The Allegheny County Health Department’s Air Quality Program is running a roughly $1 million deficit this year as it awaits approval of long-delayed permit fee increases by County Council. Officials say the shortfall threatens to slow enforcement and monitoring work across the region.
The Air Pollution Control Division — which oversees industrial emissions, air monitoring and compliance — had budgeted for about $6.2 million in expenses for 2025, but expects to generate only $3.8 million in revenue.
The difference is the result of fee changes not being passed, according to county health officials.
To close the gap, the division has implemented a hiring freeze, leaving nine positions unfilled that vary from field compliance engineers to air quality technicians.
On Monday evening, the Air Pollution Control Advisory Committee also approved the withdrawal of 5%, or about $507,900, from its Clean Air Fund — a reserve completely financed by past enforcement penalties — and is waiting on the final stamp from the Board of Health.
“We have been very proactive in freezing positions and doing things that we needed to try and do to make the budget even ourselves, but we still are not there, nor do we think that we can get there, especially by the end of the year,” said Kim Joyce, chief operating officer at the Allegheny County Health Department, during Monday’s committee meeting.
Read More
As a result, the air quality teams are all “short-handed,” and the processes of air monitoring, modeling and enforcement work have slowed. The most significant delays have been the ability to go out and address complaints in a timely manner, according to Ms.Joyce.
“When you don't have the financial resources, it's impossible to do all things for all people, so we must prioritize with the resources we have,” she said.
A proposal to raise annual permit fees is expected to go before Allegheny County Council on Nov. 5. Together, annual fees for permits, maintenance, asbestos remediation and abrasive blasting, add up to $2.7 million of the total revenue generated by the program.
The fee changes, which were approved by the county’s Board of Health in September 2024, would raise a range of permit and maintenance costs for industrial facilities starting Jan. 1.
One of the largest price increases is for an annual maintenance fee paid by major emitters producing more than 100 tons of pollutants per year — jumping from $8,000 to $55,000.
Officials said they have held off sending invoices until after the Nov. 5 vote. If the measure passes, they believe it could help stabilize the budget starting in 2026.
Grant funding is also coming up short of what was budgeted.
The program receives $1.1 million in annual funding from the Environmental Protection Agency, down from the $1.4 million originally anticipated when the agency approved the 2022-25 grant cycle. The EPA reduced the allocation after the first year, citing provisions that allow mid-cycle adjustments.
Stagnant funding, “modest” annual cost-of-living increases and rising health care costs have contributed to the ongoing financial strain, Ms. Joyce said.
The program has relied on small withdrawals from the Clean Air Fund “for quite some time” to stay afloat. The fund had a balance of $10.16 million at the end of 2024.
Given that the increased fees are only meant to plug the gap and funding from the EPA is declining, Ms. Joyce anticipates having to navigate losing around three positions next year — which is “way better than the prognosis if the fees would not pass,” she said, adding that the air quality program would only have the funding to minimally operate, going from 56 budgeted positions to 36.
In addition to the hiring freezes, fee increases and withdrawals from the Clean Air Fund, the department said it’s been closely monitoring all spending, restricting most non-essential training and travel, as well as attempting to find other grant funds.
But getting grants through the EPA has proven to be more challenging recently. According to Ms. Joyce, her staff attempted to submit a grant request this week, but their point of contact had been furloughed and not permitted to respond until after the U.S. government shutdown ends.
“The longer the state and federal shutdowns occur, the more impactful it will become. We are playing this day by day,” she said.
The cost of clean air
The proposal for fee increases has bounced between health officials and County Council for months, with environmental groups consistently pushing for its approval –- arguing the increases are necessary to help fund the inspections and monitoring that hold industrial plants in the county accountable.
“This resolution is needed now more than ever,” said Nickolas Bartel, clean air campaign manager at the environmental advocacy group PennFuture during a Oct. 7 county council meeting. “Underfunded enforcement lets a few toxic companies cut corners, pollute more and profit by breaking the rules.”
Several speakers during the public comment period that day pointed to major air polluters in the Mon Valley, including U.S. Steel’s Clairton Coke Works plant, where an explosion on Aug. 11 killed two people and left 10 injured.
“This could have been a preventable situation,” said NaTisha Washington, a council member of Wilkinsburg Borough and former communications manager of the Breathe Project in Uptown. She also cited other incidents at the Clairton Coke Works plant in the months prior, such as a battery explosion in February and an equipment breakdown that caused spikes in sulfur emissions in June.
Increasing the fees will help the department carry out its enforcement practices more effectively and keep residents safe from the toxins that are emitted during such scenarios, advocates argued.
During Monday evening’s air pollution control advisory committee meeting, members said they plan to follow up on the investigative findings into those two incidents before the next meeting in December.
Ms. Joyce said the delay in approval over the fee changes is a consequence of “a perfect storm of timing and concerns to council from industry both large and small.”
County health officials and environmental justice advocates hope the new fee schedule will win council approval and begin to relieve some of the financial pressure on the department’s air quality program.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.