This story mentions suicide. If you or a loved one are having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988, or use the online chat option. For the military crisis line, dial 988, then press 1.
When he first sought mental health care from a military psychiatrist, Tate Dunnivan, of Adamsburg, had been in the service for about a decade. At the time — in February 2008, when he was stationed in Baghdad — the conversation and the treatment itself were taboo, he noted.
Though Dunnivan, now 44, had struggled to talk about his mental health, he now says he will discuss it with anyone he can. Having these conversations with other people who might be in a similar situation helps break the boundaries of what veterans should talk about, said the Army and Army National Guard veteran, who served nearly 13 years before his medical discharge in 2011.
For many veterans, discussing struggles with mental health has long been challenging, fueled in large part by stigma coupled with just-power-through-it stereotypes surrounding those who serve. But with evolving mental health services and conversations within the Department of Veterans Affairs, the narrative is changing.
“You don't have to fit into the stereotype of what a veteran should look like or be like, and you can be open and honest about those things,” Dunnivan said. “And I think getting care at the VA, we have to participate in it for it to get better, right? And that's what we want, is for the VA and the services to get better.”
Stigma looming around conversations about mental health in the military has contributed to both the fear in seeking help and the treatment of those who did, said Mary Dorritie, an Army veteran and a counseling psychologist specializing in PTSD with the VA Pittsburgh Healthcare System. In the military, she said, the idea is, “We have to get the mission done, the mission comes first.”
“You get into the military and it's very masculine. And, you know, aggression is rewarded,” said Dorritie, who is also the Behavioral Health Interdisciplinary Program manager and trauma recovery clinic supervisor at VA Pittsburgh. She joined the VA in 2008 after returning from Iraq.
In 2004, the VA developed a “comprehensive mental health strategic plan,” said a VA spokesperson, which led to the department’s 2005 handbook, “Uniform Mental Health Services In VA Medical Centers and Clinics.” The creation of the handbook “standardized the implementation of mental health programs across VA,” the spokesperson said via email.
“VA addresses mental health stigma through education, increased awareness, shifting perspectives and empowering Veterans in their care. Mental health recovery focuses on confronting many myths about mental illness, such as people with mental illness cannot get better,” the VA spokesperson said. Care for those with mental health struggles “is seen as a normal aspect of medical care.”
For Keith Newhouse, a 46-year-old Army veteran from Latrobe, finding care took time — about 10 years. With a combined service of “20 years, three months and three days,” Newhouse recalled facing PTSD, depression, anxiety, sleep apnea, hypertension, fibromyalgia, rhinitis, tinnitus.
Newhouse’s active duty included, from June 2005 to June 2006, being stationed in Ramadi. The city south of Baghdad is located within what’s been dubbed Iraq’s “Triangle of Death,” a major site for combat and violence during the Iraq War. When he returned home that June, he began to struggle. The name “Triangle of Death,” he said, “should tell you enough.”
In 2016 Newhouse found a good fit for treating his mental and physical health: the Westmoreland County VA clinic in Greensburg. He felt understood, and he was met with support. Eventually, he was connected to VA Pittsburgh, where he began intense cognitive behavioral therapy with a psychiatrist twice a week for several months.
“It forced me to talk about things that I didn't think I was ready to talk about,” Newhouse said. “It did make all the side effects rougher for a while, but then eventually it also helped me realize that I wasn't necessarily doing the best thing for me, either, so I began medication and things like that.” He’s kept up with his appointments since, at least bimonthly — “sometimes more, sometimes less, depends on what's going on.”
A shift in conversation
Nikki Weigand, director of advocacy and public policy for the National Alliance on Mental Illness Keystone, is an Army veteran who works with veterans and their families. When she tried to seek treatment for her mental health in the Army in the early 2000s, it was frowned upon, she said. Weigand has also seen greater acceptance in recent years with seeking mental health treatment in the military.
“After the military, because so many people fall into that rut of, ‘Oh, I'm hopeless. Nobody wants to help me,’ or, ‘I don't feel like I'm worthy of getting that help,’” Weigand said. “There's a self-imposed stigma in the military that ‘Somebody out there needs to help more than I do,’ so a lot of times, that keeps people from seeking treatment.”
The VA “saw a significant reduction in mental health staff” in the 1990s; in 2000, there were fewer than 1,550 psychologists and 1,800 psychiatrists in the department, the VA spokesperson said. Following several hiring initiatives from 2005 to 2017, however, the VA “expanded mental health staff tremendously” to more than 3,500 psychiatrists and 7,000 psychologists, along with similar numbers of other mental health providers and social workers. “Research has consistently shown that expanding staff not only improves quality of care but also increases access to services and enhances overall satisfaction for Veterans.”
Brandon Ketchum, a disabled Army veteran, licensed clinical social worker and local recovery coordinator for VA Pittsburgh, said since his time in the military, “we’ve come a long way.”
“From the VA side of it, from the therapeutic side of it, from giving group and individual therapy [to] the veterans, it's improved massively. There's still, of course, the underlying culture of, ‘just keep it to yourself, don't feel those strong emotions,’” Ketchum said. “But through the programs that we work with and the veterans that we engage with, I definitely think it has improved.”
‘One person is too many’
In 2007, the VA introduced a suicide prevention program, said Nicole Gallagher, community engagement and partnership coordinator for suicide prevention for VA Pittsburgh. “One person is too many,” she said.
“We definitely want to make sure that we create an environment where people are checking in more with each other because, honestly, veterans usually know about suicide risk of other veterans before we do,” Gallagher said. “Veterans are more likely to disclose suicidal thoughts to other veterans, much more likely than they are to family or to providers.”
With the introduction of the new, three-digit Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, 988, in 2022, the VA worked to add a new option for veterans that July: Dial 988 then Press 1. This connects callers to the Veterans Crisis Line, which is operated by the VA and is linked to more than 500 suicide prevention coordinators within its system. As of July 2024, the line has responded to more than 1,638,138 calls, representing a 22.7% increase in daily calls in the previous two years, according to a VA news release.
“To show how far the needle was moved with the VA, if you come in for any kind of care and express a mental health concern, you are offered same-day treatment,” Ketchum emphasized. “You can immediately be seen by a behavioral health specialist.”
As the stigma around seeking mental health care for all generations of veterans has decreased, the VA said it has “prioritized efforts to enhance availability, accessibility and affordability of mental health care, making it easy for Veterans who wish to initiate care.”
“In 2017, VA initiated open access scheduling for licensed mental health providers, ensuring Veterans had immediate access to care when needed,” per the VA spokesperson.
Greater social acceptance of mental health, Dorritie said, has led to a wider understanding among veterans that addressing mental health doesn’t equate to weakness.
“And that's not saying that that's completely changed, because it hasn't, but the needle’s definitely moved,” Dorritie said. “And a lot has to do with a veteran coming in and finding that one provider, that one mental health provider that they form a good relationship with, they will go tell all their friends, ‘You should go to the VA.’”
After working in the civilian sector, Jin Cheng, an addiction psychiatrist with VA Pittsburgh, said he thinks the access and care offered by the VA is better than some of what he has seen in some of his previous work.
Engaging with veterans every day is important “because that's how you're going to break down stigma over time, is for patients to be more vulnerable,” Cheng said. “And stigma we think of as a global thing, but I think it's almost like an individualized thing for each person too.”
The awareness of poor mental health and high suicide rates in veterans already exists, Dunnivan said, and he thinks the next steps include pre-care and preparation for those getting ready to leave for the military.
Some mental health treatments that could come before or after military service, like therapy and medication, come with their own challenges. Psychotherapy isn’t usually “high on peoples’ list of preferred activities, even if they're generally comfortable talking about mental health,” said Eric Meyer, professor and chair of Department of Counseling and Behavioral Health at the University of Pittsburgh.
“It's a fundamentally uncomfortable place for most people to be,” said Meyer, who is also a clinical psychologist who specializes in PTSD and treating veterans.
Dunnivan said he has noticed a shift in the culture of older veterans, which makes him hopeful for a difference in treatment.
“When you send people into an environment that's hostile and gruesome and violent, they're going to be impacted,” Dunnivan said. “So we do have to have the tools and resources available and the money available to treat them and accept them. And really, the biggest shift I would like to see next is that acceptance of what you went through isn't baseline normal, and it's OK for however you reacted, but let's fix it so that you can be better.”
For more mental health and suicide prevention resources or to find your local VA, visit va.gov.
Correction (March 10, 2025): An earlier version of this story had the incorrect surname for Nikki Weigand, director of advocacy and public policy for the National Alliance on Mental Illness Keystone.
Allie Miller (allie.l.mill@gmail.com) is a freelance journalist living in New Stanton.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.