In a fight to gather sensitive information about patients seeking gender services at UPMC, the Department of Justice asked a federal court Tuesday to narrow the scope of its subpoena against the hospital system, allowing all patient information to be anonymous.

The DOJ has said the move, which was discussed in meetings from Dec. 12–15, renders moot UPMC’s argument that releasing the records would jeopardize the safety and privacy of patients, because they will be anonymized.

The Public Interest Law Center, a firm representing four UPMC families, insists its argument against the DOJ remains valid and objects to the release of the information, even if it doesn’t include the patients’ names or exact birthdays. These records include incredibly sensitive patient information about minors, including their mental health, says the group.

UPMC has not yet released any records.

Advertise with us

“The details in these records are so deeply personal that no redaction or anonymization can protect their privacy. We disagree that this would in any way moot our client’s cases," said Mimi McKenzie, legal director of the Public Interest Law Center.

The Department of Justice announced in July it would request medical records from more than 20 health facilities that provide gender care to those under the age of 19, including UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh and Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia.

“Medical professionals and organizations that mutilated children in the service of a warped ideology will be held accountable by this Department of Justice,” said Attorney General Pamela Bondi in a July 9 news release.

The subpoena, with a stated aim of uncovering fraud, seeks a broad swath of patient-identifying information for anyone under age 19 who has been prescribed hormones or puberty blockers by UPMC since 2020.

Gender care, which can include counseling services, haircuts and clothing, hormones and surgery, has been supported by major medical groups in the U.S., including the American Medical Association and American Academy of Pediatrics.

Advertise with us

The DOJ’s attempts to gather information from health agencies have been met with legal battles. A federal court judge, for instance, blocked part of the DOJ subpoena against Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia in late November, stating the department’s asks exceeded its authority.

“Even if this private information could be relevant, the heightened privacy interests of children and their families substantially outweighed the Department’s need to know the children’s names, addresses, and treatment along with disclosures for gender-affirming care at The Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia,” said Judge Mark Kearney in the ruling.

As for UPMC’s subpoena, the DOJ had previously said it would accept redacted patient material from the health system, with the ability to request unredacted materials at a later date. The current motion states the DOJ will not ask for unredacted patient information. UPMC has been instructed to still give the birth year of patients.

UPMC did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

An Allegheny County parent whose transgender child had received gender services at UPMC Children’s, until they were denied services this past summer, said it would be a relief if children’s names were not released, as the family has concerns about safety. The parent is not being identified, for fear of retaliation and privacy concerns.

Advertise with us

Their 15-year-old had been prescribed puberty blockers from UPMC Children’s until the health system stated it would align with President Donald Trump’s executive order to ban these services to those under 19. They have accrued expenses trying to access that medication elsewhere.

PILC independently filed to quash all aspects of the subpoena on behalf of families, on both the grounds of privacy and that the subpoena was issued in bad faith. UPMC has not filed to quash the subpoena in its entirety, as other hospital systems have done.

Correction, posted Dec. 17, 2025: A previous version of this article misrepresented the nature of the court document. It is a motion by the DOJ.