For the first time in 40 years, the updated U.S. dietary guidelines step away from specific daily limits on alcohol consumption, instead offering a broad directive: “Consume less alcohol for better overall health.”

The guidelines specify that some people should avoid alcohol entirely, including pregnant women, people recovering from alcohol use disorder and individuals taking medications that don’t mix well with alcohol. People with a family history of alcoholism are advised to be mindful of how much they imbibe.

The shift away from clear daily portions has drawn criticism from both nutrition experts and public health advocates. Previously, the guidelines offered a strictly defined limit: no more than one drink per day for women, two for men.

“It just seems this set of guidelines has just gotten more vague,” said Karen Harouse-Bell, assistant professor of nutrition and dietetics and the program director of the integrated master’s in nutrition and dietetics at Seton Hill University in Greensburg.

Advertise with us

The directive on alcohol consumption stood out to Harouse-Bell as one of the most troubling sections of the updated recommendations. She was also alarmed by a statement made by Mehmet Oz, administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid, during the Jan. 7 press conference announcing the guidelines, when he said that alcohol can act as a "social lubricant" and there's "nothing healthier than having a good time with friends in a safe way," according to an Associated Press video.

“But alcohol is still calorie dense,” Harouse-Bell pointed out, “and it is associated with higher rates of cancer and dementia and depression, and it can disrupt your sleep, and it can impact your blood pressure.”

The consumption of alcohol has so many health implications that removing strict guidelines for daily maximums and instead simply saying “drink less” adds both unnecessary confusion and ambiguity to the conversation, she said. “It's just very, very controversial.”

U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. discusses the updated U.S. dietary guidelines Jan. 21 in the state Capitol Rotunda, Harrisburg. (Megan Lavey-Heaton / PennLive.com)

Public health groups have echoed those concerns. The U.S. Alcohol Policy Alliance, a nonprofit and nonpartisan organization focused on informing the public of the dangers of alcohol, sharply criticized the alcohol section of the dietary guidelines, calling it “a big win for the alcohol industry.”

“The scientific evidence is clear: alcohol is a toxic, addictive carcinogen that kills about 178,000 Americans each year — a 30% increase in fatalities over the past decade,” said alliance CEO Mike Marshall in a statement.

Advertise with us

The organization said the new guidelines fail to clearly address alcohol’s well-established link to cancer risk, underage drinking and violence, and it criticized the removal of specific recommendations on daily intake and the definition of a standard drink.

“Given how deeply alcohol is embedded in American life, the public deserves clear, honest information about the risks of drinking so they can make the best decisions for themselves, their families, and their communities,” Marshall said. “Despite HHS’s claim that ‘providing the public with science-based dietary guidance is core to the Dietary Guidelines,’ the Department shirked its responsibility to do just that when it comes to alcohol.”

While the alliance acknowledged that advising Americans to “drink less” is a step in the right direction, it said the science shows there is no safe level of alcohol consumption.

“There is no healthy level of alcohol use,” the group said, pointing to increased risks of cancer, heart disease, liver disease, stroke and alcohol use disorder.