HARRISBURG — Toward the end of an overdose awareness event Friday on the steps of Pennsylvania’s Capitol, a collection of mothers took turns reading an incomplete list of names of those who died from fentanyl.

It took 31 minutes to read them all.

There were multiple Austins, Dereks, Amandas and Justins. Many Jeremys and many Rachels, among them Jeremy Creasy and Rachel Paul. Their moms were here, wiping tears and steeling their gazes.

These thousands of sons and daughters have left thousands of grieving parents, who don’t always agree on the best ways to end the fentanyl epidemic. “One big family” was the theme of the event leading up to International Overdose Awareness Day, which falls on Aug. 31 each year.

Advertise with us

Some say this division is stymying real progress toward reducing overdose deaths. There’s also evidence to suggest that the Trump administration has stifled research on fentanyl and those who use it. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention staffers told NPR last month that the administration would withhold $140 million set aside for overdose research.

“I hear every day lately that we are actually going backward again,” said Marianne Sinisi, an Altoona mother whose son, Shawn, died in 2018 at age 26 in a Pittsburgh McDonald’s from a fentanyl overdose. Ms. Sinisi was the last speaker of the day, having been fighting for years to curb the crisis.

Within Facebook groups, text messages and on committee floors, one particular disagreement about the best way to move forward is revealing cracks in an already fraught system.

The chief disagreement is this: Some view their child’s death as a murder and insist on the term “poisoning” over “overdose.” These parents tend to seek retribution for dealers and support criminalization, whereas other moms hold firmly to the notion that addiction is a disease and hope for stronger social services.

Bedford County mom Lynn Beck, for one, has lost relationships over this debate.

Advertise with us

“I’ve gotten yelled at for saying the word ‘overdose,’” she said. Her daughter, Jessie Deni, died in 2018 on her 24th birthday from fentanyl. “I’ve had people tell me, ‘your daughter was murdered.’ I felt I was being taught how to feel.”

Shortly after her daughter died, she said she wanted someone to pay for the actions leading to her death. But over time, she changed her thinking, realizing that putting someone else in jail wouldn’t bring her the solace she wanted. She said she’s stepped back from several Facebook groups over these disagreements.

Tammy Plakstis, who lives in Florida and lost her 29-year-old son, Dylan, to fentanyl in 2020, thinks otherwise.

“It’s like, basically, if you order a hamburger and somebody puts arsenic in it, you think you’re getting a hamburger, and it has poison in it. So my take it on it is that it’s a poisoning.”

At the time, Ms. Plakstis didn’t know anything about fentanyl, aside from that the singer Prince died from it — and neither did Dylan, she said. He thought he was buying cocaine.

Advertise with us

Like Ms. Sinisi, Ms. Plakstis is also doggedly pursuing changes within the state Legislature. She started the Facebook group Angel Mothers of the Poisoned, which currently has 708 members; she has shared testimony in front of lawmakers, and she wrote a letter to the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee as part of the HALT Fentanyl Act, which President Donald Trump recently signed into law.

The HALT Act will permanently classify fentanyl and fentanyl-related substances as Schedule I, or having a high potential for abuse and no currently accepted medical use under the Controlled Substances Act.

Some parents viewed it as a victory, but many harm-reduction advocates say scheduling only leads to more stigma, criminalization and dangerous adulterants in the supply.

Ms. Plakstis also helped prosecute the dealer who sold Dylan the fentanyl that killed him.

“I got the dealer and he was let go,” reads her letter to Congress. “It’s the same thing over and over. We need justice for our children and for our future children, so that another family member doesn’t have to go through this crisis.”

Advertise with us
Marianne Sinisi, an Altoona mother whose son, Shawn, died in 2018 at age 26, speaks outside the Capitol Building in Harrisburg on Friday. (Hanna Webster / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Michelle Creasy, of Columbia County, also knows who sold the fentanyl that killed her son, Jeremy, in 2018 at age 27.

“Could I go the route of demanding justice? I could, but they are sick, too,” she said. “Me wishing harm against someone else’s son or daughter or grandchild, niece or nephew, it’s a little bit hypocritical. It’s not going to bring me peace. It’s not going to bring him back.

“I am not going to get hung up on the substance that took our son,” she added. “He’s gone.”

Vickie Henry, a mom from Osceola Mills in Clearfield County, lost her son Elliott Henry two years ago from fentanyl. She ended a relationship with her best friend over their differences regarding criminalization of drug users.

Criminalization didn’t help Elliott, she said, who went to jail multiple times for intent to manufacture or deliver substances and use or possession of drug paraphernalia.

Advertise with us

“It did get him to rehab, but then rehab failed him,” she said.

Among current legislation, prosecuting drug dealers and slapping hefty fines to slow the flow of fentanyl does seem to be more popular than, say, reserving funds for overdose prevention sites or allowing community recovery organizations to practice around-the-clock wound care.

In the commonwealth, state Rep. Doyle Heffley, R-Carbon, has reintroduced a bill from last session that seeks to establish stronger criminal penalties for anyone convicted of making or selling fentanyl — specifically, a prison sentence of up to 20 years with a fine of $500,000. Currently those convicted on these charges face a prison sentence of up to 15 years and a fine of $250,000.

And Republican Marla Brown, of Lawrence County, has a similar bill to instate mandatory sentencing for drug dealers, specifically targeting fentanyl trafficking. That bill was sent to the House Judiciary Committee in January.

Other bipartisan legislation goes a different route: expanding access to syringe service sites. That bill has been introduced and was referred to the House Judiciary Committee in March.

Advertise with us

“Jail is not treatment,” said Ms. Creasy. “We can’t arrest our way out of this problem, and you’ll hear that a lot.”

Speakers on Friday said such tactics do little to meaningfully change overdose rates.

“The War on Drugs, those policies did not and do not work,” said Glenn Sterner, associate professor of criminal justice at the University of Kentucky, formerly of Penn State, specializing in opioids.

“We know the D.A.R.E. program does not work. In fact, it can cause the exact opposite effect. When we use fear, that doesn’t work to prevent kids from substance use.”

Mr. Sterner said he would rather see consistency, compassion and an end to stigma.

Advertise with us

“We know that stigma kills,” he said. “It prevents people from talking to one another. This can happen to anyone at any time under any circumstance.”

While improvements have been made — last year, overdose deaths decreased by nearly a third compared to the year prior — tens of thousands are still dying from opioids each year in America, including more than 3,000 in Pennsylvania.

Asked about strengthening social services, Ms. Plakstis said she agrees with that too. She frequently gives away the overdose reversal medication Narcan, as well as fentanyl test strips.

Bucks County mom Maureen Hardie said she hopes to see a stronger continuum of care for people leaving rehab, as well as smoothing the process for people with substance use disorders to enter rehab, with insurance companies more understanding of their situation.

She said she believes her daughter, Rachel Paul, took her own life after struggling with addiction for years and not being able to access services to help her. Rachel’s body was found, alone in a hotel room, with multiple substances in her system. She was 29.

Advertise with us

Ms. Beck said her daughter died while on a waiting list for intensive outpatient treatment, after having been discharged from an in-patient rehab two months earlier. She also said Bedford County, at that time, had no Narcotics Anonymous meetings and little in the way of transportation even if those meetings existed.

Ms. Creasy hopes legislators will come together to have productive conversations and “find real solutions” to the fentanyl epidemic.

“This problem is never going to go away,” she said, “not unless there is unity.”