After six years of legal arguments, the question of whether low-income Pennsylvanians can use Medicaid funds to pay for abortions had another day in court Wednesday, in the City-County Building Downtown.
In 2019, the Allegheny Reproductive Health Center and other abortion providers filed suit, charging that a state law restricting the use of Medicaid funds to pay for abortions is unconstitutional.
Last year, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled largely in favor of those groups, calling the law “presumptively unconstitutional” and sending the case down to the state Commonwealth Court for judges to decide whether the law passed “strict scrutiny.”
For a law to be constitutional under that strict scrutiny standard, it needs to serve a compelling government interest, be narrowly tailored and to be the least restrictive means of achieving its interest.
The federal Hyde Amendment of 1977 prohibits federal Medicaid funds from being used for abortions, unless abortion is necessary to save the life of the mother or the pregnancies are the result of rape or incest. States can choose whether to use state Medicaid funds to cover other abortions.
In states where abortion is currently legal, 20 permit state dollars to be used to fund abortions for Medicaid recipients and 18 do not, according to KFF, a health policy research organization based in San Francisco.
Read More
In its 2024 ruling, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court determined that the prohibition on using Medicaid funds for abortion qualifies as “sex-based distinction,” at odds with the state’s Equal Rights Amendment.
In court Wednesday, attorneys argued over whether additional facts needed to be presented before the court could rule on the narrow question of whether the law was constitutional under the strict scrutiny standard.
“We have some very bold assertions that aren’t supported by fact,” said Michael Scarinci, representing Pennsylvania’s Attorney General’s office. “That's why we need discovery and a trial in this case to flesh out these many issues.”
Attorneys representing the interests of the seven abortion providers argued that the facts had already been stipulated, and that Medicaid did not specifically exclude coverage for any health conditions affecting only men.
“Your Honor, the Attorney General has not disputed that there is no comparable health care coverage for men that is excluded under the coverage exclusion,” said Elizabeth Lester-Abdalla of the Women’s Law Project. “That is not in dispute.”
The hearing featured an unusual dynamic in which different departments of state government argued on opposite sides of the case. Gov. Josh Shapiro declined to defend the law in court after the state Supreme Court ruling in 2024, and sent an attorney to court on Wednesday to argue that it was unconstitutional.
Aimee Thomson, deputy general counsel for the state, argued that the law failed on strict scrutiny, in part because it failed to serve any compelling government interest.
“The Attorney General has not put forward any state interest for why maternal health or fetal health are more compelling with regards to poor women in this Commonwealth than it is to other women,” she said.
It was not clear from the hearing Wednesday when the Commonwealth Court will issue a ruling in the case.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.