Throughout their lifetime, those who menstruate will use more than 11,000 tampons and pads, with up to 80% preferring tampons.

Tampons are often made of cotton, rayon, or a blend of the two, but a study published in ScienceDirect in July found more than those fibers. Out of Columbia University, researchers measured 16 metals and metalloids in 30 tampons across 14 brands, including popular store and name brands, and discovered all 16 — including lead and arsenic — in each sample.

The FDA followed with a September announcement that it was beginning an independent literature review of the study as well as conducting laboratory testing on tampons to further investigate. In particular, it noted wanting to understand if any metals present are released into the user.

With concerns raised and uncertainty hanging in the balance, why haven’t experts advised against tampon use?

Advertise with us

Waiting on more research

The lead author of the study, Jenni Shearston, a postdoctoral scholar of environmental science at the University of California, Berkeley, said when the research for the study began in 2019, she and the research team expected to find metals in tampons. What they did not expect: finding metals in each one.

The reason metals and metalloids (elements with properties of both metals and nonmetals) end up in tampons is due to the main ingredient, cotton — which can accumulate metals from fertilizers and soils during the growth process, Shearston said. Cotton, she noted, is one of the “most heavily pesticide-applied crops in the world.”

Though the study has raised valid concerns, there is more science to be learned until they know how these metals could be impacting the body.

“While we’re finding these metals, and some of them are toxic metals, we don’t know if the metals can come out of the tampon during use, or if they can be absorbed by the body, so we don't know if they’re contributing to any health effects,” said Shearston, who is also an environmental epidemiologist.

The question of whether or not lead is present in products we use and consume — from water to gasoline to tampons — has been a public issue for decades, said Anna Pollack, professor of global and community health at George Mason University in Virginia and an environmental epidemiologist. Though it’s not known if the body is absorbing the metals, Pollack said the tissues that make up the vaginal wall are highly permeable.

Advertise with us

“We understand that, while this particular study didn’t take on that question, metals are readily taken into the body, and that we know the vagina is a route of drug delivery, so I think that it's pretty clear that exposure to metals from tampons would easily happen,” Pollack said.

The important next step of finding that out is already underway, in a lab at Columbia University, by Kathrin Schilling, senior author of the July study and assistant professor of environmental health.

“We’re doing leaching experiments to determine how much of these metals might come out exactly the same way, like simulating normal use in the vagina,” she explained. “So that means thinking about the temperature of the vagina, thinking about the pH of the vagina, thinking about the time a person might wear a tampon.”

A Food and Drug Administration spokesperson said the FDA is in the process of reviewing the study, and noted that all studies have limitations, and that this study did not assess whether any metals are absorbed by the body with tampon usage.

“We plan to evaluate the study closely, and take any action warranted to safeguard the health of consumers who use these products,” the spokesperson said in an email.

Advertise with us

Avoiding blanket statements

Though the concentration of lead found in tampons was small, there is no amount of lead that is safe or recommended to be absorbed, said Colleen Krajewski, a gynecologist with AHN Women and director of transgender gynecology.

Lead is in other things we consume and use, such as water and some cosmetic products, Krajewski said, and there are other environmental toxins — for example, microplastics and chemicals. While trace amounts likely aren’t as dangerous, “when we have lots of trace amounts of lots of things, it can really build up over time and cause big problems.”

But everyone experiences menstruation differently, she said. So, for Krajewski, making a blanket statement — like, “Nobody should use tampons” — to her patients is not the answer.

“If someone says, ‘The only way I can possibly have my menstrual cycle be acceptable to me is to use tampons,’ well then, OK, maybe that might be a time to circle back and look at the rest of your environment and figure out how you can decrease other lead exposures to kind of mitigate that. I'm not telling all my patients, ‘Absolutely no tampons ever,’ because I do think that finding a way to experience your period is acceptable to you is quite hard.”

For trans and nonbinary people, sexual trauma survivors and victims, and people who cannot afford or don’t have access to period products, menstruation is an especially challenging experience.

Advertise with us

“I don’t want to take tampons away from my patients,” Krajewski said. “If that’s the only toxin in your life, I think we’re doing all right.”

Tampon alternatives

Before tampons can be sold on store shelves, an FDA spokesperson said, “The FDA requires tampon manufacturers to comply with FDA requirements for manufacturing to assure the safety and performance of these devices.”

But for those who are considering switching products, there are other options.

First and foremost, both Krajewski and Pollack said to always stay away from any period product that is scented, as fragrances carry chemicals that can be harmful or irritating.

For reusable and environmentally friendly products, Krajewski pointed to menstrual cups and discs, which are made of silicone. During menstruation, those products are self-inserted and are designed to catch menstrual blood for up to 12 hours, though they cannot be used in conjunction with an IUD. The cups can last up to a decade, and typically cost between $20 and $40.

Advertise with us

Though there can be a learning curve to using them, Krajewski said some of her patients have reported their period cramps disappearing with the use of menstrual cups.

Many of Krajewski’s gender diverse patients prefer period underwear, which are designed to look and feel like regular underwear and absorb menstrual blood, and are washable. But some say they can cause or contribute to their gender dysphoria since they have to wash it, rather than a disposable product like a tampon or a pad that just gets thrown away.

“For a lot of people, they tell me it’s more comfortable than pads,” Krajewski said. “And I think pads are something that's interesting, because we’ve sort of known for a while that pads can contain weird chemicals and irritants. I see a lot of patients who suffer from vaginitis and vaginal irritation, and it’s very pad-specific.”

Though pads are also a common period product, Krajewski and Pollack said they likely contain similar metals as tampons.

“I would expect that once someone tests pads for metals that they would detect them similarly to the study that found them in tampons,” Pollack said.

Advertise with us

While there are alternatives to tampons for those who want to change products, Pollack said issues with accessibility and period poverty —  being unable to afford necessary products — remain.

“I don’t recommend that menstruators decide to change the products that they’re comfortable using, just because there's a real lack of clarity on whether or not any changes would actually decrease exposures,” Pollack explained. “And then also, my own recognition that reusable menstrual cups and similar things may not be … accessible and feasible for everyone.”

Becoming more comfortable with talking about periods will help move us forward, Shearston said.

“Tampons have been on the U.S. market since the 1930s. … And so it’s a little surprising that it's not now, until 2024, that we’re evaluating metal concentrations in tampons,” Shearston said. “It’s really important that people talk about menstrual products and talk about periods, because when we don’t do that, we don’t ask really important scientific questions, we don’t demand that we know what’s in products.”

Allie Miller (allie.l.mill@gmail.com) is a freelance journalist living in New Stanton.