The consequences of the repeal of Roe v. Wade on women’s reproductive health across the country are highlighted in a report released Thursday by the nonprofit The Commonwealth Fund. The analysis found that states with restrictive abortion laws often fared the worst, with higher maternal deaths, fewer maternal care providers and less access to care in general.
In the state-by-state report card on women’s health and reproductive care, Pennsylvania scored above average overall, ranking 19 out of 51, though it was home to higher rates of women who were uninsured, a sub-average number of abortion clinics, and a population with less access to health care.

“Based on the evidence and data, one thing is absolutely clear: Women’s health in the U.S. is in a very fragile state,” said Joseph Betancourt, president of The Commonwealth Fund and a physician, in a Wednesday webinar on the report’s findings. “There are stark disparities in women's access to quality health care among states across racial, ethnic and socioeconomic lines.”
While Dr. Betancourt acknowledged that such disparities are certainly not new, he said that “recent policy choices and judicial decisions restricting access to reproductive care have and may continue to exacerbate them.”
The report looked at numerous indicators from publicly available databases and surveys, including maternal and infant deaths, rates of sexually transmitted infections and reproductive cancers, and intimate partner violence. Health care access and affordability data were also analyzed, including women who went without care due to being uninsured or being unable to access care.
The findings illustrate the consequences of a post-Roe nation on women and their families, especially as many state laws regarding abortion and reproductive health care are still rolling out, with unknown impact.
Read More
A 2021 paper showed the protections of Roe v. Wade reduced Black maternal death by 30-40%, averting 113 deaths the first year it was instated.
It looks like the same can be said for the reverse.
The Commonwealth Fund study linked the Dobbs decision that overturned Roe with deadly consequences for the pregnant people in states that upheld restrictive laws.
Mississippi, Texas, Nevada, Oklahoma and Arkansas scored lowest for reproductive health performance overall. Many of those states also had abortion bans.
Rates of maternal deaths were highest in the Mississippi Delta region, including Mississippi, Arkansas, Tennessee and Louisiana.
“All four states had abortion restrictions prior to the 2022 Supreme Court decision over returning Roe v. Wade, and they all now have full abortion bans,” said Sara Collins, senior scholar at The Commonwealth Fund, vice president for health care coverage and access and lead author on the study, in a news release about the report.
Pennsylvania scored below average in terms of number of abortion clinics, per 100,000 women, as well as for:
- Breast and cervical cancer deaths per 100,000
- Percent of women with a recent live birth without health insurance coverage during pregnancy
- Percent of women ages 50–74 with a mammogram in the past two years
To nab its overall ranking at No. 19, Pennsylvania was above average for health metrics including:
- Maternal deaths while pregnant or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy, per 100,000 live births
- Syphilis and congenital syphilis rates, women 15–44
- Percent of women ages 19–64 without health insurance coverage
- Percent of women ages 18–44 who reported needing a doctor but couldn’t afford one
“Looking across states and comparing their health care systems is an important way of telling us what is and isn’t working in American health care,” said Ms. Collins.
“The scorecard’s findings are deeply concerning and underscore the urgent need for federal and state policies to expand women’s access to affordable, timely reproductive care and other essential health services, regardless of who they are, what they earn, or where they live.”
A main concern for the study’s authors were maternity care deserts. According to the March of Dimes, 6 million women live in maternity care deserts: counties without hospitals or birth centers to provide obstetric care.
“Access isn't just about having coverage, it's also about being able to get to a service provider when care is needed,” said David Radley, a senior scientist with The Commonwealth Fund’s Tracking Health System Performance program and one of the study authors. “We looked at the adequacy of the maternity care workforce in each state and found that states with the most restrictive abortion policies also tended to have the fewest maternity care providers.
“There is concern among experts that abortion bans and restrictions may reduce the number of maternity care providers even further.”
Pennsylvania scored above the national average when it came to the rate of maternity care providers per 100,000 women. The state has also shouldered the burden of providing abortion care for patients traveling from surrounding restrictive states such as West Virginia and Ohio, previous data shows.
Instead of limiting care, legislators should work to ensure women have access to comprehensive health care, including reproductive care, said Laurie Zephyrin, The Commonwealth Fund’s senior vice president for Advancing Health Equity and study co-author, in the release.
Pennsylvania legislators are working on this. House Rep. La’Tasha D. Mayes, D-Allegheny, launched the Black Maternal Health Caucus last October, focused specifically on reducing Black maternal mortality and improving health outcomes for Black women throughout the state.
And a grant from the Benedum Foundation is expected to support the creation of a Wellness Index for Black women in Pittsburgh.
“Our hope is that these in-depth, state-by-state findings will help inform federal and state policymakers and health care delivery system leaders and their efforts to strengthen women's health and ensure that all women can get the health care they need when they need it,” said Ms. Collins.
Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.