Even as participants in the annual anti-abortion March for Life in Washington, D.C., settle in to hear a video address from President Donald Trump on Friday, the challenge of mapping out exactly where a second Trump administration will stand on the issue has advocates on both sides concerned.
Trump, who was the first sitting president to attend the March for Life rally when he spoke at it in 2020, has taken credit for his role in nominating U.S. Supreme Court justices during his first term who eventually helped overturn the landmark Roe v. Wade ruling.
Hours after he was sworn in on Monday, the White House took down a website that provided information to people on their rights and where to find reproductive care. And on Thursday, he pardoned more than 20 people who had been convicted of blocking access to reproductive health clinics.
But as a candidate last year, Trump signaled he did not support a federal ban on abortion and even vowed to veto one if passed by Congress. That pledge, and his December promise to not block access to abortion pills, upset some anti-abortion advocates.
“He lost a lot of our faith,” said Nikki Bruni, executive director of People Concerned for the Unborn Child, a Pittsburgh-based nonprofit focused on anti-abortion activism. “We voted for Trump, but I don’t think we have a whole lot of confidence — unless something happens to change his mind — that he’s going to really, truly become pro-life.”
Trump’s return to the White House, meanwhile, has abortion rights advocates are on high alert.
Read More
“We are deeply concerned about abortion,” said Tracy Baton, the director of the Women’s March Pittsburgh, which has hosted rallies supporting reproductive rights for women.
A ‘pro-life president’
Vice President JD Vance is scheduled to speak at the Friday’s March for Life, an event held in Washington, D.C., every year to protest the practice of abortion. Mr. Vance has been staunchly anti-abortion throughout his political career.
Many believe his new boss will also support continuing to put curbs on the practice.
“President Trump governed as a pro-life president during his first term, which resulted in a long list of accomplishments,” March for Life leaders Jeanne Mancini and Jennie Bradley said in a statement.
“We look forward to working with him and Vice President Vance as they dismantle the Biden Administration’s aggressive and unpopular abortion agenda and once again put wins on the board for vulnerable unborn children and their mothers,” they added.
So far, Trump has chosen a mix of anti-abortion and abortion-rights nominees to fill health roles in his new administration.
His team rejected a push from anti-abortion groups to pick Roger Severino as Health and Human Services secretary over concerns his abortion views were too extreme, Politico reported. Mr. Severino helped write the abortion segment of the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025 document, which outlined plans for policies like banning and criminalizing abortions.
Trump has said that, by picking three of the justices who helped to overturn Roe v. Wade in the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization case, he placed the abortion issue back in states’ hands.
That has led to a patchwork of rules across the country.
Abortions in Pennsylvania are legal up to 24 weeks, and newly-elected Sen. Dave McCormick, R-Pa, has said he wouldn’t vote for a federal ban on abortion.
Pittsburgh has enacted shield laws that would protect abortion providers in the city from out-of-state investigations for providing abortions to residents of states where the practice is illegal.
‘We’re preparing for all eventualities’
While Trump has previously said he wouldn’t support a federal ban on abortions, Ms. Baton suggested there are other ways to “make it impossible to have an abortion,” such as raising the price of the procedure, making it unavailable for many people across the country.
And she pointed to abortion-related medical education, saying programs that teach how to safely conduct the procedure could be eliminated.
“We’re preparing for all eventualities,” said Erica Wilson-Domer, president and CEO of Planned Parenthood of Greater Ohio. “What’s most critical in my mind is maintaining access to reproductive health care for all of the many people who need us.”
Many of the patients who use Planned Parenthood in Ohio and Pennsylvania for general reproductive health care — things like regular checkups and testing — get their coverage through Medicaid, Ms. Wilson-Domer said.
Of the 9.13 million services Planned Parenthood performed nationwide in 2023, about 392,700 – or 4% – of them were abortions, according to the organization’s annual report. The majority of its services, about 4.6 million, were for STI tests and treatments, the report said.
Ms. Baton is also concerned about federal funding for programs related to Black women’s healthcare.
Federal programs focusing on diversity, equity and inclusion were slashed under a Day 1 executive order issued by Trump. By Tuesday, U.S. Office of Personnel Management acting director Charles Ezell had sent a memo to agency leaders ordering them to place all employees of DEIA offices on paid administrative leave.
Ms. Baton noted that state officials previously showed support for those programs and indicated they would “protect Black women’s health locally.” But cuts in federal funding could cause Pittsburgh to go back to “being the worst place for maternal health in the United States for Black women, undermining the progress we’ve made,” she said.
A March report from the Allegheny County Health Department that analyzed 10 years of deaths during pregnancy, birth or shortly after delivery found that Black birthers in the county face a maternal death rate higher than the national average, and two and a half times higher than their white counterparts.
‘Defund Planned Parenthood’
Anti-abortion advocates, like Ms. Bruni, are hoping the new Trump administration’s next step is to defund Planned Parenthood, which is a nationwide organization that provides reproductive health care to people across economic backgrounds.
“I don’t think [Trump] really likes the idea of giving the abortion giant billions of taxpayer dollars,” Ms. Bruni said. “If they defund Planned Parenthood, a lot of them will close. So that would be definitely a success for us.”
Those attempting to see where the new administration is headed are focusing on all of the details, including the executive orders that have been rolling out since Monday.
Reproductive Freedom for All, a Washington-based advocacy group, noted an early executive order that declared that from the government’s perspective there are only two genders, also injected “personhood” language into defining life as starting at conception.
The executive order — titled “Defending women from gender ideology extremism and restoring biological truth to the federal government” — defined female as “a person belonging, at conception, to the sex that produces the large reproductive cell” and male as “a person belonging, at conception, to the sex that produces the small reproductive cell.”
The group said consequences of the order could include potentially criminalizing abortion, stem cell research, common forms of birth control and IVF, although Trump said last summer he wants the federal government or insurance companies to pay for IVF.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.