She’s not someone from 100 years ago — she’s still practicing medicine today,” said Samuel Black, director of the African American Program at the Heinz History Center. “We were just elated to tell her story.”

Advertise with us

Born in Barbados, Scantlebury was about 10 years old when she had a school assignment to write an essay on a career of interest. The youngest of seven children, Scantlebury had recently seen her family devastated when an older sister died from an infection at age 22 while studying nursing in England. She decided she wanted to become a doctor.

Even as a child in Barbados, Scantlebury’s skin color was a challenge. Although her academic abilities were not in question, she was denied admission to one prestigious school likely because she failed the informal “paper bag test,” meaning that her skin was darker than a paper bag.

Several years later, her family moved to New York City for a better opportunity for education. Even there, Scantlebury’s academic abilities were not always appreciated. When she told her high school guidance counselor that she wanted to go to college to become a doctor, Scantlebury said the counselor saw mainly her dark skin and Caribbean accent, suggesting that she get a job and try night school instead.

Nonetheless, Scantlebury applied to college, receiving a full scholarship to Long Island University. After four years there, she enrolled in medical school at Columbia University.

From her first dissection in first-year gross anatomy class, she was drawn to surgery. “It was absolutely an eye-opener,” she said in a phone interview earlier this month. “You can fix your patients with immediate improvement in their lives.”

Advertise with us
Velma Scantlebury’s surgical glasses are included in the “Pittsburgh: A Tradition of Innovation” exhibit at the Heinz History Center. (Courtesy Heinz History Center)

As a medical student, she found a role model in one of the few practicing female pediatric surgeons, Barbara Barlow at Harlem Hospital Center. “Watching her dissect and do surgery on those infants and tiny babies was absolutely the most incredible thing I had ever seen,” Scantlebury said.

She was able to get a surgical residency there with Barlow as her mentor, but taking the next step to a pediatric surgery fellowship proved difficult — something no Black woman had ever done before.

She found a path through Pittsburgh, perhaps given a chance there because she had done previous research in transplants in New York.

Pittsburgh was one of very few places in the country at the time doing liver transplants, and Scantlebury was trained by the father of transplantation himself, Thomas Starzl. The training was difficult, both physically and mentally. Starzl was brilliant but demanding; criticism was ample and sleep was scarce.

“We would round with him in the middle of the night — that’s when he would appear,” she said. “He would come around 11 p.m., 11:30 to drag us all out again and say, ‘Let’s go over those patients.’”

Advertise with us

The fellows weren’t home much to sleep and instead had long, pillowed couches in their offices. Pittsburgh was doing about 600 liver transplants per year at the time, and first-year fellows were responsible for flying around the country at a moment’s notice to retrieve and surgically remove donor organs. The upside was the hours of quiet time on the plane; they would grab their biggest coats for sustained naps.

Though the work was grueling, Scantlebury developed a love for transplantation, especially when paired with her goal of pediatric surgery for organ transplants in children.

She took a position in Pittsburgh doing liver transplants, working with doctors who traveled from around the world to study organ transplantation. When she had her first daughter, she switched to kidney transplants for an “easier” schedule. She ran the living kidney donor program together with transplant surgeon Ron Shapiro, alternating weeks they were on call.

“She’s a nice person, she’s crazy smart, she was really good with patients, she was technically brilliant and she played well with others,” said Shapiro, who left Pittsburgh in 2014 to become surgical director for kidney and pancreas transplantation at Mount Sinai Hospital in New York. “She was the whole package.”

Surgeon Velma Scantlebury in front of an exhibit featuring her story at the Heinz History Center. (Courtesy Heinz History Center)

For Scantlebury, an on-call week would involve arriving at the clinic around 8 a.m. and working a full day. When a transplant occurred, which was often the case, it would generally begin around 10 p.m. Scantlebury tried to make sure that the transplants finished by 5 a.m., so that she could get back home to do the mornings with her two daughters before school, and before she would return to work by 8 a.m.

Advertise with us

She feels passionately about letting other young women know that it is possible to be a physician and also have children. “There are always sacrifices,” she said, “but young people should know that you don’t have to make a choice.”

As the first Black woman transplant surgeon, Scantlebury faced comments and assumptions of all kinds. She was told that she was only admitted into medical school as a token. She was asked more than once by patients when the “real doctor” would be arriving. She encountered patients who not only had never met a Black doctor, but a Black person at all.

“She triumphed over a lot, and had been triumphing over a lot for a really long time,” said Shapiro. “That requires a different level of determination and commitment.”

Scantlebury left Pittsburgh in 2002 following turnover in the organ transplant program and spent six years in Mobile, Ala., before taking a job at Christiana Hospital in Delaware. Now, at 70, she is retired from surgery but still works as the co-founder of the Delaware Health Equity Coalition, which works to eliminate health care disparities in vulnerable communities.

She takes pride in providing a place where patients can feel heard, noting that she recently saw a 95-year-old patient who decided to switch doctors because she didn’t feel like her previous physician was listening to her.

“It’s really for those patients who don’t feel like they are respected by the health care system,” she said. “It’s important to provide culturally appropriate health care that restores trust.”