Even as Richard Thoma completed his third marathon in January 2023, he didn’t feel quite right. As the year progressed, he battled fatigue and his stomach began to swell. Before the year was done, Thoma, of Phoenix, was diagnosed with an advanced stage of appendix cancer.
“It was obviously a shock,” he said. “I was 29 years old and by all accounts healthy. You don’t think that’s going to be you.”
Thoma initially consulted with a doctor in Phoenix and ultimately found his way to Pittsburgh for treatment — as do many patients facing the rare but growing diagnosis of appendix cancer.
There are only about 3,000 cases of appendix cancer diagnosed in the U.S. each year, or roughly one in a million people. While rare, appendix cancer has dramatically increased in younger generations, a study published last month in the Annals of Internal Medicine found. People born between 1981 and 1989 were four times as likely to be diagnosed with an appendix cancer than those born from 1941 to 1949, and those born from 1976 and 1984 were three times as likely.
There are several types of appendix cancers, but they have some similarities, usually beginning inside the appendix and growing there undetected for some time. At some point, the cancer invades through the wall of the appendix and spreads into the abdomen.
“It’s like throwing seeds in a garden,” said David Bartlett, chair of the AHN Cancer Institute and one of the country’s most experienced surgical oncologists treating appendix cancers. “The peritoneum, the lining of the abdominal cavity, gets seeded with tumors and, eventually, the belly just fills up with tumors. By the time we diagnose it, it tends to be very advanced.”
Treatment for advanced appendix cancers is often what is known as “the mother of all surgeries.” First, every visible tumor is surgically removed, which also may involve removing all or part of organs such as the spleen, gall bladder, colon, uterus, stomach and rectum. Then, the abdominal lining is partially removed and cleansed of tumors. And finally, the abdominal cavity is filled with a chemotherapy solution heated to nearly 108 degrees. For about 90 minutes, the patient is physically rocked back and forth to allow the chemotherapy solution to reach all crevices of the abdomen.
“These are 12- to 14-hour operations — just extremely long operations where we go in and remove all of the disease,” said Bartlett.
For patients with advanced disease, it’s likely that the operation will need to be repeated months or years later, he said.
That was the case for Thoma.
Diagnosed in Phoenix, a surgical oncologist there essentially politely declined to take his case, recommending that he check out surgeons in Pittsburgh instead. “He looked at my scans and said you’ve got LAMN, which is the low-grade version most likely, but you’ve got a lot of it,” said Thoma, referring to low-grade appendiceal mucinous neoplasm. “You need to see an expert. You need to see a high-volume center.”
On a scale that rates the severity of the cancer’s spread within the abdominal cavity from 1 to 39, Thoma scored a 39.
In October 2023, he had a 12-hour surgery done by Patrick Wagner, director of complex surgical oncology at AHN’s Cancer Institute. Nine months later, as was likely with an initial score of 39, the cancer reoccurred and he had another lengthy surgical procedure at AHN in November 2024. Scans since have shown no cancer, and he is currently training to run the New York City Marathon this November.
As Thoma connected with other appendix cancer patients through social media, he realized that he wasn’t the only one flying to Pittsburgh. Both AHN and UPMC are high-volume surgical centers treating the rare cancer.
Despite the relatively low incidences of appendix cancer, AHN sees about five new appendix cancer patients per week, from all over the world. UPMC has nearly 1,000 appendix cancer surgeries recorded in its clinical database, which dates back to 2001, said Haroon Choudry, a surgical oncologist at UPMC Hillman Cancer Center.
Bartlett and Wagner were previously affiliated with UPMC before joining AHN in 2019.
“It’s interesting — you’ve got two of the best appendiceal cancer centers in the world in Pittsburgh,” said Thoma. “This is such a rare cancer but when you go there, all the doctors, nurses, support staff are familiar. I’ve been to other ERs around the country, and it’s frightening when they don’t know what they are doing. Being in Pittsburgh is phenomenal.”
Indeed, the frequency at which the surgeries are done in Pittsburgh makes it a destination.
“The surgery is really involved,” said Dennis Hsu, a medical oncologist at UPMC Hillman Cancer Center who treats appendix cancer patients. “It can take several hours or a whole day. You want to be at a place where this is relatively routine — not where the surgeon is doing it once a month.”
That knowledge base was a factor in bringing Monty Eskew to Pittsburgh after he was diagnosed five years ago.
Eskew, of Easton, Md., noticed in mid-2020 that he was putting on weight, and that his belly felt bloated, almost as if it were filled with fluid. He saw a doctor and eventually received a diagnosis of mucinous adenocarcinoma, a type of appendix cancer in which the tumors produce a component of mucus.
One local doctor in Maryland discouraged him from even treating the cancer.
“He point-blank told me you have 18 months to live,” said Eskew, now 51. “He said, ‘If I were you, I would take my credit cards, move to the Bahamas and die on a beach, because the surgery is that bad.’”
Instead, Eskew’s wife made some calls to doctors around the country. A little over a week later, they were in an operating room at UPMC Shadyside, where he underwent a lengthy surgical procedure.
“From what I’ve been told, my appendix actually exploded and dropped about 400 tumors,” said Eskew. “Because they were mucus-y, they were attached to everything, very invasive.”
About two years later, Eskew also had a recurrence that required another surgery. His cancer had morphed into a more aggressive form and his surgeon, Choudry, actually stopped his procedure mid-surgery, in November 2002, to wake Eskew up to ask him how he wanted to proceed: remove about 80% of his bowel for a better chance at getting all of the tumors, or remove less of it for a better quality of life.
Eskew chose to remove less of his bowel, and had another major surgery, complete with the heated chemotherapy procedure, in 2023. He medically retired from his financial career that year, and is focused on enjoying his life, albeit at a slower pace than he once did.
“I have slowed down drastically,” he said. “The cancer has put me in a position where we value every minute. If God chooses to give you cancer, what do you choose to do with it?”
Most appendix cancers are diagnosed in people over 50, so both Eskew and Thoma are unusual for their youth at the time of diagnosis. And doctors and researchers are unsure why the cancers seem to be appearing more often in more recent generations.
One theory is that diagnoses are more precise, and that appendix cancers may have previously been mistaken for ovarian or other cancers. Other theories are that the increase is tied to factors also driving a notable rise in colon cancers in younger generations, possibly because of a more modern diet.
“It’s not necessarily that they are getting it at a younger age, but just that the incidence is increasing over time,” said Bartlett. “We don’t have a good idea why.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.